The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Air vs Apple iPad mini

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple iPad AirApple iPad mini
Owners with an opinion180172
Positive verdicts69% of 14670% of 156
Positive/negative since 202459/2659/33
Happy after 3+ years1311
Longest happy owner10 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityportability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and ease of useperformance and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Air: NeutralApple iPad mini: Likes it
Ipad Mini is such a good size. My friend lent me his Mini2 when he borrowed money from me and used it for a good 6 months i think and it was marvelous. I didn't use it all that much but later got an Air 2 and used it maybe slightly less. Then I got an iPad Pro 11" but only used it for a while and don't really touch it too much anymore. I feel maybe an ipad mini I would use more. But the jelly scroll really has me urked and I kinda want OLED on it, so there is definitely room for a Pro version if they wish, but the iPads are overwhelming with 5 sizes already.
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad mini: Likes it
Forget the dimensions and size on paper. I tried the iPhone 17 for two weeks, came running back to the Mini. Later on, I upgraded to the Air and I'm very pleased. Yes, it's slightly larger in hand but it's still delightful to use like the Mini. Even though its 25g heavier than the Mini, it feels lighter because it's less dense.
Apple iPad Air: NeutralApple iPad mini: Neutral
My iPad travel setups, from least-portable/most-functional to most-portable/least-functional: 1. iPad Air with iPad Magic Keyboard. 2. iPad Air with Smart Keyboard Folio. 3. iPad Mini (usually in portrait mode) with Magic Keyboard. (The mac bluetooth keyboard, no numpad. I use an sfbags sleeve for it.)
Apple iPad Air: Likes itApple iPad mini: Likes it
All of my non English speaking grandparents and great grandparents who are not familiar with computers were able to use FaceTime to video call with all the kids. And we tried with Nexus devices and non Apple solutions first, but the iPad mini and iPad Air is what worked to give them troubleshoot free, consistent ability to video call people.
Apple iPad Air: Doesn’t like itApple iPad mini: Doesn’t like it
i had a perfectly good Air 3 essentially die on me because the lightning port wore down and the hassle of getting it fixed was outweighed by getting a 5 with USB-C. same thing with my Mini 2 before that. touchwood, all of my USB-C devices have lasted perfectly well (including a Switch that is older than the Air 3). USB-C also puts a lot more of the stress on the cable, which is much easier and cheaper to replace, and (as pointed out in the event) the switch means you can use one connector for a wide variety of devices. i've long owned Apple devices (certainly iPads) and i'm only annoyed they took this long.