The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Ryzen vs Nvidia GeForce

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

AMD RyzenNvidia GeForce
Owners with an opinion355305
Positive verdicts77% of 26574% of 217
Positive/negative since 2024109/2485/30
Happy after 3+ years511
Longest happy owner7 yrs21 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized fornoisesoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Ryzen: NeutralNvidia GeForce: Likes it
This is Black Friday pricing at least, if you're willing to shuck. Seagate drives are still sub-$10/TB which... a single 24-26TB is enough for all my photos (ever), media and some dataset backup for work. I'm planning to backup photos and other "glacier"-tier media like YouTube channels to BluRay (a disk or two per year). It's at the point where I'd rather just pay the money and forget about it for 5-10 years. I built the case from Makerbeam and printed panels, an old Corsair SF600 and a 4 year old ITX system with one of Silverstone's backplanes. They make up to 5 drives in a 3x5-1/4 bay form factor. It's a little overpowered (a 5950X), but I also use it as a generic server at home and run a shared ZFS pool with 2x mirrored vdevs. Even with inefficient space it's more than I need. I put in a 1080ti for transcoding or odd jobs that need a little CUDA (like photo tagging). Runs ResNet50-class models easily enough. I also wondered about treating it as a single-node SLURM server.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Neutral
I'm on a 5800X with a 3080ti and 64GB, also PCIe 4.0 SSDs. I built in in 2019 then upgraded the CPU a year ago from a 3600x to the 5800x and it's so insanely fast for everything I do, including VMs, compiles, transcodes, etc. Nutty performance. The past few years have had amazing performance boosts.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Doesn’t like it
Basically anything recent but not the latest components will work well. If you want hassle-free then going with amd everything is the most efficient IMO. I'm running a ryzen 3600 and a radeon rx5700xt, and i've not had any driver issues, be it with x11 or wayland. I've been playing a bunch of games from my library but there are still some games that aren't compatible (for ex. Vermintide 2 has non-compatible anticheat) so i keep a spartan windows instal on a 128gb ssd for those and VR. VR is a non-starter on linux. That being said, nvidia has RT cores now, which can do very fast matrix multiplication which is advantageous for ML workloads (on top of a lot of ml work being optimized for cuda cores). Can't speak to their drivers but older cards should be safer, especially considering the 40 series hasn't been shown to be worth it over used 30 series.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Neutral
Note this whole discussion is in the context of the 4090. If you're an enthusiast, soldering the GPU to the mobo forces you to spend $200-$700 more every time you upgrade your GPU because you also have to buy a new mobo and possibly a new CPU if the socket changed. The GPU is also one of the easiest components to swap today. That's not something I want to give up unless I see performance improvements. Cooling doesn't count because I already have an external radiator attached to my open-frame "case". I went through 3 GPUs before changing motherboards and I'm still bottlenecked on my 3090, not my 5800X3D. After I get a 4090, I expect to upgrade it at least once before getting a new mobo.
AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
I built new media box last year and thought I would try AMD Ryzen 2400G APU. Turns out it was a bad choice. Those graphics drivers are extremely unstable, it keeps crashing frequently, kernel bug reports have many reports from multiple people with info on how to reproduce them but those cases are still in status "NEW" almost 1 year later. And while their Windows benchmarks are decent, anything 3D related on Linux is a glitching disaster with poor performance. My friend bought latest Intel NUC with AMD Vega graphics and he could not even get Linux to boot with that. Meanwhile I have Nvidia GTX970 on my desktop PC and everything works fine, even G-Sync works. I have used Nvidia cards with Linux for 10 years now and I have not had any issues like I have with AMD now. To me it seems like AMD dumping their drivers as open source is a call for help on maintaining them rather than being all friendly to community.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
"Nope. I watch a lotta youtube on a PC, FF runs vids like crap because Google changes something, and FF struggls to play well unlike Chrome or Edge." You must have a hardware problem, as I'm playing 4K videos on a 1st-gen Ryzen and GTX 1080 using Firefox and I've never had a single issue since I got the machine, around the 4th week the processor was available to purchase.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
Mine was built with a leftover ryzen 1500X, microatx motherboard and RAM that were effectively free, a geforce 1030, and a random cheap 256GB SSD I found on newegg (the video content lives elsewhere across the LAN). It continues to be capable of playing 2160p60 H.265/HEVC content so I don't see a cpu and motherboard upgrade any time in the next couple of years, unless very high bitrate AV1 encoded content suddenly becomes more popular.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
Successfully ran Gemma4-26B-A4B on my 8yo first-gen Ryzen with a GeForce GTX 1070. It actually ran acceptably well; I was surprised. I even did some coding with it, but the wheels fell abruptly off when it tried several times to use a constant I told it doesn't exist. I only have 32 GiB of RAM in this old bucket, and these results are not worth the RAM consumption, so I put it aside. Maybe if I finish that build with more memory...
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
On my ryzen laptop, i have to manually ensure that Linux is setting the right power settings. Once i do that, my 5950HS laptop from 2022 is completely competitive with my work MacBook M2. Louder and hotter at full tilt, but it also has a better GPU (even with the onboard Nvidia turned off) and i can get ~6 hours of web dev out of it if I'm not constantly churning tons of files. I would try it with Windows for a better comparison, or get into the weeds of getting Linux to handle the ryzen platform power settings better. With Ubuntu properly managing fans and temps and clocks, I'll take it over the Mac 10/10 times.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
I love MacBooks and Mac machines however they aren't cut out for specialised work. I have a M4 Max with 128 GB RAM. If I play Civ VI (a game released in 2016) on it for a few hours without limiting the FPS it will heat up till it turns itself off. It's not cut out for heavy loads consistently like games or crypto mining. It's cut out for a heavy loads like Xcode compiling for a few minutes then back to editing text. My gaming machine which has poorer performance (in fps terms) and is equipped with AMD 3700 and a 2080 Super can play Civ VI indefinitely without breaking a sweat.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNvidia GeForce: Neutral
Recently tried Plasma 6 for a while on a fresh openSUSE install (with Nvidia drivers) but the visual bugs and omnipresent lag annoyed me so much that I switched to XFCE, which still runs fantastically. Plasma 6 also had some weird issues rendering Steam, in particular - often the window would show with the content completely corrupted (as in, a random mess of static and colors). Haven't had that issue under XFCE so far. I have a decent desktop (Nvidia 3090, AMD 2700x, 64 GB DDR4, 2 TB NVMe) and I try Plasma every few years because I always hear positive things but my experience this time was the same as every time before: 1) It was laggy, firefox, obsidian, and the file explorer consistently take 20 - 30 seconds to start. Steam takes 1 - 2 minutes to start and lags the whole time. 2) It was buggy: - adding and moving panels is inconsistent - steam and other applications often fail to render properly - the themes in the theme browser often don't work at all, or have major visual issues 3) It doesn't respect my choices - after installing firefox and signing into my sync account, the plasma desktop added a firefox-plasma integration extension without any interaction from me, which then got synced to my other devices. ---- I'll probably try it again in a few years if nothing better comes along but I was really disappointed. The only issue I have with XFCE is that screen-locking doesn't work right now and I'm pretty sure that I'll be able to resolve that.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
I went from 2700 to 5800X3D and the difference is absolutely dramatic and well worth it. Originally I had a 1440p monitor with Geforce 1080 which was fine. Then I bought a 4K monitor and it brought it down to it's knees. Then upgraded to 3080 and there definitely was an improvement, but FPS was still unacceptably low so upgraded to that X3D processor. It's a beast and I play most games on 140+fps.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNvidia GeForce: Neutral
Yup, so I've adopted a strategy for my past few desktop builds like this: - Every time a new ToTL GPU comes out for a new family, buy it at retail price as soon as it launches (so, the first-available ToTL models that were big gains in perf: GTX 1080 Ti, RTX 2080 Ti, RTX 3090, RTX 4090) - Every other release cycle, upgrade CPU to the ToTL consumer chip (eg on a 12900KS right now, HEDT like ThreadRipper is super expensive and not usually better for gaming or normal dev stuff). I was with Ryzen since 1800x -> 3950x -> 5950x but Intel is better for the particular game I play 90% of the time. - Every time you upgrade, sell the stuff you've upgraded ASAP. If you do this right and never pay above MSRP for parts, you can usually keep running very high-end hardware for minimal TCO. - Buy a great case, ToTL >1000w PSU (Seasonic or be quiet!), and ToTL cooling system (currently on half a dozen 140mm Noctua fans and a Corsair 420mm AIO). This should last at least 3 generations of upgrading the other stuff. - Storage moves more slowly than the rest, and I've had cycles where I've re-used RAM as well, so again here go for the good stuff to maximize perf, but older SSDs work great for home servers or whatever else. - Monitor and other peripherals are outside of the scope of this but should hopefully last at least 3 upgrade generations. I bit when OLED TVs supported 4K 120hz G-Sync, so I've got a 55" LG G1 that I'm still quite happy with and not wanting to immediately upg…
AMD Ryzen: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
It seems like you think I'm trying to dunk on Apple. I am not. Apple Silicon is a great first showing for them. Performance simply isn't better than Ryzen APUs running in the same power envelope. And power usage is what you'd expect of silicon running on the latest node. Further, some of Apple's choices - bringing memory on package, only two display outputs - caused regressions for their users compared to the previous Intel offerings. I wouldn't call what Apple did innovation - they followed predictable development trajectories - more integration. They licensed ARM's instruction set, Imagination's PowerVR GPU, most of the major system busses (PCIe, Thunderbolt, USB 3, Displayport, etc), they bonded chiplets together with TSMC's packaging and chip-to-chip communication technologies, and they made extensions (like optional x86 memory ordering for all ARM instructions which removes a lot of the work of emulation). Incidentally, Apple kicked off it's chip design efforts by purchasing PA Semi. Those folks had all the power management chip design expertise already. But again, it's been a good first showing for Apple. I think they were smart to ship on-package DRAM in a consumer device. Now is about the right time for the CPU to be absorbing DRAM, as can be seen by AMD's 3D VCache in another form. And it's cool for Apple folks to have their own cool thing. Yay y'all. But I've run Linux for 20 years, I've run Linux on every computer I can get my hands on in that time, a…
AMD Ryzen: NeutralNvidia GeForce: Neutral
From my experience with deep learning I can eyeball it: one or two orders of magnitude. The fine details may be different on this particular problem. In DL in general, if you have sort of equivalent CPU/GPUs (think a 5600 vs GeForce 3070) you'll find yourself in the range of 10 to 30x faster training with GPU. If you have substantially different platforms, you can start looking at 100x speedups or more. For example, my mobile 4600H CPU trains about 100x slower than a desktop GeForce 2060. And close to 300x faster than the old Intel 7200u I use as a "slow system" to test things. Which also has a GeForce 940MX, that trains about 30x slower than the 2060 (if you manage to make your model small enough to fit in 2GB of VRAM).