The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Radeon vs Nvidia GeForce GTX

Hacker News owners lean toward the Nvidia GeForce GTX.

AMD RadeonNvidia GeForce GTX
Owners with an opinion232132
Positive verdicts59% of 19073% of 100
Positive/negative since 202462/4535/14
Happy after 3+ years715
Longest happy owner14 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce GTX: Likes it
AMD GPUs are fantastic values for money when it comes to running mainstream PC games. Once you step outside that narrow box they become infuriating. My 7900XTX is probably the last AMD GPU I ever buy. It's just horrible at all the other things I want to use it for, especially and gallingly, game console emulation. For the first few months I had it I actually kept my old GTX1070 plugged into my motherboard because the eight year old $400 GPU was so much better at half my use cases than the $900 AMD card.
AMD Radeon: NeutralNvidia GeForce GTX: Likes it
I ran a used GTX570 until it died in 2017. Then a used GTX780 until it died in 2021. Now I'm on a used Radeon 5600. I paid less than $200 for each of them. I've also been running the same i5-3470 CPU since it was new. Computers can last a long, long time if you can bear the thought of not being on the bleeding edge. Otherwise, yeah, you're going to be paying a premium for brand new tech. That's the trade you make chasing the newest and shiniest thing.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce GTX: Likes it
Same, but R9 380X back in college. Bang per buck it seemed better than NVidia. But despite my distaste for NVidia back then, after that experience, I resolved to never get an AMD GPU again unless things drastically change. Drivers would constantly break something, some games would run poorly and I would have to fiddle with driver versions to address this (often involving annoying version rollbacks), it would randomly start overheating for no reason, sometimes it would just crash the system, etc. Upgraded to 480 later, and the exact same story repeated. You know what happened once I got an NVidia GPU years later (1080Ti)? I never had to think about the GPU ever again. I install a driver update occasionally, it “just werks”, and I would go on my merry way. Upgraded to a 3080 about half a year after it got released, and had the same story - it just works, and I never have to think or worry about it ever. I would love to support AMD GPUs, but I cannot, in good conscience, buy their GPU again and waste time troubleshooting it and stress over every driver update. On the flip side, AMD CPUs are amazing. Been with them since the original Ryzen release, upgraded once (from 1700 to 3900x), no issues whatsoever and am very happy with those. My next build will be an AMD Ryzen CPU as well, but it will have an NVidia GPU.
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce GTX: Doesn’t like it
Bro since Lisa Su in charge things changed a bit, my 7900xt works like a charm with X and wayland and same did rx580 for few years now, amdgpu is open source driver integrated in kernel of most Linux distributions, its plug an play, just install gpu, turn on the machine, boot into your linux then load amdgpu module reboot, and you can already immediately set ur display on 144hz, try that with my 1080gtx and you are locked at 60 with noveau driver module loaded, until u install their proprietary sheit.... There are many examples of companies and countries that have improved their competitiveness and efficiency by adopting open source strategies. The creation of skills through all levels is of fundamental importance to both companies and countries.
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce GTX: Likes it
I used an AMD Radeon 7770 for years, then I upgraded to a GTX 1060, the 7770 became my younger sister's GPU for her PC. It has only recently gave out, after some 14 years of service. Likewise for the 1060, its still going strong. I upgraded to a 3060 round about the time my younger brother decided he wanted a PC so he is now using it without any issues. About 10 years use out of it, plenty more to go. GPUs are pretty damn resilient if you aren't pissing around with them.
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce GTX: Likes it
My previous card (Radeon 7970HD) was used for BTC mining in a gaming PC and lasted until about 2018 (So about 6 years). My current GPU is a 1080Ti that used to be in a mining rig and shows no signs of damage at about 4 years of age. I'm looking forward to buying a used crypto mining card when the current one dies.