The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad mini vs Apple iPad Pro

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPad mini.

Apple iPad miniApple iPad Pro
Owners with an opinion172643
Positive verdicts70% of 15664% of 549
Positive/negative since 202459/33150/111
Happy after 3+ years1141
Longest happy owner12 yrs10 yrs
Praised forportability and ease of useperformance and display
Criticized forperformance and softwaresoftware and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I use an iPad Mini every day (I’m on it, right now). I also have a big iPad Pro, that I never use. It’s likely that I will end up getting a Duo, eventually. I’m not in a hurry. I’ll bet that there will be teething problems. I suspect all my apps will run OK on Duos. I have been designing for flexible iOS screen dimensions since Day One (2012). It was a habit I already had, from MacOS development, and all my apps work in landscape mode (It’s shocking, how many apps you can break, simply by turning the phone 90 degrees). Looks like an open Duo is about the same dimensions as running an iOS app on Mac (by default—you can easily resize Mac iOS app windows). I am interested in seeing if I can leverage running on inside and outside screens. That might be interesting (but I don’t know if that’s possible. They probably switch off the outer screen, when the device is open). I’ll bet that Apple ships an Apple Pen Mini, for Duos.
Apple iPad mini: NeutralApple iPad Pro: Likes it
> People don't really think "my priority is 8.3 inches" I have 12.9" iPad Pro, my priority was thunderbolt and screen size, but mainly screen size (battery life is given on Apple devices). I also have iPad Mini where my priority was...bigger than the biggest iPhone, smaller than regular iPad. > The killer use-cases for tablets seem to be drawing and media consumption, but not only is drawing not a huge market, these two aren't at odds. Both are better with a better, bigger screen. It's like all-season tires, does not exceed in any particular field. I use my iPad for casual CAD with 3d printing in mind, it works great. I also use it as a bedroom screen on stand by the bed. Can two separate devices do a better job? Yes, but I don't need > For laptops the buckets are portability and performance. iPads not bucketed like this because you're not buying iPad for performance. > I think the iPad's lineup could be simplified to just one model, but I understand Apple want's to have several for marketing and price-ladder delineation, like it does with the iPhone Sure they can. This would lead to less overall sales. Right now 11" buyer have whole 3 feature set selections to choose from. I'd get rid of Pro, but not everyone needs 11" and Air features.
Apple iPad mini: Doesn’t like itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
> My Google Pixel 10 has both an in-the-screen fingerprint reader, and a Face ID, and I use both. They're both useful in different situations. That sounds great. > Some iPads have the finger print reader on the side of the device, on the power button. My main iPad is a Mini (latest gen). It has the Touch ID on the top. I find it to be a bit "flaky." It often misses prints. However, I think it works amazingly well, given that it's just a strip. I also have an iPad Pro, with FaceID. That works nicely. I like that it works in both portrait and landscape. That didn't happen in my older phones, but seems to be the case in my latest (17 Pro).
Apple iPad mini: Doesn’t like itApple iPad Pro: Neutral
I am in the same boat. I have two ipads, one is probably ipad mini 2 if I remember it correctly and another one is the first ipad pro. Ipad pro is still usable but not fully functional because I cannot upgrade the os and many apps dropped support for old os. Ipad mini on the other hand is totally unusable. I even think it’s in a better shape than the pro one. It feels snappy when navigating. But I cannot use it in any meaningful way.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I bought the iPad Pro 11 (M4) on its release day and did the same thing you did: throwing out what I knew to adjust to new paradigms. I regret its purchase. It is still fundamentally a device that cannot handle code-based workflows, although it's OK for some media creation. For software development, the canonical advice consists of excuses that rely on a "Pro" device to be a thin client. Remoting out to a workstation somewhere else defeats the purpose of having an M4 in the tablet itself. I can't even run a VM with native virtualization. A Chromebook with Crostini offers more functionality in this regard. You are also a consumer in another way: iOS revenue models are optimized for rent-seeking, whereas that is only partially true for macOS - even for Apple itself. As an example, I use Logic on the Mac and I pay for it once - Logic for iPad is subscription based. I don't hate the idea of the iPad overall - I have an iPad mini I use to read and mark up papers, and it's great for that.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Neutral
Ipad Mini is such a good size. My friend lent me his Mini2 when he borrowed money from me and used it for a good 6 months i think and it was marvelous. I didn't use it all that much but later got an Air 2 and used it maybe slightly less. Then I got an iPad Pro 11" but only used it for a while and don't really touch it too much anymore. I feel maybe an ipad mini I would use more. But the jelly scroll really has me urked and I kinda want OLED on it, so there is definitely room for a Pro version if they wish, but the iPads are overwhelming with 5 sizes already.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I have found the same as GP. I have an iPad Mini Retina (2014?) and an iPad Pro (2018). I once ran a test with both of them in airplane mode, and the Mini outlasted the Pro by a mile. My hypothesis is that the Mini still runs iOS, and the Pro runs iPadOS. I think I started noticing the Pro standby battery drain after "upgrading" the Pro to iPadOS, whenever that came out.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
Amazingly, my 2014 iPad Mini lasts longer on standby than my 2018 iPad Pro. Even with all optional stuff turned off (and no cellular antenna), the new Pro lasts about 2 weeks, while the old Mini lasts a month. I'm not sure, but I think the difference is that the old iPad can't update to iPadOS, which has worse standby performance. It's pretty frustrating to pick up the Pro after a week of standby and find the battery half depleted.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Neutral
I have been using my original iPad Mini since it shipped. I have not found a reason to upgrade it. I did get the MaxiPAD (iPad Pro) with the pen to use to draw and take notes however when I want to read or just in general, I use the Mini.
Switched from the Apple iPad Pro to the Apple iPad miniApple iPad mini: Likes it
Yeah, iPad Mini is great. I bought it a year ago and it replaced my iPad Pro 2018 which is too big to take out and hide often. I think iPad Mini is the ideal device for smart people. Only a little bit worse in performance, it can be seen when heated.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
The problem is they are both drugs and productivity devices. I have two iPads and I love them. I use a Mini exclusively for book reading and logging workouts. I use a Pro for video calls and occasionally YouTube videos. The addiction didn’t get me through them… on the other hand, here I am posting HN comments instead of doing something productive so it did reach me through my phone.
Apple iPad mini: Doesn’t like itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
Or MacBooks not having touch screens, or iPads being unable to run macOS / macOS apps even if you buy the $350 keyboard that gives it the same exact inputs as a MacBook, or iPads with modems being unable to place calls. There's all sorts of limitations that seem less like thoughtful design and more like holding back the devices just that bit to make you want another device. You can't just want an iPad Pro, how will you run desktop apps? You can't just want an iPad Mini, how will you call people? Well, at least the iPads can function as calculators now.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
But old iPads already work for yeeeears. My work ipad pro is 4 years old, and I can't be bothered to replace it (I can upgrade for free at work, at the 'cost' of having to migrate my apps and data etc...) My personal ipad mini 3 has been travelling with me until last year, as ebook reader. Sure it was heavily handicapped in the sense that I did not get app updates or any new apps really. But I still have my books and goodreader app, and still had VLC, and until very recently also netflix. That thing was 9 years old and I only retired it because work unlocked my work ipad so I only travel with 1 ipad now.
Apple iPad mini: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
N=1 but I am long time Android user going back to the Nexus era and bought an iPad Mini and iPad Pro entirely due to the USB-C switch when I wouldn’t have considered them before. I’m pretty committed to the Samsung ecosystem but a USB-C iPhone would actually make my next phone purchase competitive instead of Android by default. Having one cable to charge everything is too convenient for me to give up.