The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Air vs Apple iPad Pro

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPad Air.

Apple iPad AirApple iPad Pro
Owners with an opinion180643
Positive verdicts69% of 14664% of 549
Positive/negative since 202459/26150/111
Happy after 3+ years1341
Longest happy owner10 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and display
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usesoftware and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Air: Recommends itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
Isn't the whole "raison d'être" of Apple to be able to do stuff that other computer company completely fail ? The surface make a poor tablet but that's mostly because the hardware isn't suitable for it anyway (because they lack the potential Apple Silicon has). It would be quite pointless for Microsoft to focus on tablet style software when the hardware wouldn't be able to make advantage of it and anyway, the touch layer they have on top is largely sufficient for most task you would want to do in tablet mode (especially since it is sold with a stylus and focus on that interaction method). Android would make a poor desktop OS as is, but Google is merging ChromeOS with it and there is Samsung Dex that is quite competent already. With the increased competitiveness of Qualcomm chips I think they'll attain a quite decent middle ground at some point. You say it would be a master of none device but isn't it what the iPad Pro already is ? Quite overkill for a content consumption tablet and too limited to be a full laptop replacement. This is particularly true for the 13 inch model, most use the 11 inch, which is kinda pointless for the price. Better to buy a cheaper iPad Air and a good enough laptop for the price asked. But really the hardware isn't the problem, it's all about the software that Apple willingly gimp, they could very well make a dual mode device with legacy support for "classic" Mac Apps and a way to suspend to swap when you go into full tablet mode. Most of the app in…
Apple iPad Air: Recommends itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
Office is a great use for a $350 regular iPad. Honestly the same one I'd recommend to developers, or worst case an $800 iPad Air for the 13" screen size. The $1000+ iPad Pro isn't helpful for any of that.
Apple iPad Air: Doesn’t like itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
What’s sad about the Air is that it’s only a 60hz screen. I’m spoilt now with 120hz on the first gen iPad Pro, the iPad needs it even more than phones (and they need it). So I’m not a demanding user in all other ways but the Air is not satisfying to me, yet.
Apple iPad Air: Doesn’t like itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
I don't understand the fluff about thin devices. I bought an iPad air a few years back and every time I picked it up the screen warped and I could see my fingers pressing through the back. I got a case for it thinking that'd help but I could still see it happen if I pressed hard enough. Returned immediately for the iPad Pro. I can't help but expect this would have similar problems AND it's Pro priced.
Apple iPad Air: NeutralApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I'm struggling to see why I'd buy this over a Macbook Air. I have an iPad Air. I use it a lot but generally just to watch Netflix or Youtube. I don't enjoy typing on it at all. I have the Air specifically because it's TouchID. I hate FaceID with a passion. But this update has pushed up the iPad Pro price well into the Macbook territory and that's a much more capable and flexible device.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Recommends it
Get the big iPad Pro. I got the iPad Air (10.86") for reading sheet music (piano and singing) and I love it, but after using it for a while I wish I had purchased the 12.9" Pro. Some people in my conservatory have it and it works great for them. I'll probably end up upgrading soon just so reading sheet music is more comfortable. And it is much cheaper than $2000 (It reaches almost $2k with the 1TB + Apple Pencil, but starts at like $1.1k). No dual displays though. I'm not sure if it qualifies as lightweight, but if you are referring to actual weight, it seems to weigh around half as the Yoga Book 9i and a bit more than double the Gvido sheet music reader... The Air weighs 1 lb and it feels fine when holding it up during a performance, the 13" Pro weighs 1.5 lb.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
USB-C would be nice but it probably won't happen until Apple is forced to do it. I have an iPhone 11 that is starting to fail so I guess its time to upgrade but honestly there's nothing feature-wise I can think that I need in newer models and it's been that way for years. One thing I wish they'd do is have Touch ID as an option on all iPhones, iPads and the Apple Watch. I absolutely hate Face ID. In fact it's ableist, often failing for people who through lack of normal vision have to hold their phones closer to see them. Just put a touch sensor on the back like the Samsung Galaxy phones used to (and still do?). But that won't happen. Still, I ditched a perfectly good iPad Pro (with Face ID) to buy an iPad Air (with Touch ID) but that one and only reason.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I bought a Magic Keyboard today for my 5th gen iPad Air and I have been playing around with it and Blink terminal and I’m really impressed with it and can see the iPad being a full MacBook replacement in a few years, presumably when Logic and Final Cut Pro make their way on to the iPad (they’ve got to do it now DaVinci is on iPad surely). Anyhow, I decided to have a look to see how much it would cost to upgrade to the 12.9 iPad Pro and a Magic Keyboard. To my astonishment, a 512Gb iPad Pro is now £1599 and an accompanying Magic Keyboard is £379. That means a full setup is going to set you back £1978. In comparison, a 13” 512Gb MacBook Pro with 8GB RAM is £1549. I understand that the iPad has a better screen and camera but I was still a bit taken aback that it was both £50 more expensive outright or £429 more expensive when you add a Magic Keyboard. Does anyone else think this is a little crazy?
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I don’t see anything you listed as requiring an iPad Pro. Most of what you mentioned revolved around note taking, which is a low cpu/gpu/memory task. You could easily do all those things on a iPad Air without stressing the device at all.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad Pro: Neutral
I currently use a latest-gen iPad Air. I used the iPad Pro before the redesign for school. Currently a lot of my friends use the device as a second screen because they're always traveling. Secondly, many content creators use it as a portable workstation because it works really well for certain types of editing. I personally prefer Lightroom on an iPad to the one on the computer. Lastly, it's my favorite media consumption device. I've been thinking of turning in my iPad Air for the newest iPad Pro because I want the improved screen.
Apple iPad Air: Doesn’t like itApple iPad Pro: Likes it
Recently I visited the Apple store and compared the latest 11 inch iPad Air (A14 processor) and iPad Pro (M1 processor) models side-by-side. I loaded up Apple’s website in Safari and scrolled. The Pro is noticeably butter-smooth, while the Air stutters. My iPhone also stutters in the same way, but it’s never bothered me before. It’s only after looking at the performance of the M1-driven iPad Pro that I knew to look for it. And I previously had a similar experience noticing how much smoother my iPhone was than my old Android phones! I don’t know for sure the processor is the difference, this is just a report of my observations.
Switched from the Apple iPad Pro to the Apple iPad AirApple iPad Air: Likes it
Note taking and Reading are my primary use cases. Goes without saying YMMV but it works for me. I had to hand down my iPad Pro 3rd Gen (the one with A12x Bionic chip) to my daughter for her school use. I got myself a 13" iPad Air (M2 chip) this time and Apple Pencil Pro (from Apple Refurbished store). The larger screen size isn't that much of a botheration as I thought it might be. On the flip side, the screen size is a lot closer to an A4 sheet and writing on it feels much better. I use Paperlike screen cover and pencil tips too. I don't have Netflix or YouTube installed on it. I only use it for Apple Books, Kindle, Notes and now Preview app is there as well. I might this time even use it as Sidekick and remote access IDEs running on my MBP but not sure if I want to do that yet on the iPad.
Switched from the Apple iPad Air to the Apple iPad ProApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
1. I do know what to do with it. I take notes, a lot, in my work as a doctor. That's been the case since I owned an iPad Air from 2020, which I replaced with an 11 inch M1 iPad Pro (which broke), and I finally caved and bought a 13" iPad Pro to replace it. I ended up getting the M4 model because there just didn't seem to be older ones reasonably available. Even the M1 was more than fast enough for the overwhelming majority of iPadOS applicantions. Why an iPad? Android tablets have been... not great for a long time. The pencil is very handy, and the ecosystem has the best apps. Also, I know a few rather handy tricks Safari can do, such as exporting entire webpages as PDF after a full-screen screenshot, that are very useful to my workflow. 2. I already own multiple general purpose computers. They're not as convenient as an iPad. My ridiculously powerful PC or even my decent laptop doesn't allow the same workflow. However, that's not an intentional software limitation, it's a consequence of their form factor, so I can't hold Microsoft to blame. On the other hand,Apple could easily make an iPad equivalent to a MacBook by getting out of the way. 3. The inability/difficulty of side-loading apps, the restriction to a locked down store. Refusing to make an interface that would allow for laptop-equivalent usage with an external/Bluetooth m+k. You can use an external monitor, but a 13" screen should already be perfectly good if window management and M+K usage wasn't subpar. Macs and
Switched from the Apple iPad Pro to the Apple iPad AirApple iPad Air: Likes it
Same, I actually bought a few of the Smart Keyboard Folios to use as they die. Upgraded to the M2 iPad Air, as I think it's the last of this form factor... It is just such a shame they discontinued the keyboard. It makes for the perfect iPad with a full keyboard.
Switched from the Apple iPad Air to the Apple iPad ProApple iPad Pro: Likes it
I actually can’t use Touch ID, at least year-round. I have naturally very dry skin, and no matter how much moisturizer I used in colder months, I had to constantly have it relearn my fingerprint, to the point where I would just give up and use a passcode instead. Face ID, on the other hand, has been flawless since my first phone with it in 2018 (minus some mask-related challenges during the pandemic). It and ProMotion are basically the two reasons I bought an iPad Pro over an iPad Air.
Switched from the Apple iPad Pro to the Apple iPad AirApple iPad Air: Likes it
This was me this year. Went from a Late 2013 MacBook Pro that was an OS behind to an M1 Pro Macbook and also went from a 1st Gen iPad Pro to an M2 iPad Air with Magic Keyboard and Pencil 2. Everything about the MacBook is better than its predecessor but I was particularly blown away by the iPad Air and the handwriting recognition. I put my 1st gen Apple Pencil in the drawer not long after buying the original iPad Pro and eventually sold it. Now I use my 2nd gen pencil every day and I’m even thinking of buying an iPad mini as a really portable digital notebook. I get the same pleasure again next year when I finally get to upgrade my iPhone 8 Plus. Battery life on my 8 is terrible now and it will get dropped from OS upgrades next year. I’m probably going to upgrade to a Pro Max because I’ve heard the current generation get 48 hours+ battery. But most exciting of all next year: USB-C!
Switched from the Apple iPad Air to the Apple iPad ProApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I was all in on GarageBand on my 2013 ipad Air, but finally was convinced to upgrade to a new M1 iPad Pro. I'm pretty upset about it. Garage Band is essentially abandonware at this point and things that used to work (like coreUSB midi) don't work anymore. Like, they broke it and don't care about fixing it. They'd rather I was using Logic, which doesn't have an ipad version (it has a nice controller app which is not the same thing). The app store is a joke, full of scammy ad supported junk. It used to have lots of very expensive (but extremely usable) apps. Now its a wasteland. I tried some of the DAWs and music production stuff and it all feels like windows 98 BS. I've switched to an old mac book and have given up on the pad as a moble production rig. SmartStrings on the iPad is a magical instrument. My brother recorded, produced, and mixed two whole albums on his iPhone while it effortlessly drummed along to his playing. What happened to the momentum that was there for iOS to be a useful professional production tool? Lol, and forget using that fancy M1 to compile anything ever 'cause iPadders arent allowed to use xCode.
Switched from the Apple iPad Air to the Apple iPad ProApple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like it
I tried switching from an iPad Air 2 to a 12.9" iPad Pro primarily because I wanted something larger to read PDFs with, and quickly discovered it was too large to be my iPad for everything else. So, I'm waiting for a refresh and then I'll decide whether I can justify having two iPads.