The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods vs Bose QuietComfort

Hacker News owners lean toward the Bose QuietComfort.

Apple AirPodsBose QuietComfort
Owners with an opinion1024265
Positive verdicts54% of 89476% of 229
Positive/negative since 2024210/15440/21
Happy after 3+ years1319
Longest happy owner8 yrs15 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilitynoise and comfort
Criticized forsoundreliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
>I didn't say they did but the Airpods are essentially best in class for this Best in class are the Bose QuietComfort Ultra, (wireless is optional for the overears, as is should be in such a product). Sennheiser Momentum 4 (wire also optional for the overears) are also a very good alternative, maybe not as blocking as the Airpods, but the sound is probably better, more "natural", but that is a personal taste after all. Comparing only the ear buds, Airpods are the less forgiving with the ear fit of the three models, they clearly prioritized aestetics before ergonomics. The point is that there were excellent NC options before the Airpods, and almost nobody gave a fuck about the technology. Suddenly Apple "invented" the tech for the masses, and now nobody can't live without it, to the point that you are a cavemen if you are not using them. They never were the best, they are just another ones. Kudos to Apple for good marketing and brand positioning. Incidentally, I can't use regular ear buds for long without them moving around and losing a lot of sound quality. I have in-ear monitors custom made, and they still move and pop out sometimes. I tested the Airpods my sister has (the ones without silicone tip), and they simply don't do the work because they don't seal enough unless you push them with your fingers.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
Even new, they had nowhere near the noise cancellation of my old Bose QC20i. AirPods are disappointing, but convenient. I guess that's why we buy them.
Apple AirPods: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
Not much. My Bose QC's made me nauseous when I started using them. I acclimatized to a degree but only ever use them in flights. And they "sound" weird compared to eg. covering my ears with my palms. Also tried AirPods Pro and didn't like the feature (or the amount they stick into your ears); swapped for the cheaper / older model which I love.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
agreed. until bluetooth earphone batteries can go for a few days between recharging, and can quick charge in, say, 15 min or so, I'll keep my wired. I also have AirPod Pros, but I keep my Bose qc20 around and still find myself using them multiple times per month when the APP go low (never get more than around 3 hrs from them).
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
I hope these are better for calls. We've debated banning AirPods at my workplace because the mics are so awful. I tried AirPods but eventually landed on the new Pixel Buds, which are incredible. Sony's WF-1000MX4s are good too, and I'm still using my Bose QC 35 II as daily drivers (pun intended, I guess).
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
Interestingly enough that's what I miss about my Bose. The in-ear QuietComfort earbuds I had were _far_ more comfortable (and stable in my ear) and the noise cancelling was so far ahead of my AirPods Pro that you wouldn't even consider the two devices in the same genre.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
I am just curious how are people dealing with EMF radiations emitted by AirPods? I have 2 sets of AirPods and Bose QC35 but I stopped using AirPods altogether and I use QC35 using the wire. NIH study: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6701402/
Apple AirPods: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
I had the Bose QC35 IIs and had the exact same issue. My work laptop was in sleep mode and still they decided to keep connecting to it. I had to either open up the mobile app, wait for it to do its stuff and force a disconnect with the laptop OR get up, walk to the laptop, open it, turn off BT and close it again. Ordered AirPods Max and I've had pretty much zero issues since. I can walk from my computer to the TV and Apple TV will prompt me to connect to it with one button. I can grab my phone, walk away and the headphones will move to the phone automatically. Magic.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
That's odd. I have a pair of airpods pro shared with an m1 mbp, and an iphone. The airpods seem to randomly connect to 1 of the 2 devices, almost never the one I want them to connect to. This is the same experience I've had with other BT devices. The only good BT experience I've had is my Bose QC35ii headphones, which can connect to multiple devices at the same time.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
sounds more like this is on Apple which systematically designs their bluetooth devices such that they exhibit uncooperative interfacing. f.x. my airpods won't connect to my Linux notebook (Sony, Bose - all work). my iPhone won't connect to my TomTom navi (various Android smartphones - no problem). same for hotspot settings which refuse connection from Android. Apple is a digital bully. furthermore I am using a Logitech MX Anywhere 3 mouse via bluetooth and at the same time use either Bose QC35 or EarBuds also via bluetooth. no problem. so that's that ...
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
I thought this was a satire. It looks like this is not. I like the fact that the author loves experimentation and tried this setup. I'm someone who still thinks Apple has not even solved the design of the AirPods/Pro. So, anything else that makes us like "Batman with a utility belt" is something I would find a more aesthetic alternative. For most of the video call needs, I have tried boom/condenser and XLR microphones. Right now, an XLR is the best that stays away from my desk (mounted on an extended arm) while I continue to keep a desk Microphone as a backup. The last resort is the trusty Bose Quietcomfort 35-II. While on the move, a wireless bud such as the AirPods would be OK. I have been working remotely since the early 00s, and have used the early Jabra Bluetooth with phones, and now, if I can take back that flaunt, I would. These days, I drive past busy social hangout areas or visit diners with the family; I see people wearing AirPods or AirPod-like knockoffs as an always-on ornamental addition even while not talking (on phone). My brain always cries in silence, "Batman." I don't see this throat mic fitting in any sensible scenario, and from the article, the ROI of audio quality over anything else is not worth the roll-eyes that will you will gain from your audience. Nonetheless, I would love to try this with a walkie-talkie in the jungles when I'm working with the planters for the natural decarbonization projects I'm involved with.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Neutral
Makes sense to me. The audio quality isn't good. You never seem to know what they are going to decide to connect to a different device. I had a pair, when the battery died I decided not to replace them. They are an environmental mess as well. I use Bose QC35 headphones via Bluetooth at the gym to listen to music. A Blue Snowball iCE for podcast type things. And wired, in ear headphones (from JBL) with a microphone on the cable for everything else.
Apple AirPods: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
Airpods are the only BT audio headset I have that can easily and consistently switch audio. Haven't had any reliability issues. I can't get my Sony MX3's switch devices without removing and repairing. My work Bose QC35's says it's connected to both, but won't switch devices - it tries connecting, then fails and reverts to the last paired device.
Apple AirPods: Recommends itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
Owning Sony XM4s, Galaxy Buds Pros, Bose QC, and Airpods Pros: that's an extreme take. All of these devices "just work" and "don't just work" in nearly the same ways. The microphone quality is a tin can on all of them. Among my friends in Discord, anytime someone logs on with a shit mic the meme is "dude are you using airpods?!" They usually are. Or any earbeans. Because they're all bad. The AV desync is an equal issue on both of them. BT headphones are basically useless for any realtime application (think: playing a digital piano). This may just be me, but: I have no idea what the "automatic device switching" airpods feature is. I have a Mac. I have an iPhone. If I want to switch my Airpods from iPhone to the Mac, I have to go to the bluetooth menu in the toolbar, and click the Airpods on the Mac... just like the XM4s. To go back, I go into the bluetooth quick settings menu and click Airpods Pros. Its exactly the same. Like, ever since they announced this feature, I feel like either the world entered a collective psychosis on what this feature does, or I'm getting old and I'm missing something, but its exactly the same (and, not that bad; exactly how many steps I'd expect to switch an audio output device). The Airpods are certainly very nice during the initial pair process, but that's a one-time thing on both devices. The scary part to me is: the APPs do have slightly better UX on Apple devices. And it isn't just the value-add features like "automatic" switching and spat…
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
>After several years of usage, my first two pairs of AirPods both developed a buzzing noise which became unbearable. The only solution I found was to buy a new pair. Is that really acceptable for premium headphones? My Bose QC25s continue to work fine after almost eight years of daily use. I realise that there's more which can go wrong with the AirPods, but two (?) years isn't much at all. The author should've taken the issue further rather than just giving Apple more money.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Neutral
I have the same headphones and the main issue I have with it is their multi-device support is pretty much broken for me. If I'm on a zoom call and I get a phone call on my other device it takes over the audio (as expected), but then if I decline the phone call the audio doesn't switch back to my zoom call (computer). I end up having to turn the headphones off and back on for them to reconnect, which actually takes a good 10-15 seconds at least. The Bose QC35 I had before handled multiple devices way better, unfortunately they just didn't sound as good as the Sony.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
Yea I went wired at the beginning of the pandemic, QC-35 wired with a wired antlion mic, works like a charm. 3 main reasons I went with this setup : 1- Reduce the audio lag (bluetooth comes with a noticeable lag in video conferencing) 2- Not having to worry about battery life (going wired vastly improved the QC-35 battery life) 3- Keep the stellar comfort (at least for me) of the QC-35. I personally don't understand why people endure the sucky audio quality of bluetooth handset profile. Couple this with a very ordinary battery life for airpods (I don't care if it charges in 10 minutes, when it's out and you need it you're stuck), I don't understand why this product is so popular.
Apple AirPods: NeutralBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
My only other bluetooth headset is a set of Bose QC35s. As sibling comments reported, quality is about par overall. I find UX of Bose is worse on all counts when working with multiple devices. And the battery life of my AirPods is less on a single use, but much better overall considering I can recharge in the case. My airpods, generally, also have to put up with more. I don't use my Bose with my phone or on the go which is, generally, where the AirPods experience 90% of their quirks. That makes for a poor sample size though so would absolutely love suggestions for more reliable alternatives. Edit: apparently I don't know how to spell Bose
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
I'm only an indirect user of AirPods and I really do not like them: Every time my team does a google meet / hangout the folks using AirPods sound terrible to the point that it's distracting. I don't know if it's in the microphone, the bluetooth connection, or the interaction with a google product, but it is much worse than (a) wired earbuds and (b) the folks using Bose QC 35s (which the company gave out a while back)