The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods Max vs Sony WH-1000XM

Hacker News owners lean toward the Sony WH-1000XM.

Apple AirPods MaxSony WH-1000XM
Owners with an opinion130214
Positive verdicts55% of 12165% of 180
Positive/negative since 202444/4445/27
Happy after 3+ years24
Longest happy owner5 yrs6 yrs
Praised forsound and noisenoise and sound
Criticized forcomfort and reliabilityease of use and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I'm curious whether Apple has addressed the tinnitus issue of its ANC technology (or some part of it). I couldn't use neither AirPods Max nor AirPods Pro (1st generation) because they were making my tinnitus noticeably worse. I have no such issues whatsoever with my Sony WH-1000XM4 and a few other ANC headphones I've used.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
> to the point of being fairly uncomfortable after listening for any longer amount of time. #1 reason I use the Sony XM4/XM6. Sometimes I wonder if they intentionally do this to appeal to a younger crowd cause as an older person with neck issues it’s just not a very good product. The audio quality of the Sonys is just as good but the comfort is a much better. I think I like the mic on the AirPods Max better but the mic on the MacBook I use in meetings works as well for meetings.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
Yeah, no joke. For bald people like myself these headphones are unusable once the mesh stretches enough that the metal bands touch your skull. I could go 30 minutes before the discomfort made me have to take it off. No such issue with the WH-1000XM6, I can wear it the entire day.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I bought the AirPods Max 1 but had to return them because they felt like a vice and were too heavy. I ended up going with the Sony wh-1000xm5, which are much lighter. My only complaint on the Sony is the earcups are not deep enough for my big ears.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Recommends it
I've been using the AirPods Max 1s for the last five years and you should get the Sony XM-6s. The Apple AirPod Max sound great, bur are heavy and fairly uncomfortable on the head when worn for more than an hour or two. Furthermore, I experienced persistent wireless connectivity problems and eventually sent them back to Apple under warranty. They were replaced successfully, but with a different pair of the same model which had a worn out headband. Overall it's been a bad experience and I wish that I purchased the Sony XM-6s insead.
Apple AirPods Max: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
AirPods Pro Max I've had two Sonys (XM4 and XM5) and a bunch of Boses (QC 1x something, 25, 35II). These are by far the best ones for me. The fabric on the ear cups doesn't get sweaty, I have tactile buttons for every function (unlike the Sonys), ANC works even when the mic is on (Bose can't do this). And the best feature: I can charge them while I'm using them. Neither the Sony or Bose can do that, they just go offline.
Apple AirPods Max: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
Or, perhaps, there are more nuanced reasons? I had a pair of Sony WH-1000XM3. The earpads collapsed quite badly after about a year of constant use at work, and the inside of the (very shallow!) ear cups starting pressing on my ears, which ended up being painful to wear for more than a few hours. I contacted Sony, expecting to be able to buy replacement earpads like basically every major headphone manufacturer on earth supplies (yes, even Apple and Bose), and they informed me that earpads are not user serviceable and that I would have to send the headphones into their service centre for a paid for repair. The repair would have ended up costing more than a new pair of the same headphones from Amazon. I'm not replacing my headphones annually, it's ridiculous (both from a cost and a waste PoV). I looked online and found replacement pads available from third parties, and tried a set of Dekoni pads, which noticeably changed the sound signature of the headphones and caused ANC problems. So I started looking for a replacement, discounted Sony's line completely, and ended up buying AirPods Max from Amazon when they were decently discounted in a Prime sale, and... they're fine. ANC is competent, sound quality is reasonable, unlike the WH-1000XM3 when I want to move them between Apple devices I don't have to do the re-pairing mess or stop bluetooth from autoconnecting on my other devices, earcups are lovely and deep, and the pads are user replaceable. They're honestly not a bad prod…
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
I have tinnitus and I do not see any issues with my WH1000XM4s making it any worse. It does feel like I can hear the tinnitus a bit worse with the headphones on, but I think that's just the ANC cutting out low frequency noise as expected. I've been using XM4s and XM3s for years, and my tinnitus has been steady, so I assume not all ANC makes tinnitus worse inherently. It is possible AirPods Max would also not increase tinnitus for me, but I am not going to use them because I do not use Apple products for much currently and so I am sure it'd be a pain to update and configure them. (Not to mention, it's nice being able to use LDAC in Pipewire, or Multipoint, and I don't know if Apple supports either of these options.)
Apple AirPods Max: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
Yeah. I remember my reason for switching to AirPods Max. My Sony xm3 kept connecting to the laptop in my backpack - which was asleep - when I was getting on my bike. I had to unpair my phone and re-pair it to force it to "own" the headphones. It was such a pita. That really was the biggest value add of the Apple headphones, and it works absolutely great. It almost (a 99.5%+ kind of almost) always connects to the device I want it to connect to, right away. It's a pity though that they have the common issues of Bluetooth, and turning on the microphone immediately kills the sound quality... It's one of the cases where I'd appreciate them just using a proprietary protocol. The headphones basically only work well with Apple devices anyway.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
AirPods Max are way more expensive than what I'd consider paying for headphones, the case I wouldn't trust in my backpack, the battery life doesn't even last a long international flight, nor does it come with airplane adapters, it doesn't have an aux cable for backup and I don't trust apple to integrate with anything outside their walled garden - which includes pretty much everything I own. As for other brands the cutting out is inherent to bluetooth and so is the pairing process. Even with longer lasting batteries they'd still run out eventually. It sometimes not connecting automatically is likely related to my phone, so I doubt an alternative would change that. I'm extremely happy with my Sony XM4's, but to me them having bluetooth makes little difference.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Recommends it
I loved my XM3. They eventually broke, and I replaced them with the AirPod Max as I’m all-in on Apple gear. Returned those within a week. The weight, the size, and the ANC side effects made it unusable for all-day wear. Some people love them, but I was disappointed. I’m back to XM, with newfound appreciation. You can try both for a week, and return the set that doesn’t fit into your life. Both Apple and Sony can handle a refund.
Apple AirPods Max: Recommends itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I own Sony 1000XM3s, and have since they were released. I've really enjoyed them. However, I like my AirPods Max much better, mostly because of their better UX around pairing/multiple devices and better onboard controls (digital crown vs. touch gestures). I also own older Sony Bluetooth headphones, Sennheiser HD-650s, a pair of Bose QC-20i, and several other headphones ranging from cheap to mid-range. I'm confident I can judge what I personally prefer.
Switched from the Apple AirPods Max to the Sony WH-1000XMSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I had the xm6 but the combination of worse sound (for me at least) and shallow earcups which hurt my ears drove me back to airpods max
Switched from the Apple AirPods Max to the Sony WH-1000XMSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
no, sometimes the ads are helpful for me, but I'm not really against ads. I prefer for there to be ads so (small) companies can try to convince me to buy their stuff (the alternative for me is basically just defaulting to the big co's with their marketing budget). an example of this was that I was looking to buy some Airpod Max's and noticed Sony has XM5's that are superior and cheaper so I bought those instead.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
totally valid to call out apple for issues, but for most folks already accustomed to apple's walled garden, the grass is not greener on the other side For instance, I've had a ton of issues with Airpods Max so I moved over to the Sony WH-1000XM6, and they do a much worse job sharing connections between multiple devices to the point where I have to reset them constantly to get sound to reliably play from both my phone & computer. Same for moving to macOS to linux - the issues on add up to the point where the papercuts from macOS are still worth it.