The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Apple AirPods Max vs Bose QuietComfort

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Bose QuietComfort.

Apple AirPods MaxBose QuietComfort
Owners with an opinion130265
Positive verdicts55% of 12176% of 229
Positive/negative since 202444/4440/21
Happy after 3+ years219
Longest happy owner5 yrs15 yrs
Praised forsound and noisenoise and comfort
Criticized forcomfort and reliabilityreliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple AirPods Max: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
They sound incredible (with Apple products), feel super premium, excel at noise cancelling and have really good mics. I've tried Bose and Sony; in fact, I have two pairs of QC Ultras sitting in their boxes waiting to be sold. Neither sound as good, even after EQing them as close to the Harman curve as their software allows (with Apple products; I haven't tried them with AptX streaming) and both were slower at cancelling noise. The Bose headphones I tried got decent mics after an update, but they are still unreliable at times. The Maxes are also heavy, but you don't feel it due to its being very nicely distributed across the head. I've seen scores of people run, walk, and work out in these. I even saw a child using them! I can't stress how premium the Maxes feel. The cups, for example, don't deform even after hours and hours of wear (and sweat). Replacing them is trivial and they attach with magnets instead of adhesive and/or clips. The headphone band is also extremely strong; much stronger than it looks. They feel like $549. Meanwhile, Bose charges $499 for their QuietComfort Ultras with their slow noise cancelling processors (AirPods use Apple Silicon, which is unbeatable atm) and cheap, plastic body (though part of the headphone band has a chrome finish --- premium!) All this said, Bose and Sony headphones are significantly easier to travel with, and they have power buttons. This was why I sold my AirPods Maxes the first go around (though I went back to them a year later fo…
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Recommends it
My AirPods Max 1 left a headband dent in my skull from how poor the quality of the headband was after more than a year of daily use. They also are super heavy and don't travel well at all. Apple deciding that, on their 2nd refresh of these (after usb-c), they still aren't going to fix those fundamental issues is very frustrating for what feels like a very disproportionately expensive product (even by Apple standards). I'm now a very happy QC Ultra 2 user. Can't recommend enough.
Apple AirPods Max: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
I also have the AirPods Max and had the Bose QuietComfort Ultra, and it is hard to convey how effortless the Max are in comparison. The switching between devices is so seamless (if you are in the Apple ecosystem). The controls are also much easier to find and use. The weight hasn't been an issue for me.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
Absolutely! I have both the AirPods Max and the Bose QC Ultra and even though my whole ecosystem is Apple, the QC Ultra is a lot more comfortable reliable on day to day usage. Comfort is due to weight, and reliability is the batter is predictably on the QC Ultra, but on the Max I never know if the battery went all down because I can't turn it off.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
The problem I have with these headphones (at least V1) is that the ear cups don't tilt horizontally. Maybe my ears are more angled backwards that most people's ears, but with theses headphones, the headband part sits really far back on my head. This creates a lot of pressure on only the back edge of headband. Until they make the ear cups tilt horizontally, these will be a no-go for me. My ancient 10+ year old Bose QCs 35s can pivot and are a million times more comfortable.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
>> NO: they have undefinable effects on your psyche. Maybe "pressure" or some sort of non-silent silence that your body still reacts to? I understand the pressure comment. It does not bother me that much and it's wayyy worth getting used to. I have tried the Apple Airpods Max and QC45. I think QC45 is a little less on the pressure than the Apple noise cancelling. Just my 2c.
Apple AirPods Max: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like it
AirPods Pro Max I've had two Sonys (XM4 and XM5) and a bunch of Boses (QC 1x something, 25, 35II). These are by far the best ones for me. The fabric on the ear cups doesn't get sweaty, I have tactile buttons for every function (unlike the Sonys), ANC works even when the mic is on (Bose can't do this). And the best feature: I can charge them while I'm using them. Neither the Sony or Bose can do that, they just go offline.
Apple AirPods Max: Doesn’t like itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
> 1. They look great. Not after you own them for a few months. You really ought to look at some of the scuffs these things are picking up. 2. They sound great (compared to similar wireless options). At it's price point? It honestly sounds "competitive", and that's putting it nicely. It stands toe-to-toe with the other headphones in it's category, but I feel like it should be demolishing them for costing twice as much. I honestly have no preference between the QuietComforts and the Airpods Max in terms of sound quality. That's really disappointing for $600. 3. They're fully integrated with all my other Apple devices, switching devices is super easy (I have a mac, iphone, and ipad). I haven't had Bluetooth switching issues in ages. I've owned a few pairs of wireless audio headsets (Galaxy Buds, Surface Headphones) over the years, and I haven't had to manually switch devices in months. 4. The noise canceling is great. The noise cancelling is good. Remember our friend the Quietcomforts? They cost half as much as the Max, sound just as good, and the noise cancelling on the QCs makes the Max sound like a pair of aluminum open-backs. 5. They have features like spatial audio and possibly other updates coming down the line. Not lossless audio, apparently. I wouldn't be too confident in how much Apple cares about these headphones. 6. A power button isn't needed because of how it's designed. Several early reviews said they would have preferred a power button to it's strange case, and so
Apple AirPods Max: Likes itBose QuietComfort: Likes it
Judging by the phrase “ quiet and comfort able” (emphasis in the original), the author is using headphones from the Bose QuietComfort series. Those are, indeed, widely acklowledged as the most comfortable in each generation, including for prolonged periods. The ANC is also state of the art though possibly a bit worse than on the Sony XMs, and the battery is decent with the same caveat. I don’t believe I’ve ever heard the AirPods Max called the best on any of those fundamentals, only on the Apple ecosystem integration and the spatial audio. (The tuning is also ostensibly less plebeian than on Bose or Sony, but if you care for sound enough to be willing to spend AirPods Max money you’re probably getting the Focal Bathys instead anyway.)