The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods vs Sony WH-1000XM

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Sony WH-1000XM.

Apple AirPodsSony WH-1000XM
Owners with an opinion1024214
Positive verdicts54% of 89465% of 180
Positive/negative since 2024210/15445/27
Happy after 3+ years134
Longest happy owner8 yrs6 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilitynoise and sound
Criticized forsoundease of use and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
It's not just Shazam but any app that uses the mic over Bluetooth. Like if you wanted to have background music playing during a Zoom call, or wanted to wear Bluetooth headphones while gaming and voice chat kicks in when you group up, etc. It's a very annoying problem because the Airpods actually sound fantastic, but as soon as the mic kicks in, it sounds like crap. Same thing happens with my Sony XM3s or any other Bluetooth headset. The protocol drops to a shitty bitrate to support full duplex.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I have a low end Bose bluetooth speaker that connects up instantly to any of my powered on devices (2x Macbook, iPhone), and can switch between them seamlessly with a button press. I've also never had any issues with Sony WHM1000XM* headphones regarding bluetooth across these devices. My AirPods frequently hop between my MacBook and iPhone without asking though, because the other device played a split second audio clip. Strong YMMV I guess.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
My 1000-mx3 headphones have garbage cancellation compared to my AirPods. I live next to a busy street and can hear everything with the Sonys on. With AirPods, I thought we were having an earthquake recently but it was just a car with very loud music. I had to remove my AirPods to realize that.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Not to sound like a paid Apple marketer, but I think there's a distinction between wireless headphones and using AirPods with an iPhone. It's not like it's a herculean effort to use wireless headphones with a standard bluetooth connection, but it's enough of an awkward series of moves that I never enjoyed it. But I have to give Apple credit that AirPods (with an iPhone) just work way more seamlessly, to the point where the idea of quickly tossing them in and out of my ears isn't an annoyance. If I'm playing a video game and I want to listen to a podcast, I pop one into my ear, press play on my phone and I'm listening. When I'm done I simply put it in the case and it disconnects and is charging. I have a pair of Sony XM3's but as soon as I got the AirPods I basically never touched them again.
Apple AirPods: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I hope so too. I disabled touch controls on my WH-1000XM3 (the over the ear type) because an accidental swipe would rewind or skip to the next item (e.g. videos on YouTube). When I have to adjust the earbud version (WF-1000XM3) it's really easy to touch the controls on accident as well. Even the Airpods Pro that I have can be touchy when adjusting because they have sensors to pause when you take them out and resume when you put them back in (great feature) but they also sometimes pause (or unpause) incorrectly depending on the situation. (I just realized that is an option that can be disabled so I'm torn about disabling it now. Single click does pause and unpause as well.)
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I hope these are better for calls. We've debated banning AirPods at my workplace because the mics are so awful. I tried AirPods but eventually landed on the new Pixel Buds, which are incredible. Sony's WF-1000MX4s are good too, and I'm still using my Bose QC 35 II as daily drivers (pun intended, I guess).
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I've daily driven the xm3's and the xm4's for years and their multi-device support is so bad that it literally makes it worse than not having it at all. I explicitly disable multi-device support for them because the headphones will randomly jump around for seemingly no reason at all making them entirely unusable. Apple's bluetooth headphones, assuming you are living exclusively inside of the apple ecosystem, are the only bluetooth headphones that have multi-device support that is actually functional. If you chain your xm4's to a single device then they work pretty much flawlessly but that is also way less convenient.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
Sony WH-1000XM4s I'd say are the most comparable in terms of ease of use and pairing well. I haven't had any dropout problems with them like I have with others (including my gen 3 airpods). I use my AirPods for my phone/tablet and my XM4s with my 2020 Mac Mini.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I’ve got the extremely well regarded Sony WH-1000XM4s. Getting them to switch between devices is an absolute pain in the ass compared to Apple’s fairly seamless handoff. The custom Bluetooth processor seems to be letting Apple solve a lot of pain points that every other Bluetooth headphone just makes you live with.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
The only feature the wideband chip provides is the device switching and pairing, which is largely redundant with multipoint Bluetooth spec and NFC, respectively. I'll appreciate what Apple did ergonomically, but I found the "smartness" of Airpods to be less reliable than using my XM4s connected to both the devices I was using. I understand the layman's struggle here, but I honestly think most people's bad experiences with Bluetooth were in the < v3 era, where things like multipoint hadn't been introduced and reliability/pairing were... shaky. Nowadays, I think any phone running Android 10+ or Linux device using Pipewire has the best wireless audio experience I can think of. You can have high-bitrate audio codecs with excellent latency and a connection that's as good as the antennae you have plugged in. AAC and the funnel of buying U1 chip devices doesn't really put up enough of a fight, especially for a company that's long prided itself on delivering quality audio experiences.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
Safety features in headphones seem rather lacking in general. Noise cancellation tech especially is prone to causing these sudden loud tones if you somehow manage to cause a feedback loop. I fell asleep with WH-1000XM4s once soon after getting them and was treated to deafening feedback at a very unreasonable amplitude. Returned them. Apple has actually been the exception there, not only do they limit the amplitude, they also detect feedback loops (also often caused by trucks backing up) and stop noise cancelling until the source of feedback is gone.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
The automatic switching feature is a failure, honestly. I have never gotten it to work as it should across any of their AirPods models. Also, the mic on the original AirPods were best-in-class when they came out, but they have since been bested by many other offerings (from Jabra, Sony, and others). The AirPods Pro were worse than a pair of Master and Dynamic MW30s I briefly had (which was surprising, since they are niche headphones), and they are definitely worse than my current Sony WF1000XM4s that I have now (which is even more surprising, since the mic on the WF1000XM3s were not good).
Apple AirPods: Recommends itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Owning Sony XM4s, Galaxy Buds Pros, Bose QC, and Airpods Pros: that's an extreme take. All of these devices "just work" and "don't just work" in nearly the same ways. The microphone quality is a tin can on all of them. Among my friends in Discord, anytime someone logs on with a shit mic the meme is "dude are you using airpods?!" They usually are. Or any earbeans. Because they're all bad. The AV desync is an equal issue on both of them. BT headphones are basically useless for any realtime application (think: playing a digital piano). This may just be me, but: I have no idea what the "automatic device switching" airpods feature is. I have a Mac. I have an iPhone. If I want to switch my Airpods from iPhone to the Mac, I have to go to the bluetooth menu in the toolbar, and click the Airpods on the Mac... just like the XM4s. To go back, I go into the bluetooth quick settings menu and click Airpods Pros. Its exactly the same. Like, ever since they announced this feature, I feel like either the world entered a collective psychosis on what this feature does, or I'm getting old and I'm missing something, but its exactly the same (and, not that bad; exactly how many steps I'd expect to switch an audio output device). The Airpods are certainly very nice during the initial pair process, but that's a one-time thing on both devices. The scary part to me is: the APPs do have slightly better UX on Apple devices. And it isn't just the value-add features like "automatic" switching and spat…
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Having cycled through WH1000XM3, XM4, AirPods Pro, I am back to my trusty Shure SE215 that I use wired. — They never deafen me with connected/disconnected sounds (which can never be configured quiet enough) or music briefly playing at insane volume after switching or connecting. — I know I get the source quality. — I would never lose one randomly (always a chance with “true wireless” models). — I don’t get weird phased low-frequency rumble from active noise compensation gone wonky. — Most of all, their passive noise suppression with Shure’s black sleeves, depending on exact noise profile either beats or is on par with top-of-the-line active isolation (both according to rtings’ test benches and my subjective experience), and does not end when battery runs out inevitably at the most inconvenient time. Addendum: 1) I connect them via a tiny Ikko Zerda DAC, which I started using way back when I still had a phone with a headphone jack (this is subjective, but with lossless sources I hear more detail—as in literally small instrument parts I didn’t hear before in complex arrangements—compared to built-in DAC). 2) I generally pass the wire under the top layer of clothing, and personally taking an earbud out and letting it dangle is about as difficult as switching on the transparent mode on AirPods (and without audio degradation inherent to such modes).
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
Annoyance 1 - you can configure auto-connect per device. I have three computers and an iPhone that have been paired with my AirPods. I only have my iPhone configured to connect to my AirPods automatically. Annoyance 2 - since you hear the "connect" tone when the AirPods connect to a device, my guess is the author's AirPods have connected to a device they are not looking at. This is what was happening to me before I realized the auto connection was configurable. Annoyance 3 - this happens for my other Bluetooth headphones that have a microphone when using Mac OS as well. It's a Mac OS issue. I've noticed with a recent update that it happens less frequently. The fix is to set the audio output to the computer speakers, then back to the AirPods. Annoyance 5 - yeah, switching takes time. Based on my experience with Bluetooth devices, I'm not sure how much this is AirPods specific. I ended up buying a pair of the Sony WH-1000XM4 headphones because they can connect to two Bluetooth devices. This solved the switching delay, with the caveat that the mic on the WH-1000XM4 is not great so I also bought a cheap USB mic for meetings.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Recommends it
Commuting/Daily: Apple AirPod Gen 1 (~220AUD at the time) Office / Airflights: Sony WH-1000XM3 ($350AUD) Others: MH40 for home listening / PC, Grado SR215E for Open back listening at home with Jazz etc. AirPods for general day to day travelling when I'm not using a backpack. The Sony 'cans' for noise cancelling and concentrating and added Bass. Previous Earphones/Headphones: In the last 5 years * Bose QC35 - Rubbish sound quality for a pair of 300+ headphones. Active Noise cancelling is very pressured, hurts my ears. Microphone picks up EVERYTHING! Do not recommend * Shure SE215 - Great sub $200 in ear canals with great sound quality. I broke mine cause I stepped on them, decided to go wireless. * RHA T20i - Great sound quality but the rubber on the earlets broke. I replaced them twice, was to expensive to send to London each 12 months so I gave up on them. Too expensive for this design flaw. * Master and Dynamic MH40 - Look cool but heavy and expensive. Sound quality doesn't justify the price Recommendation: The Sony WH-1000XM3 is the bee knees!
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I used to obsess over audio quality. But then I reached my 40s, and it started to become clear that my ageing ears were becoming the limiting factor. Now I just embrace the convenience of Bluetooth and usefulness of noise cancelling. (But then again, even my AirPods or Sony XM4s are high fidelity compared to what many of the kids these days are listening with, small mono bluetooth speakers or playing music out of their phone speakers)
Apple AirPods: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
Using AirPods with an iPhone really is great. The annoying thing is my Sony WH-1000XM3 headphones connect to a Google pixel very similarly to how AirPods connect to an iPhone. I wish that pairing process were more open on iPhone because it really does improve the Bluetooth experience, which is otherwise dreadful compared to the simplicity of a headphone jack. It would have been nice to see Apple add that feature and the headphone jack back with this update. They’ve captured the wireless market. Now give us a standard connector again.