The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Ryzen vs Intel Core

Hacker News owners slightly favor the AMD Ryzen.

AMD RyzenIntel Core
Owners with an opinion35532
Positive verdicts77% of 26588% of 25
Positive/negative since 2024109/245/1
Happy after 3+ years51
Longest happy owner7 yrs11 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and value
Criticized fornoisebattery and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itIntel Core: Likes it
TDP is not a good metric to normalize against because it's a thermal design target only tangentially related to power limits. Power limits are generally much higher. For example the AMD stock limits result in a power target that is generally ~40 % higher than the specified TDP. Lots of motherboards will disable that limit automatically though and let the CPU draw as much power as it likes. I don't know how current AMD mobile platforms work, Intel Alder Lake has four or five different power limits. There's an instantaneous power limit, that's like 100 W. Then there's PL2, the short-term power limit (for a few seconds), which is like 30-40 W. PL1 is the sustained limit and depends on the laptop and is set to match the capabilities of the cooling system (or lack thereof) in an Intel-specified range (like 6-25 W). That's typically marketed as the TDP for laptops. There's an additional power limit for the iGPU and something somewhere is doing the divvying up of the currently available package power into iGPU power and CPU power (which doesn't seem to work that well under Linux). In the current desktop generation AMD and Intel are much closer than in Intel 12th vs AMD Zen 3. That's mostly because 13th gen has pretty much the same limits as before, but is more efficient, while Zen 4 has massively increased the power targets throughout the stack - by 60 to 90 % - to keep up with Intel (plus the marketing advantage of getting through the 5 GHz wall) E.g. a 5600X had a PPT of 76 W, a 7…
AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itIntel Core: Likes it
If I were to guess: AMD came out really poorly on motherboard pricing for AM5, 7000 CPUs are market leading in price, availability has been poor. Intel meanwhile has an established year old motherboard pipeline for their current socket that 13th gen can be dropped in to. If this were 14th gen vs Ryzen 7000 the calculus would be different as all the Intel purchases would also include a motherboard. Also, Ryzen 5000 is going gangbusters outselling everything else.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core: Doesn’t like it
I've played with an AMD 6800u laptop and I would say it's the ideal x86 laptop chip right now. Normal usage at the 12w mode or light gaming at 20w mode was super impressive. Even though 12th Gen Intel chips have made great performance gains Intel is still relying on unsustainable high turbo boosts to get the benchmark numbers. I just recently stumbled across these two otherwise identical laptops. https://psref.lenovo.com/syspool/Sys/PDF/Lenovo/Lenovo_Slim_... https://psref.lenovo.com/syspool/Sys/PDF/Lenovo/Lenovo_Slim_... The AMD version is rated for 20% greater battery life just from the CPU difference.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core: Doesn’t like it
Intel has removed support for S3 sleep from their platform, so every laptop with 11th+ generation Intel is plagued with this issue. Dell even put out an advisory that a sleeping laptop is not safe to store in a backpack anymore! AMD still supports S3 sleep on their Ryzen processors, but you'll need to check user feedback to make sure that the vendor did their job implementing it properly. In S3 sleep, the UEFI/BIOS is responsible for suspending and resuming hardware state. If not implemented correctly, you'll have high battery drain (components not suspended) or bugs on resume. Lenovo had dropped the ball on that front repeatedly, with the last two gens of T14 requiring BIOS updates to fix issues.
AMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like itIntel Core: Likes it
> and are now a desktop enthusiast favorite as well. The i5/i7 class is outmatched in every metric ($/FLOP, W/$, and W/FLOP) by the Ryzen series. maybe a couple years ago, at this point Intel is dominating the gaming market, competing in the productivity market despite having fewer cores (i.e. more potent cores), are at least matching Zen3 efficiency (except i9, but you said i5/i7) if not beating (particularly at lower power budgets due to infinity fabric overhead). Ryzen has absolutely lost favor with the enthusiast market due to the significant price increases (in some segments, a 50% increase over last generation) and the refusal to chop prices to remain competitive with intel (justified with "but they can make more money selling Epyc", which is great for them but it doesn't make their products competitive for me as a consumer either). And AMD has completely abandoned the value market... i3 12100F is listed for $110 at Best Buy (iGPU version is $140), and Intel is in the process of rolling out Celerons for even cheaper rigs (will be nice for HTPC with that iGPU). AMD's cheapest processor has a $300 MSRP and they won't budge on pricing at all given their focus on the server market. go look at a tech enthusiast forum and nobody is recommending Ryzen anymore. It's overpriced, it no longer has a performance or efficiency advantage (in fact it's rather flopped the other way), and AMD would rather address the server market instead. this has really shifted in the last 6 mont…
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core: Doesn’t like it
But they really haven't. We've not seen hide nor hair of the new process, only iterative improvements on the current process, and the attempt at big.LITTLE x86-style doesn't seem to have worked out terribly well. ARM has taken out the low-power market that Atom and Pentium classes were aiming at. AMD APUs have long been a favorite of mid-power devices like gaming consoles and are now a desktop enthusiast favorite as well. The i5/i7 class is outmatched in every metric ($/FLOP, W/$, and W/FLOP) by the Ryzen series. IBM and Azure placed their big chip refresh orders with AMD as well, so the hyperscaler market is in danger. The only place Xeons are still superior is the scientific and high computing space, and Threadripper is making inroads there as well. Intel still has great sales from existing cashflows and OEM agreements, but if you were buying a computer in 2022, why choose Intel? Why would its customers? I think they're going to have to come up with something new and soon.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralIntel Core: Neutral
Yup, so I've adopted a strategy for my past few desktop builds like this: - Every time a new ToTL GPU comes out for a new family, buy it at retail price as soon as it launches (so, the first-available ToTL models that were big gains in perf: GTX 1080 Ti, RTX 2080 Ti, RTX 3090, RTX 4090) - Every other release cycle, upgrade CPU to the ToTL consumer chip (eg on a 12900KS right now, HEDT like ThreadRipper is super expensive and not usually better for gaming or normal dev stuff). I was with Ryzen since 1800x -> 3950x -> 5950x but Intel is better for the particular game I play 90% of the time. - Every time you upgrade, sell the stuff you've upgraded ASAP. If you do this right and never pay above MSRP for parts, you can usually keep running very high-end hardware for minimal TCO. - Buy a great case, ToTL >1000w PSU (Seasonic or be quiet!), and ToTL cooling system (currently on half a dozen 140mm Noctua fans and a Corsair 420mm AIO). This should last at least 3 generations of upgrading the other stuff. - Storage moves more slowly than the rest, and I've had cycles where I've re-used RAM as well, so again here go for the good stuff to maximize perf, but older SSDs work great for home servers or whatever else. - Monitor and other peripherals are outside of the scope of this but should hopefully last at least 3 upgrade generations. I bit when OLED TVs supported 4K 120hz G-Sync, so I've got a 55" LG G1 that I'm still quite happy with and not wanting to immediately upg…
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core: Likes it
In games both 7000 Ryzens and 13 gen Intel are overpriced. A tuned 12th gen Intel or Ryzen 7 5800X3D will almost match them. Also value overclocking is back - cheap boards like MSI MAG B660M Mortar Max Wifi DDR4 and AsRock B660M PG Riptide can overclock non-K Intel CPUs. Combined with say an i5 12400f overclocked to 5.1GHz they are providing amazing performance per dollar.
AMD Ryzen: NeutralIntel Core: Neutral
From my experience with deep learning I can eyeball it: one or two orders of magnitude. The fine details may be different on this particular problem. In DL in general, if you have sort of equivalent CPU/GPUs (think a 5600 vs GeForce 3070) you'll find yourself in the range of 10 to 30x faster training with GPU. If you have substantially different platforms, you can start looking at 100x speedups or more. For example, my mobile 4600H CPU trains about 100x slower than a desktop GeForce 2060. And close to 300x faster than the old Intel 7200u I use as a "slow system" to test things. Which also has a GeForce 940MX, that trains about 30x slower than the 2060 (if you manage to make your model small enough to fit in 2GB of VRAM).
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core: Likes it
I don't get the obsession with the M1. The Intel 12900h is equal at 45w and substantially faster at higher wattages. Same goes for the AMD 6900HX which also scales really well into lower wattages. Dedicated GPUs of course mop the floor with Apple IGPs, admittedly with more energy. All that with a cheaper and less dense architecture. The fact that Apple - a company with 14 times the market cap of Intel and AMD and exlusive access to TSMC 5n for their PC processors - has failed to beat them is embarrassing.
AMD Ryzen: Likes itIntel Core: Likes it
Game performance, and cooling in general outside of a very specific use case, isn't affected by what the marketing department of Intel says the 10 core AVX wattage of the 12600k is being compared to what the marketing department of AMD says the 6 core AVX wattage of the 5600X is. When a single core is maxed out the real world measured difference is roughly 12 watts between the two and remember the 12600k is doing slightly more per second than the 5600X. If your gaming device of choice is a laptop that'd be interesting but both are desktop gaming CPUs. If 24/7 all core workload power efficiency is your concern I'd steer you away from either gaming optimized option. I really like what AMD has done, my last 2 desktop CPUs have been a 3900X and a 5950X, but if I were to buy a entry level gaming CPU right now the 12600k would be very interesting regardless what the all core AVX thermals look like on a stock cooler.