The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods vs Apple EarPods

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple EarPods.

Apple AirPodsApple EarPods
Owners with an opinion102448
Positive verdicts54% of 89484% of 43
Positive/negative since 2024210/15426/3
Happy after 3+ years133
Longest happy owner8 yrs21 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilitysound and value
Criticized forsounddurability and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itApple EarPods: Likes it
I compared the mic quality of Airpods Pro 2, Airpods 4 ANC (similar), and freebie Apple 3.5mm wired earbuds. The earbuds won. My limited research suggested either 1) compression and transmission take a lot of power, so the Airpods don't do as good of a job as something with a bigger battery can afford to, 2) the mic position is worse, or 3) Bluetooth doesn't have enough bi-directional bandwidth for two good signals.
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itApple EarPods: Likes it
Anecdote, I like wired headphones for important online calls. I use earpods[1], I started using them back when they came with a phone, I'm happy that it's still possible to buy replacements. I like having a reliable wired connection that works and disconnects predictably. I guess a lot of that is nostalgia. My laptop model no longer has a webcam cover or a physical network switch; connecting and disconnecting the trrs[2] cable reminds me of these. But some of that is still practical needs. I have AirPods and Bose wireless headphones, both praised for reliable connections. Every now and then they take a bit longer to connect or the volume changes unpredictably, or they need to be charged, etc - when wired headphones just work. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_headphones#EarPods [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phone_connector_(audio)#TRRS_s...
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itApple EarPods: Likes it
Wireless microphones in general suck. Dankpods has a good video[0] comparing a few Airpods models to the Earpods, and it's obvious that the fancy Airpods beamforming mics are no match for the small tumor attached to the Earpods. My understanding is that wirelessly transmitting and receiving audio data is hell on your Bluetooth bandwidth, so most headphones will switch codecs to playback and record at the same time. AFAIK, Airpods will switch between SBC and AAC depending on if your mic is getting used.
Apple AirPods: NeutralApple EarPods: Doesn’t like it
I recently did the same thing, although I picked up a 6th gen iPod Classic. A few things I've noticed: 1. Battery life is insane, even though this thing is more than 10 years old. I've always laughed off complaints about phone/smart watch battery life because charging daily doesn't seem like a chore but it is really nice have a battery that will last a week or more. 2. Syncing is so slow (I'd forgotten how slow) but not too much of a frustration given I'm on a computer all day anyway. 3. Having a device without the internet is really nice. No distractions other than the 3 arcade games on the device which are a trip down memory lane. 4. The UI is shockingly laggy. Scrolling with the click wheel stutter a lot as it tries to read from the HDD. Maybe I have a bad device? I'm not sure as I always had flash iPod's in the past. 5. iTunes still exists and as I've built up a 'large' library through it over the years I still use it - however Apple isn't selling their lossless or Atmos content through it. The latter doesn't matter much but it's a shame I can't get the lossless tracks I can get through Apple Music. 6. EarPods SUCK. I bought a pair just to get the full iPod experience. I use a range of headphones but mostly use AirPod Pro's these days. EarPods sound tinny, fall out and are just generally bad. Weirdly, I used to really like them but I guess things have gotten much better in the mass market headphone scene over the last decade. 7. Shuffle mode is fantastic. Because you've p…
Apple AirPods: Doesn’t like itApple EarPods: Neutral
I had AirPods since the launch day. The battery was not great to begin with and they decayed pretty fast. After that they're basically trash as replacing the batteries is about as expensive as buying new ones. I'm back to EarPods now. Don't listen to music on my phone anyway.
Switched from the Apple EarPods to the Apple AirPodsApple AirPods: Likes it
I’ve seen people minimize the usability of the AirPods. My dad who’s quite technology-averse, figured it out in 2 minutes while I helped him over FaceTime. The only reason he agreed to even try it was because the wired EarPods broke. Since then he just loves his AirPods.
Switched from the Apple EarPods to the Apple AirPodsApple AirPods: Likes it
I thought I’d be using the adapter but my Apple headphones that come with an iphone are collecting dust for like two years now since I got AirPods. Not going back, couldn’t care less about headphone jack. Now I wish charging port was gone too now just to push the industry even further.
Apple AirPods: Likes itApple EarPods: Likes it
I have the same issue with ALL earbuds. Long ago after seeing a comment recommending silicon "hookz", I found them on ebay for $1 and gave them a try. They've kept my earpods and airpods in even while running and dancing. My current pair has worked perfectly for years. I've never tried the over-the-ear version. This is one example of the style that works for me: https://www.amazon.com/OneCut-Pairs-Silicone-Compatible-AirP...
Apple AirPods: Likes itApple EarPods: Likes it
I used AirPods and loved them, but have gone back to wired EarPods plus Shure IEMs. I’m happy with this combo, perhaps because I don’t use earbuds very much. Plus, the EarPods’s mike is much better than wireless earbuds for calls.
Apple AirPods: Likes itApple EarPods: Likes it
Hard disagree on 6. I bought my first pair of AirPod Pros a few weeks ago after being a diehard EarPods users for a nearly decade. I still use my EarPods while biking, but now use the the AirPods for everything else. Obviously, they can't compete on features like ANC, but I think the EarPods sound quality is superior and the controller is more reliable than using "Hey Siri" on the AirPods. Also, I guess we have different ear canals, because neither set falls out of my ears. Plus, EarPods are freaking indestructible. Mine look like hell, have been through hundreds of hours-long summer rides in high humidity, soaked in sweat and just as many winter rides in subfreezing temperatures, and they are still going strong. No matter how well I take care of my AirPods (which cost 10X the price), I can only expect to get two or three years out of them.