The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Ryzen vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

AMD RyzenNVIDIA GeForce RTX
Owners with an opinion355617
Positive verdicts77% of 26576% of 416
Positive/negative since 2024109/24214/71
Happy after 3+ years510
Longest happy owner7 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and value
Criticized fornoisenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Because M3 Pro is not a real thing as far as actual agentic workflows go. I run dual R9700 boxes those idle at 150W Because of a Ryzen AM5, and I run Spark boxes, which are decent But still idle at 45-50 watts a pop. My favorite, to be honest, is a 5090 with a Qwen 27B because that one is good for quick hitters and flies, But again, the box itself idles at 140 watts. So it's really the idle power that I don't like And it's too much of an inconvenience to power boxes down and power them back on, so they just end up running and sucking electricity. I am working on getting some sort of a smarter proxy setup where I would give boxes time to wake up and go to the cloud while they're waking up. So the whole point of having these things running in the background is that you do want them to be almost always available. So power consumption is definitely an issue.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Openrouter is not ideal, because you don't know who they send your traffic to and there are rumours of vendors cheating by providing quantized models. I'm very happy with Deepinfra. Less model coverage, but good prices and quite fast. However I have to caution you about one thing. No one will give you as many input tokens for so little money as Claude Max x5 (maybe x20 too, I use x5). I tend to use 1.1B to 1.4B a week about 0.8-1B cached. Even with cache were talking thousands of $ in API prices a week. Hundreds if we're talking cheap cloud like Deepinfra. However, local AI well setup is actually a good alternative for this if Claude Max was unavailable. For example my system a ryzen 7950x 192GB ram, 5x rtx3090 plus an rtx5060 ti 16gb. (3 rtx3090 cards via usb4 egpu dock). Let's me run Qwen3.8-Flash-Next with 3slots (no rtx5060 used) at 55tok/s decode dropping to 50 at the end of a 260k context, 1200tok/s refill dropping to 950 at the end of context. With RAM and ssd cashing and 80% cache were talking on the order of 4B a week could be ingested by this setup (roughly) if it was running 24/7. I found 6 interactive cloud code sessions are fairly pleasant with this 3 user setup. If I include the rtx5060 in the mix I can bump to 5 users, but it slows down by about 15% (note the speeds are give are for one active user, multiple users at once see maybe 70% of tgat per user so aggregate is much higher in multi user setup). So in theory I should be able to run 10 cloud code sessions…
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
i'd say it depends (as with everything) i'm still using an old i7 3770k @ 4.8ghz with 16gb (ddr3) ram running linux for random tasks like executing tests. obviously, power consumption is higher. my main machine is a MBP M1 Max which i use for everything. i also have my main linux desktop workstation that has a 5950x with 128gb (ddr4) ram. i'll probably get 2-5 years out of my MBP, and my AMD workstation will probably be good for another 5-10 years. i'm not a gamer, but i have a 3080. i'm sure my 5950x will still be good for gaming in 10 years if paired with a modern GPU.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Doesn't directly answer your question as I don't have a modern AMD card to test with, but even with an RTX 5080 Super + 9800X3D, I was still only getting about ~45-55 FPS at 4K60. I left the default settings of High and DLSS enabled (Ultra was slower). Turning off DLSS tanked the FPS to like ~15-20 and ate up almost the full 16GB of VRAM. Even so, it was still really cool to experience and was plenty playable as-is. I'm excited to see the full release.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
I had a laptop with a mobile GeForce RTX 4060 - it was a pain to run Linux on, mainly because of Nvidia. I got rid of it and built myself a PC (not just because of Nvidia, gaming laptops are just a disappointing experience). And went all in with Team Red - Ryzen and Radeon. It's a joy to run Linux on, I work on it and have played several games - 0 problems. Nvidia may be the leader in performance, but if it means you're stuck with Windows - I'd say it's not worth it.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
I recently bought a machine with an RTX 4090 and a 7950X3D. Installed Pop OS; expected there might be one or two hiccups with the Nvidia drivers. Yet I had zero driver config/installation issues - and there's not been a single Windows game I could not play on Linux at full settings. On top of it the Linux machine also streams to my Steam Deck. I've abandoned Windows 2 years ago - I see no reason to ever return.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
3700X's 8-cores is a generational leap above the 7700k's quad core for modern games. They aren't comparable at all. I ran a GTX 1080 and then an RTX 3080. The performance was not very good in modern games designed for current gen consoles like pretty much any BR game for example. Some games got high FPS at times but with low minimum FPS.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
I have 70B at q4_0 running at 20 tokens/s inference using 2 Founders Edition RTX3090s with NVLink. It's an older AMD 5950x with a motherboard with 4-slot spacing between the PCI-e (iirc, the motherboard is an ASRock x570 Taichi). For comparison, I tried the same rig with a single RTX 4090, but it generated an abysmal 2.4 tokens/s, which I would consider nigh unusable. The difference between all GPU VRAM is significant.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Just a quick note, it's worth pointing out that for most people (eg, wanting to chat to a model in realtime), I don't think running locally on a CPU is a very viable option unless you're very patient. On my 16c Ryzen 5950X/64GB DDR4-3800 system, llama-2-70b-chat (q4_K_M) running llama.cpp (eb542d3) and testing doing a 100 token test (life's too short to try max context), I got 1.25 tokens/second (~1 word/second) output. Compiled with cuBLAS w/ `-ngl 0` (~400MB of VRAM usage, no layers loaded) makes no perf difference. The max layers I can load on a headless 24GB 4090 is 45/83 layers (running `-ngl 45 --low-vram`) which brings speeds up to 2.5 t/s. A little less painful, but still not super pleasant. For reference, people have reported performance of 12-15 t/s with 2x4090s w/ exllama (GPTQ). People are using a 14,20 split and able to load a full (NTK Rope scaled) 16K context into 48GB of VRAM.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Agreed, I don't mind spending extra money on GPUs (I have 2 3090s sitting next to me) because the improvement are still worthwhile for my use case, but the CPU prices have been unjustifiable, especially on the AMD side. Increasing CPU price, absurd motherboard price AND needing to buy new RAM, all for an improvement that isn't really too meaningful unless in very specific tasks, is not really worth it. I instead just got a 5900x for my computer and moved its 3900x into a server, retiring its 1600x (which was also sufficient for its work, although at least the 1600x was noticeably slower for transcoding, the 3900x is proving more than sufficient).
AMD Ryzen: Recommends itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
I would pick AMD Ryzen CPU and any Nvidia GPU with more ram. If budget allows, I would pick RTX3090, if budget is too tight, look at RTX3080 or RTX3080Ti 12 Gb vram models. 10 gb vram models can be too small in the future or if you plan to use it for image processing. I also am working mainly with image processing and segmentation, we mainly use RTX3080 and RTX3080Ti GPUs. It should also be cheaper to pick components and build PC yourself.
AMD Ryzen: Recommends itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
That's awesome re the Threadripper Pro! Yes, DCS World in particular, but also Star Citizen (where nothing else comes close at the moment) and to some degree iRacing. It went from stuttering all the time (bad 99% lows) on a well overclocked (all core 4.4ghz) 3900XT to butter smooth frame rates in DCS - and that's including custom scripts I had to exclude before (Streamdeck integration, etc). I can now push DCS World to three screens; even on my lowly (for the task) 3070, the lowish 30-40-50 depending on weather FPS numbers combined with Free(G)sync monitors are never stuttering so it still feels smooth. I attribute it to the CPU never being the weak link; also, have reasonably good memory (4x 16GB C16-3600 Neos at XMP/3600mhz). For gaming, there's no better value for money right now than the 5800X3D - if you already have an AMD system. And even then, if not, and you're not made of money.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Unified memory is a lot more flexible and efficient though. You don't have to have assets loaded in RAM and also VRAM for the CPU/GPU to use them. Don't forget about how much more RAM a general purpose OS like Steam OS can consume versus a gaming specific OS too. The PS5 Pro also has an extra 2GB of DDR5 system RAM too. My old Ryzen 3700X gaming PC has 16GB of RAM and 8GB of VRAM (RTX 2070 Super) and there isn't any game that runs better on it than my Xbox Series X. And the GPU in the Steam Machine is slightly worse than an RTX 2070 Super.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Idk - I’ve been trying out Linux gaming on Bazzite and everything seems to just work? It’s been a basically flawless experience. I dual boot Linux + Windows (technically triple boot - I have a third drive with a different distro for dev work) and I haven’t needed to boot to windows a single time in the ~5 months I’ve been testing out Linux gaming. Not a single game has required any tweaking with proton settings either. My plan is to remove Windows entirely if I make it through the year without needing it. No issues with drivers, no issues with peripherals (Wired speakers, Bluetooth headset, usb headset, webcam), with 3 displays at different resolutions/framerates/orientations. Running Ryzen 9800x3d and an RTX 4070ti. Games I’ve played on Linux cover a pretty wide spectrum too. - Arc Raiders - Stalker 2 - Kingdom come deliverance 2 - Doom the dark ages - Timberborn - Pacific Drive - Baulders Gate 3 - Disco Elysium - Peak - Alan Wake 2 - RV there yet - Yapyap - Pentinence and probably others I’m forgetting. I honestly wasn’t expecting the experience to be this smooth. Windows days as the gaming default feel numbered.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Local! I do not mind the cost honestly. And a bit slower also works. I just use one older mac ultra 2/192G ram and another with an rtx5060/16G and an and r9700/32G. Between those I get my models working fine. That also gives me full privacy. And that is worth way way way more than any cost.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Many reputable websites and channels “measure” the power consumption of Mac computers using apps like Max Power Gadget or asitop. These apps are built on top of the powermetrics MacOS facility. However, in the man pages of the facility it is clearly explained that the readings are estimated and not measured values and that they shouldn’t be used for making power consumption comparisons. In my performance investigation studies I found that the reported CPU and GPU power consumption is vastly underestimated: in case of the GPU the reported value is just over a third of the actual consumption, as is explained in the video. It is unfortunate that said reviewers do not bother to sanity check the numbers with a power meter and thereby perpetuate misleading information on Apple silicon performance/Watt. In a prior investigation, where I did extensive Linear Algebra performance investigations on the M4 Max, I found that it’s CPU performance/Watt in dense matrix multiplication is well below that of Ryzen 9950X, when the computations are carried out on its Neon vector units. Similarly for Apple’s M4 Max GPU vs nVidia last gen RTX 4090.