The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Air vs reMarkable

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple iPad Air.

Apple iPad AirreMarkable
Owners with an opinion180475
Positive verdicts69% of 14660% of 383
Positive/negative since 202459/26101/101
Happy after 3+ years136
Longest happy owner10 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityease of use and display
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usesoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Air: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
A Galaxy Tab or iPad is better in almost every way. I’ve used both the Tab S8 and iPad Air. Unless you’re outside or have some reason to need battery life for more than 9 hours of continuous use the remarkable is just a gimmick. Also be ready to pay monthly to keep your notes backed up and synced I bought the remarkable and regretted it so much.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I just use an iPad Air with Goodnotes (notes app) and Kindle (e-reader), in exactly the same way you use the Remarkable. These Remarkable tablets seem awfully expensive for what they provide, almost like "lifestyle gimmicks" like those minimal Light phones which cost as much as a smartphone. How people deal with distractions is largely on them, rather than the devices. People shouldn't need to buy a stripped down (but premium-ly priced) device. You can probably just take another product and configure it downwards (disable notifications, remove apps, set app timers) if focus is such an issue. "Feature packed" - remove apps you don't want, configure UI of what you do want. "prematurely obsolete" - Remarkable are already on a 2nd device. Who's to say there won't be a third, fourth, fifth? "demands way too much attention from users" - just turn notifications off.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
It costs even more , because they force you to sign up for their cloud service to get its signature advertised features, like handwriting recognition. $400, and then another $80 for the "marker", which does not have replaceable tips like every other company that makes a pen-tablet device. Apple, Wacom, Samsung, etc. So the opex is about $100/year, plus however often you need to replace the 'pen'. That's hitting $800 TCO for three years. Or you can buy a previous generation iPad Air and Apple Pencil and get a device that is far more capable, has replacement tips, a stylus that supports pressure and angle, etc. It baffles me that people start frothing at the mouth about Apple "forcing" people to use iCloud when damn near nothing on the device requires a paid iCloud account and there's pretty decent integration with open standards based systems... ...but the ReMarkable is basically PDF reader without their cloud subscription and HNers just can't shut up about how awesome it is? Oh, and then there's the shady-as-shit return policy. They basically don't have one...unless you buy the cloud service. Which you have to buy in a minimum 3 month block, and is non-refundable. Edit: apparently there are replacement tips.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itreMarkable: Likes it
I had an iPad Air, which I changed for a reMarkable 2 and I couldn't be happier! I see a lot of people here commenting about the limitations of it, and I get it. For me personally those limitations are features. My needs are mostly note taking and reading technical PDFs, and for that the reMarkable is fantastic. I used it extensively while taking Calculus, which, it was great to use as many pages as I needed and to write as big as I wanted without worrying about "wasting" paper. I miss background light from time to time, which I think is a great addition. I'm not super familiar with alternatives so I can't say that is better than X or Y, but I personally have been moving as much as I can to single purpose electronic devices. That allows me to be more focus and not fight my device wanting to distract me. That takes out every eInk table that has android for me, I don't want a yet another multipurpose device that I need to develop discipline to use it! On that line, I love my kindle, but that spends about 90% of the time in airplane mode, because, again, the kindle is for readin, the reMarkable for taking notes and reading Datasheets and such... But, that's just me :-)