The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple iMac vs Apple Mac Pro

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple iMac.

Apple iMacApple Mac Pro
Owners with an opinion281162
Positive verdicts70% of 23467% of 124
Positive/negative since 202471/4242/18
Happy after 3+ years3318
Longest happy owner20 yrs17 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayperformance and reliability
Criticized forreliability and repairabilityvalue
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iMac: NeutralApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Having had a six-display setup for about 5 years, I agree. The Mac Pro made it quite easy to set up, too. Having separate (preferrably HD) panels, each dedicated to one window, feels excellent. For about half a year now, I've been using a 3-display setup centered around a large iMac. While the iMac display is nice, I kind of miss my old work flow. The iMac resolution is quite awkward, actually, because it's too small to split in two or four separate work areas, but at the same time it's way too big for just one window. There is really no good way to use that screen efficiently. So I often end up splitting it into two overlapping halves with a code window and some other window, but on the whole the setup is not as satisfying as the 6-screen.
Switched from the Apple Mac Pro to the Apple iMacApple iMac: Likes it
I basically buy everything Apple releases. So I've got an 8 core Mac Pro loaded to the hilt and.. it's sat in my shed unused for the past 9 months! Once the new 27" iMac came out, that was it. Perfect form factor, "fast enough", a far better screen than my 30" ACD.. so it turns out a machine half the price of my Mac Pro set up totally replaced it. And as there's no market for used Mac Pros, it seems, I now have a full Mac Pro + 30" setup sitting around entirely unused (and a 17" MBP - once I realized I don't really like or need a notebook).
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Every iMac, Mac Pro, MacBook Air, Mac Mini and MacBook Pro I’ve had (for me and family) has been indestructible. A few months ago Spotify on an ancient Intel Mac mini in the living room started complaining that the new version of Spotify is no longer compatible with that Mac. Then I ran Open Core and updated the MacOS to a much newer version, and Spotify is happy. Now I’ll get even more years out of that machine.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Well, I know exactly what you're saying, but to be fair to Apple, my 68K Mac that's nearly 40 still works. My iMac G4 is fine. PowerMac G3 is fine. First gen Mac Pro is fine. Meanwhile, the only PCs I know of that survive time quite as well (and I collect old crap) were all nearly equivalent to Apple level pricing at the time of their introduction. While Apple does charge nearly criminal markup for RAM and storage, they at least make some products that last (except for the TouchBar MacBooks' keyboards). I just hope my Mac Studio lasts too.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
I'm not sure why your iCloud account would stop working on old devices. I can still log into devices with Mac OS 10.11 with my iCloud account. Maybe because MFA was introduced a few years ago? But like the previous comment said you can use OCLP to install new versions of MacOS on "unsupported hardware". Usually you can go 2-3 versions of newer MacOS without any issue. Beyond that little things will start breaking, but it will still be functional. I run the newest versions of Sonoma on a 2010 iMac (that I upgraded to a quad core CPU, Metal capable GPU, and 32GB of RAM), a 2012 Mac Pro 5,1 (also upgraded to dual 3.46GHZ CPUs, RX 580, and 64GB RAM), and a 2009 MacBook Pro (SSD, and RAM Upgraded).
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like it
Value was the driving factor for some of my early hackintoshing (Core 2 Duo era), but what pushed me to do it from 2015-2020 was the abysmal state of higher powered Mac hardware. The Mac Pro was still the un-updated 2012 trash can, the 15” MBPs were too thin for the CPUs they housed (perhaps Intel’s fault for getting stuck on 14nm for so long, but still) and were hot with terrible battery life, and while the 27” iMacs weren’t terrible and probably the best of the lineup, they still weren’t cooled quite as well as they should’ve been. My 6700k + 980Ti tower in a Fractal Define case with a big quiet Noctua cooler was just flat better and made a far better Mac than anything Apple sold at the time. That said, I did eventually grow tired of the tinkery-ness of it all and in 2020 picked up a refurbed base model iMac Pro, one of the few Macs in that timespan that wasn’t a mistake, for about half its MSRP. It was about as powerful as that tower, surprisingly even more quiet, and of course just worked without the tinkering.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
This article is both excellent and brilliant. Lots of ideas... but one misnomer about Snow Leopard and 32-bit EFI. "You can force Snow Leopard 10.6 to use the 64 bit kernel by holding down the “6” and “4” keys during system boot. Likewise, you can switch back to the 32 bit kernel by holding down “3” and “2” during system boot. It may be stating the obvious, but the 64 bit kernel will not work on a machine that is not 64 bit." That is a CPU that is 64-bit, but an EFI that is 32-bit will boot Snow Leopard in 64-bit mode, and the 32-bit Snow Leopard and the 64-bit Snow Leopard will run 64-bit applications. The 2006 MacServe was the first 32-bit EFI to boot and run 64-bit Snow Leopard, and support 32GB of ram, and I have heard that every Intel Mac that supported Snow Leopard after that could also do it, but I only tried it on Mac Pros and iMacs, and a few Macbooks. The iMacs needed a 4GB SO-Dimm on the right hand slot, and it would both recognize 6GB and run applications that were 64-bit.
Apple iMac: NeutralApple Mac Pro: Neutral
This is true. I'm a developer (Clojure mostly) and: * I had a Mac Pro until 2016, sold it and used the money to buy a second monitor * I had an iMac 2019-2022, sold it because I bought an M1 MacBook Pro 16", which was faster Right now I very much enjoy a single-computer life, much less overhead. I anticipate I'll want to upgrade to an M3 MacBook Pro, but I don't see a need to use anything else, especially as the CPU (what I care about!) performance isn't significantly better in the Mac Studios or Mac Pros.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
I have some concerns about longevity of many of the current M1 machines. Yes, they have no moving parts other than keyboards (and fans in some models) which would be covered by AppleCare+ [1] so it would seem that you could keep on going a long time. However, one of the non-moving parts does wear out: the SSD. It is not clear to me from the AppleCare+ TOS if an SSD failing due to reaching its write limits would be covered. The TOS says it does not cover wear and tear, but I'm not sure if SSD wear falls under that or not. I like to keep computers a long time. I kept my 2008 Mac Pro until 2017, and only switched then because something I needed required the latest MacOS and 2017 was the year when the 2008 Mac Pro stopped getting the new major MacOS releases. I'm now only considering replacing the 2017 iMac i got then because the display has developed a vertical line of bad pixels. If not for that I'd be staying on it for another few years at least. The SSD in my iMac is still around 98% after over 4 years and so seems like wear won't be a problem, and it is replaceable with some difficulty (OWC calls it an "advanced" repair and suggests having a pro do it). But I've got 64 GB in the iMac. I don't think I've ever seen it touch the SSD for swap/paging [2]. I'm worried that on many of the M1 Macs that would not be the case. All of them except the Studio and the 14/16" MacBook Pros top out at 16 MB, and I've noticed on my iMac that I'm usually using between 16 GB and 28 GB. I've wat
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Interesting. I wonder if this is because it has really sucked in the last 6 months and this is some sort of hail mary? I have 2 machines with the latest VMware Fusion on it. An iMac (Intel) and a Mac Pro (2013). Both ran all versions of macOS flawlessly until a few months ago. Big Sur and Monterey have massive issues. I couldn't install from scratch anything Monterey. I had random hangs, installing new macOS guests. Just so many issues. It forced me to try Parallels Pro and I found it works fine. I'm in the process of switching over.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like it
Annecdata: I was editing a movie in FCPX on my 27" iMac (Intel) w/64 GiB and it kept crashing. Reluctantly, I restarted on my 13" MBA (M1) and finished with no problems. Granted there might have been something specific to my circumstances, but I was very impressed with the performance on the lowest-spec M1 laptop. IMO, the M1 laptops are fairly priced, but the Mac Pros have been poor value in the past. I'm really curious to see if that changes.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Two reasons. First: I have 2x30" screens. I don't want to go down. Second: I can't put multiple HDDs and SSDs in an iMac. The new system replaces a 24" iMac I bought in 2008. It made it for 5 years; the only upgrades were extra RAM when new and swapping the HDD for an SSD about 2.5 years into its lifetime. I don't know how long I'll keep this one. Under Australia's small business equipment rules, it's already fully depreciated. So there's no accounting purpose to hold onto it if I don't want to.