The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple iMac vs Apple Mac mini

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple Mac mini.

Apple iMacApple Mac mini
Owners with an opinion281823
Positive verdicts70% of 23474% of 626
Positive/negative since 202471/42267/94
Happy after 3+ years3339
Longest happy owner20 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayperformance and reliability
Criticized forreliability and repairabilitysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Recommends it
I've bought several iMacs (2008, 2012, 2014, 2020) Anyway, it is frustrating once they aren't supported anymore. I think they are overbuilt, they are built to last forever but designed to be obsolete in 7 years. ChromeFlex has saved a few from recycling at our house (A chromebook with a retina display seems like such a waste) I suggest spending a bit more and getting a mac mini and a studio display instead (Equally well built but can be used almost forever). If you could only (easily) use them as monitors once they went out of support...
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Neutral
Actually you can use them as external displays but requires some hackery. See https://ohmypizza.com/2023/04/converting-a-5k-imac-into-an-e... But yeah agree entirely there. When upgrading from my somewhat cranky old 5k iMac a while back, I decided I'd never buy another iMac. The 24" was out. So I bought a Studio Display and a mac mini. At least I can upgrade the computer separately, which has happened already (M2 mini -> M4 mini). I expect the Studio Display to last a long time as you can actually buy parts for it.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Likes it
It's wild but my own issue free MacOS era was OS9 on my iBook G3 clamshell. Had to replace a harddrive (bounced down a stairwell, but held together) and upgraded the ram, but other than that fine experience. My next Mac was a 2008 Macbook Pro (non-unibody) that had backlight issues out of the box, failed display cable two years in, and then the GPU failed. (Nvidia plague era, and Steve Jobs silence plague era of shit-ass fan curves) To this day I still refuse to trust Apple's fan curves and install fan control software. Especially the M1 iMac with the cut down graphics that they only gave one fan and a smaller heatsink. Watched it break 100C regularly. The m1/m2 mac mini might be the only one I've never had issues with the stock fan curves so far, but I still bump them up anyway for peace of mind. I don't see a reason to let an SoC hit 98C even if its rated to do so.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Likes it
I stopped using a laptop long ago. A Mac mini is cheap, fast, and I have a big monitor. An iMac display went dark, and the whole thing needs repair. Same deal for laptops. Modular is great. Not to mention all the ports, and the fact that hubs and external drives hide behind the monitor, not needing to be taped to the laptop lid.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Likes it
I could never justify getting an iMac. All the downsides of a laptop & desktop in one; not upgradeable and not portable. Leaves me wondering how many of these Apple actually sell. A Mac Mini with a separate screen feels like it makes far more sense.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac mini: Neutral
I've got so much perfectly-working e-waste from Apple. It's so sad. I'm on a Late 2014 Mac mini that's stuck on Monterey macOS 12 and a Late 2014 retina iMac that's stuck on Big Sur macOS 11(!!) An iPhone7 that's stuck on iOS15. The display on that iMac is still IMO second to none. These computers do everything I need, yet their software support is stuck back in time. And 3rd party developers are terrible about supporting previous version of macOS. They alway seem to assume you are running the latest and greatest, and deliberately remove support for earlier OSs. Hell, I have an O.G. iPad 1 that still works perfectly as it did the day I bought it, but most of the built-in software no longer works, and the App Store is basically empty. What a sad state of affairs.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Neutral
I opted for a M2 mini and 27” display. I just expand the usb-c and usb ports. Bonus points: full size Logitech keyboard (I need the lights. Apple only lights the laptop keyboards and the magic one for the iPad that I know of) The forward delete key is super handy. I got a usb-c card reader, which works with the iPad as well. The iPad and magic case is my laptop. Why do I like modular? The display on the old iMac quit, meaning that the whole thing goes in for repairs.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Likes it
They are both fine. I got an M2 mini with base disk and memory. The ancient 27 inch iMac had a 7200 rpm terabyte disk and more memory, IIRC, and this $600 computer laps it in every way. ( The display quit and I may yet have it fixed ) A great reason for modular computers. I've had a lot of mini's over time. I store all I can on external SSD's. (Sneakernet is the fastest network of all, but I don't currently use it) Most people do prefer all in one's of course. I stopped using the 2010 or so MBA. Still works. The iPad Pro is my laptop, with keyboard, trackpad and third party mouse. I use it for musical scores and showing off photos from the Nikons pretty exclusively. Size and portability matter. For these two uses, a laptop configuration is less suitable for me. Desktops and laptops are still hundreds of times more efficient and useful to me than any mobile OS. Even with the gamut of goodies. If your mom upgrades so infrequently, it's like cars. The newer model will obsolete later. My phone and some other systems fell off support, and can't get software upgrades. (Other than Linux, of course) I suspect that's the rationale, even if the M series all seem interchangeable. Or maybe it will run out of horsepower later, as software gets even more demanding. I doubt that she'll need to count cores and GPU's.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac mini: Doesn’t like it
Early 2010s iMacs are extremely underpriced, given their high quality screens and generally good hardware - you can get 27" models for $300ish and ones with retina screens for maybe $400. I stumbled across a jealousy-inducing low price on a late model with very minor cosmetic issues recently and am still pinching myself. But with these machines so cheap, I have contemplated picking up a second lower powered one just to mess around with, install different Linux distros etc. I presume this is because so many Mac users are moving to the M-series CPUs and away from Intel, though I haven't done a detailed comparison with Macbook and older pro models. Mac minis still seem overpriced (to me, but after building computers for 30 years I feel entitled to be opinionated). Any it won't last forever so if you have ever wanted the nice Apple hardware but were put off by the steep prices now is your opportunity. I went for an iMac because I wanted a machine that looked nice and was nearly silent, though to my surprise I am enjoying MacOS much more than I expected.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac mini: Doesn’t like it
The KSP reference, probably not well expanded, was in comparison to the 2018 Intel Mac Mini I had previously, which basically could not play it - it was barely livable with graphics turned all the way down, because Intel Integrated Graphics on that era Mac Mini suck (I don't think it even had the eDRAM cache). KSP ran fine on my 2014 iMac with discrete graphics. It absolutely did not run acceptably on the 2018 Mac Mini, and it ran wonderfully on the ARM M1. But, no, the post was not satire. Not sure why you would think it was. It was trying to, very soon after the M1 came out, work out some concrete ways to do Linux VMs and such, and playing with performance.
Apple iMac: Recommends itApple Mac mini: Likes it
iMac 27" Retina, 7 cores, 32 gig ram, 2 TB drive. This is, bar none, the best computer I have ever owned. Finally, a zippy and powerful workstation that is a pleasure to use. My old Mac Mini served me well for 8 years, but after a couple of OS updates, it had become laggy and nearly unusable.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac mini: Doesn’t like it
I have 3 macs. One of them is an older iMac. I can't put enough RAM in it to run Mavericks (which is a memory hog). It is a perfectly good computer, there is no reason to upgrade from Lion. The next one is a 3 year old Mac Mini. I upgraded to Yosemite and it performs TERRIBLY. It has 16G of RAM. I've tried everything. Yosemite just sucks. The machine is now much slower than the 6 or 7 year old iMac with only 4G or RAM. If it was practical to back out to Mavericks I would. The last one is a 2 year old Macbook. I rely on it for my job. There is no way I'm going to risk the crappy Yosemite performance to upgrade. I'll live with the security flaw. Here is what I now know about Apple: They will not support you for the lifetime of the product. They consistently release buggy code these days. Unless you are willing to shell out more money for new hardware every time they come out with something new, you will be stuck "as-is (with bugs)" until you get rid of it. No more Apple anything for me. I'm thinking I'll switch the Mac Mini to Ubuntu if I can get it to work there. I'll use the iMac until it doesn't work any more, and when my Macbook is ready for an upgrade (in another year or two), I'll be trading in that still-Mavericks based system for a Linux laptop or maybe I'll go back to Windows.
Switched from the Apple iMac to the Apple Mac miniApple Mac mini: Likes it
I have an M1 MacBook Pro 16" I've had for almost two years and it's great. I recently got a minimal M1 Mini to replace an ancient iMac that died. the mini is really good as well. For my money these are the best computers I've had. Overall very happy with the Apple ecosystem (phone, watch, TV, etc). I do think their fees for upgrading memory and disk are crazy. I use an external SSD as the disk for the mini. I also have an OpenBSD Thinkpad (very old), an old desktop with Arch Linux, and a newer desktop with Windows 11. The MacBook is 95% of my computing time though.
Switched from the Apple iMac to the Apple Mac miniApple Mac mini: Likes it
For me it's been mostly painless. I've even used Time Machine to migrate from a 2012 Intel iMac to an Apple Silicon Mac Mini and it worked perfectly! The two pain points: 1. No support for running older virtualized macOS. I like to test back to 10.9 and need an Intel Mac to do that. 2. One Python wheel which doesn't have Apple Silicon builds and doesn't build cleanly: https://github.com/CoolProp/CoolProp/issues/2003
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac mini: Likes it
The thing that makes older iMacs "disposable" is that the required cooling vents end up [mostly] blocked, within just a few years – then they thermally throttle, until death. If you open them up and keep them clean, they can have uses forever : ---- My 27" iMac (2009) still sits faithfully alongside my main 48" setup (because I own the copy of CS4 installed upon it – FU Adobe!). It mostly plays background shows (while I work on main computer, adjacent). My 24" iMac (2006) still sits faithfully on my tax desk, for its annual usage/filing. It also still plays Warcraft 3: Frozen Throne (quite well!). ---- >I suggest spending a bit more and getting a mac mini and a ... display, instead This is fantastic advice; my past two Apple's have been Mini's. My three main machines all connect to the same massive 48" display (that is about to outlast its first retired Mini). The only new iMac I would ever again consider purchasing would be something on-par with the iMac Pro (2017) – but in 2026+ any iMac would need a 32"+ display (minimum) to be "usable" IMHO.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Doesn’t like it
Apple is extremely dumb with power management and power supply. That's because they pretended to innovate all the way back at the start and want to pretend, they still have the expertise. But I have had 2 iMac power supply die one me, the grounding problem on a MBP and a major annoyance with power noise leaking from a Mac Mini (makes for some nasty audio output, hilarious when you consider they supposedly target creative who clearly need good audio output). You always find people raving about Apple's engineering prowess but my experience is that it's mostly a smoke show, they make things look good, miniaturise/oversimplify beyond what is reasonable and you often end up with major hardware flaws that are just a pain to deal with. They always managed to have good performance and a premium feeling package but I don't think their engineering tradeoffs are actually very good most of the time. As far as I can tell, the new Mac Mini design still has grounding issues, and you will get humming issues, which is beyond stupid for a product of that caliber. At this point I don't care about having the power supply inside the dam box, just use a brick if you must to prevent that sort of problem. This is particularly infuriating since they made the iMac PSU external, which is beyond stupid for an AiO. But common sense left Apple a long time ago and now they just chase specs benchmarks and fashionnable UIs above everything.
Apple iMac: Likes itApple Mac mini: Likes it
Every iMac, Mac Pro, MacBook Air, Mac Mini and MacBook Pro I’ve had (for me and family) has been indestructible. A few months ago Spotify on an ancient Intel Mac mini in the living room started complaining that the new version of Spotify is no longer compatible with that Mac. Then I ran Open Core and updated the MacOS to a much newer version, and Spotify is happy. Now I’ll get even more years out of that machine.
Apple iMac: NeutralApple Mac mini: Neutral
I’ve got a MacBook and Mac Mini stuck on Monterey (12), and an iMac stuck on Big Sur (11). I’m pretty much dead in the water when it comes to software compatibility, unless I want to put Linux on them. Even homebrew gives me a warning that they’ve stopped support and to expect everything to break. It’s a sad state of affairs.
Apple iMac: Doesn’t like itApple Mac mini: Doesn’t like it
I have a macbook pro, an imac and a mac mini that are all in good working order and in use for various things but they all have the same problem: They can't run the latest macOS because they're too old. So, my wish for any new macOS is support for older devices. That won't happen because it makes little commercial sense so instead I plan to install linux on them all but I haven't gotten around to it yet.