The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Air vs Apple Pencil

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple iPad AirApple Pencil
Owners with an opinion18097
Positive verdicts69% of 14674% of 87
Positive/negative since 202459/2620/11
Happy after 3+ years130
Longest happy owner10 yrs2 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityease of use and performance
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usevalue and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Air: NeutralApple Pencil: Doesn’t like it
I was really excited for this - I’ve been saying to all my friends that I wish I could use my kindle for more. Obviously the kindle is quite slow so it’s not a good fit for reading on the web (I use Instapaper a lot and wish I could have that experience in eInk). I also read scientific papers and those often have figures that are very hard to read on a small black and white display, and I tend to scribble in the margins when I referee for conferences. For these tasks I use my iPad Air, but the eye strain problem is real if you’re reading for hours at a time. Since I bought a small laptop, I exclusively use my iPad for reading and writing. The writing experience could be better, with the surface feeling a little too glassy. My big worries are the app support. I use notability to write notes, which has OCR and allows syncing to my laptop and phone. My bookmarks sync across browsers. My reading list syncs with Instapaper and my citations with Zotero. Can I get a similar syncing system? Another perennial problem with such devices is the stylus. I’ve lost 2 apple pencils at conferences. It’s horrible - you now can’t write anything until you get a replacement. At least with an Apple Pencil you can walk into any store and pay the exorbitant $120 to buy a new one (imagine if you could never borrow a pen from anyone ever again and each pen cost over $100 - that’s what it feels like). How will I get a replacement pencil for this device if it falls down in an airport or out of my bag in
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple Pencil: Doesn’t like it
The on screen keyboard is really best in class if you have to enter text on a screen. For entering and editing larger text, I use a Bluetooth mechanical keyboard paired with my iPad. Dictation also works pretty decently (actually my preferred way of writing long text drafts). Really don’t see the problem with entering text (written on my iPad Air m1 with on screen keyboard)… Had 2 pencils, broke both within 1 week when they rolled of the table…
Apple iPad Air: NeutralApple Pencil: Likes it
> I really understand when I want to use the phone or the notebook computer. The iPad is sort of in the middle. I'd never seen it put that way before, but I think it hits the nail right on the head for me. I do like my 2020 iPad Air when I use it, and the pencil is great; however, I basically end up using it as easy scratch paper or when copy-pastable handwriting is useful. Plus when I need an extra screen to go with my laptop. It definitely has nice features, but doesn't feel like a compelling use-case overall, yet.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
I'm a note taker and I got tired of having hand written notes scattered all over and never being able to find the note I needed. So took a leap and purchased an iPad Air and an Apple Pencil 2. I carry it with me and make all my notes there. I use it way more than I ever imagined. I use the Paperlike screen protector to make it feel more like writing on a notebook. And it has all the added benefits of an iPad.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
I'm an app dev and I get access to most models except for Pixel. I usually buy a higher end Xiaomi/Poco phone, and iPad Air. Poco punches way above its price range. Gaming tier phones and a pretty screen for a decent price. 120 Hz screen, smoother video than my monitor, whole day battery life, charges to full in 10 min. Camera is good at night, and zoomed in. Macro camera can read the tiny text on money, the kind you'd need a magnifying glass to see. Downsides: lots of bloatware, camera claims to have a bazillion megapixels but doesn't scale in quality, probably sells my data to the CCP iPad Air is complementary to it. It's great for all "second devices" use, especially banks and auth if you have your main device rooted. Apple Pencil is amazing. I think most Apple stuff is overpriced and more style than function, but the Apple Pencil absolutely delivers on function. Also nice for signing business docs. The general iPad feels a little too big and heavy for casual use.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
This was me this year. Went from a Late 2013 MacBook Pro that was an OS behind to an M1 Pro Macbook and also went from a 1st Gen iPad Pro to an M2 iPad Air with Magic Keyboard and Pencil 2. Everything about the MacBook is better than its predecessor but I was particularly blown away by the iPad Air and the handwriting recognition. I put my 1st gen Apple Pencil in the drawer not long after buying the original iPad Pro and eventually sold it. Now I use my 2nd gen pencil every day and I’m even thinking of buying an iPad mini as a really portable digital notebook. I get the same pleasure again next year when I finally get to upgrade my iPhone 8 Plus. Battery life on my 8 is terrible now and it will get dropped from OS upgrades next year. I’m probably going to upgrade to a Pro Max because I’ve heard the current generation get 48 hours+ battery. But most exciting of all next year: USB-C!
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
I was a pretty staunch opponent of the iPad for a very long time. Tablets were clearly a consumption device, and I've always disliked Apple's penchant for proprietary connectors. However, things have shifted enough that on the artistic/creative front, the iPad is actually a really nice thing to have. When the iPad Air 4 (I think? The iPad ecosystem has terrible nomenclature) came out, it not only had a USB-C connector, but worked with the Apple Pencil 2. I did something I thought I'd never do - I bought an iPad. There are music & synthesizer apps that only make sense on a tablet, and they can talk with other music apps on the iPad pretty seamlessly too these days. And with the Apple Pencil 2, it's like a magic art pad. I've been sketching and drawing and 'painting' like I haven't done in 20 years. And I can charge it with the same cable that charges my Pixel 6, my work-issued Macbook pro, or my wife's Thinkpad's power supply. It certainly took long enough, but I no longer think that iPads are pure consumption devices. Now... would I try to use it the way I use a laptop? Oh, hell no.