The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods Pro vs Sony WH-1000XM

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Sony WH-1000XM.

Apple AirPods ProSony WH-1000XM
Owners with an opinion477214
Positive verdicts56% of 41965% of 180
Positive/negative since 2024156/9845/27
Happy after 3+ years174
Longest happy owner6.5 yrs6 yrs
Praised fornoise and soundnoise and sound
Criticized forreliability and comfortease of use and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods Pro: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I'm curious whether Apple has addressed the tinnitus issue of its ANC technology (or some part of it). I couldn't use neither AirPods Max nor AirPods Pro (1st generation) because they were making my tinnitus noticeably worse. I have no such issues whatsoever with my Sony WH-1000XM4 and a few other ANC headphones I've used.
Apple AirPods Pro: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
And everyone got mad at OpenBSD for refusing to develop bluetooth. It’s a messy standard and we shouldn’t be surprised that the race to the bottom has left some major gaps.. though Sony WH1000’s are premium tier hardware and they have no real excuses.. I always wondered how people could justify the growth of the bluetooth headphone market in such a way.. Everyone seems to use bluetooth headphones exclusively (in Sweden at least), I’m guilty of buying into it too (I own both Airpods Pro’s and the affected Sony WH1000-XM5) but part of me has always known that bluetooth is just hacks on hacks… I allowed myself to be persuaded due to popularity. Scary. I was also trying to debug bluetooth “glitching audio” issues and tried to figure out signal strength as the first troubleshooting step: I discovered that people don’t even expose signal strength anymore… the introspection into what’s happening extends literally nowhere, including not showing signal strength … truly, the whole thing is cursed and I’m shocked it works for the masses the way it does.. can you imagine not displaying wifi signal strength?
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Out of curiosity, what issues have you had with them? (I'm not at all involved with their development, just a fellow user of them). I had the Bose and Sony ones. They were OK, just uncomfortable. Been using the in-ear Airpods Pro for a few years now, for everything from work to flights to trains to exercising, and I love them soooo much... they're probably my favorite tech purchase ever (and I don't even have an iPhone). Pairing is always a pain in the ass (I just manually pair again with every device I want to switch to) but other than that, they've been so nice. Personally, I'm not an audiophile, but I find the audio quality incredible (vs my Sonos speakers, wired Koss PortaPros, generic soundbars, Sony XM3 and Bose QC35s, etc.) and the comfort unbeatable. But some people hate the in-ear kind. Anyway, not trying to convince you of anything, just wondering what made your experiences so different and bad?
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
That's nice anecdata. Got a pair of FiiO earbuds - works after 5 years Got a pair of Skullcandy earbuds - failed within a month Got a pair of Sony WF-1000XM5 - failed within a year Got a pair of AirPod Pro2 - works after 2 years Got a pair of Beat Fit Pro - failed within a year Got a pair of Moondrop Blessing 2 - works after 2 years I can keep going for a while. Aren't all of these assembled in China? The Chinese meme strong is strong with us.
Apple AirPods Pro: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I ended up giving my airpod pros to my partner. I found both the connectivity and sound quality (as well as noise canceling) much better on my Sony WF-1000MX4s. edit: isolation replaced with canceling
Apple AirPods Pro: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I disable the multiconnect on my XM4s as well. They switch based on what's currently sending signal, but one has to stop broadcasting first. It disables LDAC support anyway if you use that. I was torn between the XM4s and Airpods Max but ultimately am tired of picking up more Lightning connector devices. I will no longer purchase things that don't charge via USB-C. I use my XM4s daily as well for over 1.5 years now (Jan 2021), and have to be in my top 5 things I've bought in my life that I feel were worth every dollar. I'll be buying the XM5s on launch day. I also had a pair of Airpods Pros, they're so close to being the perfect single pair of headphones for everyone. But they hurt my ear canal with anything but the small tips, and then they wouldn't seal.
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Yeah, I like my AirPods Pro precisely because I don't need to disconnect them from the previous device to connect to them from the next device. Bose NC 700s and Sony XM4s both have the problem where I need to disconnect from them on an old device before I can connect to them on a new device.
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
I have the QC35 and the WH-1000XM3. The Sony have punchy sound. If you're a bass head, you are going to love them. The application that goes with them also gives you a lot of control. However, after playing with all the settings for a few days, I found myself not touching them ever again. For noise cancellation on airline flights, the Bose do a better job. Even after adjusting the Sony to the aircraft pressure level. Maybe the Sony are better at canceling other people's voice, but they are not as good as the Bose to cancel the noise of the aircraft engine. The Airpods Pro also do a surprisingly good job at canceling the noise of the engine. During my last flight, I used the Airpods Pro and the Sony on top of them. Not very comfortable, but noise cancellation was amazing :) When it comes to comfort, the Sony tend to hurt the top of my head after a while. The Bose are more comfortable.
Apple AirPods Pro: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I have both the Bose QC-35 ii and the Airpod pros. The Bose have better noise reduction. Plus, if you really want total quiet, you can wear earplugs underneath the Bose. The Airpod Pros are good but the physical noise isolation isn't that great. The rubber tips in Etymotics are far superior. Even my Jabras had better physical noise isolation than the Airpod Pros. My friend has the Sony WH1000XM3, so I got to play around with those. They have slightly better noise cancelation than the Bose. However, the Bose are more comfortable to me because they rest around your ear instead of on your ear like the Sony's.
Switched from the Apple AirPods Pro to the Sony WH-1000XMSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
The WF-1000MX4s are absolutely PERFECT with the sole exception of the non-tactile controls. If they replaced the touch sensors with actual buttons, they would be the best earbuds on the market.
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I have both a pair of the over ear Sony XM4’s and AirPods Pro 2 and I’m not sure I’d characterize the Sony’s sound as “better”, even when using lossless audio. They sound good but the sound profile is mostly just different, with the Sony’s leaning more bassy and the AirPods more balanced. The noise cancellation are neck and neck but the AirPods had much less of that “pressure” sensation when using it. AirPods transparency is just plain better. Comfort for long use sessions is better on the Sony’s. Mic is better on the AirPods.
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
The two brands that could have a claim to producing "the model that everyone says are the best" are Bose and Sony. For Bose, the QuietComfort Ultra are the top of the line, but the cheaper/older QuietComfort 45 and 35 are both good too. For Sony, the WH-1000XM4 is the consensus favorite, even though the XM5 is newer. I own the XM4 and the older XM3 and I prefer the XM3 because I like the way it sounds with nothing playing better. I don't know how to describe it but the "silence" of the XM4 with ANC on but nothing playing feels too artificial for me. For office use, though, I prefer the XM4 since it has bluetooth multipoint and I can use them easily with both my laptop and phone without mucking around in settings. I'm changing jobs and going from having my own office to hoteling desks, so I imagine I'll be wearing the Sony's a lot more and I'm not sure if they'll be comfortable enough for all day use. At home or on a plane, I usually need to give my ears a rest every hour or so. I'll give one of the Bose a shot if I can't deal with the Sony's all day. Apple is also very popular. I haven't tried the new AirPods with ANC, but I love the Pros. I have to fuss with them a bit to get a good seal, and they don't stand up to city or airplane use, but they're fine in a relatively quiet environment, and they're so small I pretty much always have them on me. I have no experience with the Max, but from what I've read they can be uncomfortable for some people.
Apple AirPods Pro: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
In my experience my Airpod Pros and Huawei Freebud Pros achieve 95% of the audio and noise cancellation quality of my Sony XM3s that I just barely use the big headset anymore. I understand that they are technically different categories of products but for me and a lot of other non-audiophiles I know switched to TWS earbuds once they got half decent ANC.
Apple AirPods Pro: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
> I think Apple wouldn't ship this if it wasn't a very, very good AR headset For heaven’s sake, Apple has a laundry list filled history of releasing half baked and subpar products - both hardware and software - and has been reliably consistent at doing that. I mean it’s just that its “target audience” sets their peak of standard what Apple expects them to, or to just what Apple offers. I have been using their AirPod Pro 2 and I have also tried one by Jabra and Samsung (along with XM4 and 700 - I own(ed) these two) and my goodness the noise cancellation and call quality, in even slight noise, is atrocious. That’s just one example — don’t even get me started on their software and services suite.
Apple AirPods Pro: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
The automatic switching feature is a failure, honestly. I have never gotten it to work as it should across any of their AirPods models. Also, the mic on the original AirPods were best-in-class when they came out, but they have since been bested by many other offerings (from Jabra, Sony, and others). The AirPods Pro were worse than a pair of Master and Dynamic MW30s I briefly had (which was surprising, since they are niche headphones), and they are definitely worse than my current Sony WF1000XM4s that I have now (which is even more surprising, since the mic on the WF1000XM3s were not good).
Apple AirPods Pro: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
I do feel fatigued after, but, I think, not for the reasons you expect. I noticed that when I take out either airpods pro with ANC or my WH-1000XM headphones (the first gen), I feel uneasy and overwhelmed, with some ringing. But then I realized it wasn't due to ANC, it was due to all that constant noise around me. So if I went without that noise for an hour or two and then got introduced back to it, it takes me a solid minute or two to get adjusted. All those random noises, like water moving through pipes, wind outside, air conditioning, etc. become super noticeable and end up just overwhelming me by being introduced back all at once. I've been observing this kind of stuff for a while (had my WH-1000XM headset for over 2 years), and I got better at adjusting back over time. But i still get those shorts periods of time immediately after, when that noise ends up flooding back and just making me hyper aware of it.