The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple iBook vs Apple MacBook

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook.

Apple iBookApple MacBook
Owners with an opinion402608
Positive verdicts56% of 3661% of 2254
Positive/negative since 202411/10718/459
Happy after 3+ years1161
Longest happy owner5 yrs18 yrs
Praised forreliability and batteryperformance and reliability
Criticized forrepairability and performanceease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iBook: Likes itApple MacBook: Neutral
When it come to anecdotes... I've got a powerbook and an ibook both still alive and kicking after close to 5 years and apart from the battery that I had to replace, they haven't had any problems (despite using them a lot)... On the other hand my 2 years old macbook is starting to make some strange sound (the fan probably needs to be changed)... I think that anecdotes are only that and in my experience once you have a problem with a laptop it's usually going to be more than one problem...
Apple iBook: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook: Likes it
But here's the problem: How many people do you know who have Apple products also raved about them? Or had no problem? I can come up with a huge list of my friends that have problematic Apple products. But if I gave it some consideration, I could also come up with an even longer list of friends who've had almost no problems with theirs as well. Yes, I've had to go through the trouble of having my retarded iBook G3's logic board replaced multiple times. But I can counter that with my three MacBooks being perfect until I sold/traded them off. The one I have now has had no problems. My second MacBook had a power adapter that died after one year, but nothing else. Et cetera.
Apple iBook: Likes itApple MacBook: Likes it
Battery life deteriorating is only a pain point because they make it so users can't trivially service the battery themselves. It is amazing seeing the walk back over the years from sensible affordances to the consumer to binning those features behind expensive repairs. I still remember my ibook where you could pop out the keyboard with your fingers and pop out the battery with a dime. I remember when they released the unibody macbook and they gave you a simple clasp to access both the battery and the hard drive as they were anticipating consumers shifting to SSDs in the near future in 2010 and wanted to offer an affordance. Slowly that went away. The latch went away for a dozen small screws that are easy to strip and lose. Eventually the ability to change out the drive or the battery yourself went away too. Slippery slope of setting up user expectations for a worse version of the product in a few generations from certain standpoints. Sure it is faster but imagine if it was faster and also as serviceable as devices used to be. There isn't good reason for it other than to gouge you when you spec out your macbook at rates that are always at a convenient premium over today's prices for these hardware.
Apple iBook: NeutralApple MacBook: Neutral
A bit of a collection my wife wishes wasn't so much of a collection. - M1 Macbook Air base model (Usual daily driver) - Lenovo Ideapad S340 (For testing stuff on windows) - Macbook 2007 (all white polycarbonate, kind of my main Netbsd machine) - iBook G4 (Eventually want to take on the crazy project of writing an OS for it) - A dell netbook (can't remember the exact model, for any odd purpose that fits the day) - Mac mini 2009 (serves as a little test server, running NetBSD) - Raspberri Pi 4B (FreeBSD)
Apple iBook: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
The Macbook was a fragile piece of shit, much like the iBook that proceeded it...though the iBook wasn't just fragile, it was also a lemon. Both were built down to a price and it showed, including the creaky, flexing, cheap frame. Dropping the "cheap, shitty version of a Macbook Pro" line was an excellent decision on Apple's part.
Apple iBook: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
> it's frustrating that they took so long to "do the right thing." Par for the course. I was bit by logic board problems on the dual USB iBook (2002 model), which eventually got covered under a similar warranty extension. Then I had to pull teeth when my MacBook's plastic discolored in 2006.