The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Ryzen vs Intel Core i7

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

AMD RyzenIntel Core i7
Owners with an opinion355104
Positive verdicts77% of 26582% of 83
Positive/negative since 2024109/2425/10
Happy after 3+ years514
Longest happy owner7 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized fornoisenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Neutral
3700X's 8-cores is a generational leap above the 7700k's quad core for modern games. They aren't comparable at all. I ran a GTX 1080 and then an RTX 3080. The performance was not very good in modern games designed for current gen consoles like pretty much any BR game for example. Some games got high FPS at times but with low minimum FPS.
AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itIntel Core i7: Neutral
This is blessed silicon for sure mine ryzen always (3000 series 7000 series) have very high power consumption in idle right now I’m mostly on M1 ultra and are around 7-10W idle compared to 45W on 3900x and 35-40 on 7700. (I have also intel server with 12700k that idle around 15W but it is undervolted a bit)
AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itIntel Core i7: Likes it
The scam knows no limit. Make sure Windows 10 isn't updated anymore and then make sure Windows 11 isn't supported "because the hardware is too old", forcing people to buy new computers. As a sidenote for whatever reason I tried to install Windows 11 on an AMD 3700X (don't remember why exactly I did that as I typically don't run Windows). The AMD 3700X came out in mid 2019. Windows 11 refused to install for the hardware wasn't supported: I don't know if it was the mobo, the CPU, a configuration in the mobo... Really no clue. All I know is not only it failed but it failed without telling what wasn't supported . On a computer that was not even four years old. Meanwhile my wife is happily using Ubuntu on my old sixth gen Core i7 6700K from... 2015 (first Asus mobo that had a NVMe M.2 PCIe slot so in eight years I basically just upgraded the NVMe SSD to a more recent one). I agree with the other poster: it's an opportunity to have "old" computers and just install whatever Linux distro on them. All that "normies" need is a browser: I switched my 67 years old mother-in-law to Linux. If she can use Linux, nearly anyone can.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Doesn’t like it
Interesting, because when I upgraded from a Ryzen 3000 series to a Ryzen 7000 series, I experienced significant speedups in various tasks: - Compiling code - Running multiple services in docker containers for local development that are a mix of cpu and io bound Whenever I use an older laptop I have that is on intel i7, 8th gen, these tasks are much much slower. I think it really depends on your workload.
AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itIntel Core i7: Likes it
Fair enough. I just bought a laptop with an Intel Core i7-1165G7. The reason is I got tired of dealing with Ubuntu being unable to be installed in my AMD Ryzen 2500U. Yes, even with the latest version using the latest kernel, and my last attempt to install it was a few days ago in 2022. Last time I mentioned this issue about AMD in this forum I was downvoted, but I don't care, I am writing now this comment from a nice laptop, and I'm back in Linux again, so I am happy with this decision. My point is: yes, AMD market segmentation is better, and I wish them the best. But for my particular use case: Windows is not enough, and I require the machine to work in Linux, therefore Intel is a must.
Switched from the AMD Ryzen to the Intel Core i7Intel Core i7: Likes it
> I see a number 4770 and 4790 still doing the job they were bought for. I expect the same for 12th gen when they're 13yo. Not so for anything between 4th and 12th. What do you mean? My Core i7-6700K is still running strong on its Asus Z-170A mobo (TFA mention a Z370-A, mine's a bit older but was one of the first mobo to offer a M.2 NVMe slot). It even runs very modern games just fine on whatever not-so-powerful GPU that's in it: it's the PC my daughter uses to play (I did put PoP OS! and Steam on it but I'll swap to another distro if needed). I switched to an AMD 3700X and then to an AMD7700X but I don't see anything wrong with my 6th gen Core i7.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Likes it
There are peaks in long-term CPU value. That is, CPUs that are 1) performant enough to handle general purpose computing for a decade and 2) outperform later chips for a long time. The i7-4770 was one. It reliably outperformed later Intel CPUs until near 10th gen or so. I know shops that are still plugging away on them. The first comparable replacements for it is the i7-12700 (but the i5-12400 is a good buy). At 13th gen, Intel swaps E for P cores. They have their place but I still prefer 12th gen for new desktops. Past all that, the author is right about the AMD Ryzen 9950x. It's a phenomenal chip. I used one in a friend's custom build (biz, local llm) and it'll be in use in 2035.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Likes it
10% per year does add up, particularly if you don’t upgrade every year. I think if you get some decent lifetime out of your computer you have a good chance of still getting a significant speed boost when you upgrade. I have a Ryzen 3950X and I suspect even now there’s a noticeable speed improvement at the top end, and I don’t feel like upgrading yet. That was still a big improvement over the Intel 3930K (?) I had before, even though sandy bridge was when progression started to show a slowdown. I do think it’s perhaps easier to buy a computer with some weird bottleneck (crappy storage and the like) which will present day-to-day performance on par with your outgoing computer. Day-to-day high performance is seemingly hard to get right even if you can crunch numbers faster. Sort of a latency vs throughput problem.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Likes it
> Writing to disk is fast and my internet is fast. Things feel super snappy. I've been building computers from parts since about 1998, I think this is the longest I ever went without an upgrade. I did like you: rocking a Core i7-6700 from, what, 2015 up until early 2022. 16 GB of RAM, NVMe PCI 3.0 x4 SSD, the first Samsung ones. I basically build that machine around one of the first Asus mobo to offer a NVMe M.2 slot. It was and still is an amazing machine. I gave it to my wife and I'm now using an AMD 3700X since about a year and... I'll be changing it for a 7700X in the coming weeks (hopefully). The 3700X is definitely faster than my trusty old 6th gen core i7 but Zen 4 is too good to be true so I'm upgrading. All this to say: you can stay with the same system for seven years then upgrade twice in less than 12 months!
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Likes it
For sure. I moved from setup with an i7-6700k and a gtx 1070 to one with a 5900x and an rx 6900xt, and in games the upgrade wasn't really as strong as you might expect. Code compilation, hashing, rendering were all markedly faster though. That old PC became a perfectly serviceable hand me down after 5 years of service, and I hope to get another 5 out of this rig. Pretty cool that we're seeing longevity and some progress at the same time.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core i7: Likes it
I'm kind of disappointed in this. While they are upping the core count, the overall clock speed is being decreased across the board. This means that single threaded processes will theoretically perform slower (I know it still turbos up). Honestly, I just upgraded to Ryzen from a 3770k and. My 3770k ran all cores at 4.2GHz (overclocked, obviously) and the only reason I updated was becasue I wanted to upgrade to NVMe and DDR4. That was 4 years old and I had no CPU-bound performance issues. I really think Intel needs to start innovating more rather than being complacent or AMD is actually going to steal the show. Super happy for the competition though!