The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods vs Sennheiser Momentum

Hacker News owners lean toward the Sennheiser Momentum.

Apple AirPodsSennheiser Momentum
Owners with an opinion102415
Positive verdicts54% of 894100% of 13
Positive/negative since 2024210/1544/0
Happy after 3+ years130
Longest happy owner8 yrs–
Praised forease of use and reliabilitysound and ease of use
Criticized forsoundreliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSennheiser Momentum: Likes it
>I didn't say they did but the Airpods are essentially best in class for this Best in class are the Bose QuietComfort Ultra, (wireless is optional for the overears, as is should be in such a product). Sennheiser Momentum 4 (wire also optional for the overears) are also a very good alternative, maybe not as blocking as the Airpods, but the sound is probably better, more "natural", but that is a personal taste after all. Comparing only the ear buds, Airpods are the less forgiving with the ear fit of the three models, they clearly prioritized aestetics before ergonomics. The point is that there were excellent NC options before the Airpods, and almost nobody gave a fuck about the technology. Suddenly Apple "invented" the tech for the masses, and now nobody can't live without it, to the point that you are a cavemen if you are not using them. They never were the best, they are just another ones. Kudos to Apple for good marketing and brand positioning. Incidentally, I can't use regular ear buds for long without them moving around and losing a lot of sound quality. I have in-ear monitors custom made, and they still move and pop out sometimes. I tested the Airpods my sister has (the ones without silicone tip), and they simply don't do the work because they don't seal enough unless you push them with your fingers.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSennheiser Momentum: Likes it
I always had issue with in-ear phones passing some of the friction down the ear canal. Sure over the ear ie kosses work flawlessly, but then I have to carry usb-3.5mm conversion kit all the time (and keep forgetting and then having useless headphones), no premium non-chinese phone with good camera has the port anymore. And I have small kids, so good, I mean the best on the market camera always with me is a must I will thank myself later for, as does/will all my close family. As for airpods, I don't get the hype, but thats mostly true for any Apple announcements apart from their CPUs. Yet they have the capitalization they have so they are doing something right, athough it feels its mostly marketing and "we are US" which means nothing to Europeans for good reasons unfortunately... I prefer higher quality customizable phone who respects me as user, higher quality cameras on it, higher quality in ear buds (even relatively mediocre Sennehiser Momentum 2 TW sounds miles and lightyears better, last longer, use HD codecs with anything ever created that has it too, which now means tons of devices, and pair flawlessly so far). I saw first hand my boss struggling and failing repeatedly to even pair his (back then) brand new Iphone 13 pro max pair with out-of-box charged airpods pro. WTFs all around the office, he was so ashamed... It was not the last time we all saw it from front seats, still happens quite regularly. My wife has Garmin fenix watch. Apple watch are a bad joke if you have…
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSennheiser Momentum: Neutral
Oh yes. Colleague has latest iphone 13 pro max, and latest airpods pro. Even this basic apple-apple setup is failing him numerous times, and you would expect this pair to be tweaked to perfection for that price. Conf calls where he had to give up pairing attempts and had to do it via phone. I could understand busy office space interference, but he has same issues at home. I have Samsung S22 ultra and Sennheiser momentum 2 buds. Pairing works 100% anywhere immediately with aptx (unfortunately they don't support HD variant of codecs). But if I do press play, first 1-2 seconds the music is some ugly skipping. I would rather prefer it to be quiet for longer.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itSennheiser Momentum: Likes it
I did, and went with S22 ultra at the end. Long term nikon full frame shooter. I must say both iphone 13 pro max and this are very formidable devices, each has their strengths and weaknesses, took quite a bit of time to decide. I like how S22 feels like a real computer where I can plug my variometer for paragliding via OTG cable, side load apps of my own choice, use normal charging cables like rest of the universe, upload/download files straight from filesystyem without any installed apps and so on. I am getting into whole S pen experience, its pretty nice for sketching or precise mouse-like work ie when editing photos in phone. Apple notch making it look like some basic 2015 chinese phone is just a cherry on the top. As for cameras, 10x physical zoom is not something to neglect, Apple doesn't have anything to offer there. In past 2 weeks I have it, I've shot quite a lot of otherwise impossible kids, family, nature, animals etc. pics with this zoom. That was my main motivation for new phone - a camera for pictures I always have with me, unlike dedicated camera (2.5kg being just a detail, I didn't mind carrying it but I didn't have it a lot of casual times where great situation happened). Another reason that swayed me - with this upgrade I wanted to improve headphones, priority being quality of sounds and battery life to play my collection of flacs. Airpods Pro were just not cutting it, went with Sennheiser momentum 2. You can't connect iphone and Senns via some above-defaul…
Apple AirPods: NeutralSennheiser Momentum: Likes it
+1 to the Koss Porta Pros, and their cheaper sibling - the Sporta pro. They both sound fantastic, and are cheap. They do leak sound quite a bit - people standing in a bus next to you will know what you are listening to. I've also loved the Sennheiser Momentum II wireless over-the-ear head phones. They sound fantastic, but are expensive. Their noise cancellation works well enough. They look great, feel great and sound great. I am now going through a set of wireless Bose QC35 (series II). They are decent. They sound like a generic set of headphones, nothing to complain about, but not really good enough to get excited over. The active noise cancellation is buggy - severely distorts my audiobooks at times and I have to turn the noise cancellation off and on again to make it go away. I also always carry my airpods - they sound ok, but feel very liberating. I'm strongly considering upgrading to airpods v2, but I've spent a bunch on headphones already :-) Not looking to spend any more money on headphones.
Switched from the Apple AirPods to the Sennheiser MomentumSennheiser Momentum: Likes it
Sennheiser's Momentum True Wireless are really, really good. A significant upgrade from AirPods. The first two generations were notorious for connectivity glitches, but the TW3s appear to have fixed everything by. Great ANC, battery life, ear fit. They even added multipoint through a free software update that came out about a year after launch.
Apple AirPods: Likes itSennheiser Momentum: Likes it
I have two versions of Sennheiser Momentum, but I decided to “trial” the AirPods Max by buying them with the intent of return, because they’re over half a grand $$$. After literally minutes of use, the thought to return them evaporated just as quickly. Pretty much all because of the seamless connection. To be fair to the Sennheisers, they are durable: they survived contact with a wall at least twice.