The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Radeon vs Nvidia GeForce

Hacker News owners lean toward the Nvidia GeForce.

AMD RadeonNvidia GeForce
Owners with an opinion232305
Positive verdicts59% of 19074% of 217
Positive/negative since 202462/4585/30
Happy after 3+ years711
Longest happy owner14 yrs21 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Doesn’t like it
I'm mired by my own perspective. I bought an SLI pair of 9800GTs in ~2008. I found SLI wasn't worth the difficulty (and neither was a dedicated PhysX processor), so I eventually gave one of them away to a friend who wanted a video card. My old man was scooping up scrap metal in 2015 and found a Radeon card (I forget which exact model) that was faster than the SLI 9800GTs ever were, and which had twice the RAM. It was on top of pile of trash at the curb on a small town's annual collection day. It worked great, though my PSU only had a bunch of 6-pin power connectors and this one required 8-pin (a problem that I patched around with a soldering iron). Shortly after, in 2016, I also upgraded to an i3 and DDR4 because it was cheap at the time. One core of that was faster than all 4 cores of the once-beastly Q6600 it replaced. It was an awesome upgrade. I wrote on Reddit about some problem or other with getting X going on the thing, and some well-meaning individual noticed the Radeon card. They asked me why I was even bothering with that, and opined that the i3's built-in iGPU was probably actually-better, maybe-faster, and definitely better-supported than the dedicated GPU -- while just sipping power. They were right: It was faster, better, and cheaper. Out came the Radeon GPU and things got better after that. Around that time, Rockstar was in the process of abandoning GTA:V on ye olde PS3 and was giving away the PC version of the game to PS3 users, along with account tran…
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Recommends it
I have heard frequently complaints about NVIDIA drivers on Linux, but I always wonder about which are the exact circumstances in which such problems can appear. I have used NVIDIA GPUs on Linux continuously since 2005, i.e. for 21 years. During this time I have been using more than a dozen different kinds of desktop NVIDIA GPUs, both GeForce and Quadro (I have multiple computers). I have also used several kinds of laptops with NVIDIA GPUs, both GeForce and Quadro, from Dell and from Lenovo. I have also used NVIDIA Jetson SBCs, with NVIDIA Volta GPUs. On all these many kinds of hardware and during these 21 years, I have never had any problem with the NVIDIA GPUs, either on Linux or on FreeBSD (NVIDIA is among the few hardware vendors who also provide FreeBSD device drivers). On the other hand, I have had various problems with my AMD GPUs, or, more rarely, with my Intel GPUs. Today I have more AMD GPUs than NVIDIA GPUs, but that is because I use the AMD GPUs for computational purposes, while the NVIDIA GPUs are used for graphics. I use many programs based on OpenGL, and the quality of the graphics has always been perfect with NVIDIA GPUs, while in the past it was quite bad on both AMD GPUs and Intel GPUs, regardless whether the "professional" closed-source AMD drivers were used, or their open-source drivers. By bad I mean that the AMD and Intel GPUs failed to render correctly some complex images drawn with OpenGL, unlike the NVIDIA GPUs, which were flawless. The quality of the
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
Sadly if you want a GPU with good AI performance you gotta go with NVIDIA. It might sound crazy but as a 7900XTX owner.. My 12GB 3060 on my linux server outperformed the 7900XTX by 40%. The 3060 only has half the vram of the AMD card. Proprietary drivers under Arch Linux. On top of the significantly worse software on AMD's side (literally didn't work on windows in particular - so the "performs as good on both systems" is a nonstarter, some GGUF library dependency just doesn't work/exist under AMD on windows). Had me running the AMD card on windows under WSL (not a problem with nvidia though, that ran just fine on windows-side directly). Aaaand also the other AMD bugs, such as the pink squares display corruption that has been an active issue for my GPU in particular (7900XTX) for over a year, maybe approaching two at this point, with no fix in sight from the AMD team (barely and ack at all - not on a single patch notes, just a bunch of reddit discussion). Really regret spending so much on an AMD gpu.
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Doesn’t like it
I came to rely pretty heavily on Docker and WSL(2) in Windows. I was an insiders user for a bit over a decade, and worked with .Net and C# since it was "ASP+" ... I had setup a dual boot when I swapped my old GTX 1080 for an RX 5700XT, figuring the "open source" drivers would give me a good Linux experience... it didn't. Every other update was a blank/black screen and me without a good remote config to try to recover it. After about 6 months it was actually stable, but I'd since gone ahead and paid too much for an RTX 3080, and gone back to my windows drive... I still used WSL almost all day, relying mostly on VS Code and a Browser open, terminal commands through WSL remoting in Code and results etc. on the browser. Then, one day, I clicked the trusty super/win menu and started typing in the name of he installed program I wanted to run... a freaking ad. In the start menu search results. I mean, it was a beta channel of windows, but the fact that anyone thought this was a good idea and it got implemented, I was out. I rebooted my personal desktop back to Linux... ran all the updates and it's run smoothly since. My current RX 9070XT better still, couldn't be happier. And it does everything I want it to do, and there's enough games in Steam through Proton that I can play what I want, when I want. Even the last half year on Pop Coxmic pre-release versions was overall less painful than a lot of my Windows experiences the past few years. Still not perfect, but at least it'…
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
I've been using 30s and 40s just fine with both nvidia and nvidia-open so every time I see this I don't really understand what card or game we're talking about. On the other hand when I tried a 6xx0 XT I always ran into an infamous "ring gfx timeout" GPU crash with certain applications on WINE [0]. Ended up giving that card to a cousin. [0] Examples: https://forum.endeavouros.com/t/rant-ring-gfx-0-0-0-timeout-... https://forum.endeavouros.com/t/amdgpu-ring-gfx-0-0-0-timeou...
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
The problem is that the specs of AMD consumer-grade GPUs do not translate to computer performance when you try and chain more than one together. I have 7 NVidia 4090s under my desk happily chugging along on week long training runs. I once managed to get a Radeon VII to run for six hours without shitting itself.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
Honestly it is a trust issue. I almost bought a framework laptop last year. People pitched it as a seriously viable alternative to the MacBook and applied social pressure to give it serious consideration. I realize now that it would have been a serious waste of a large amount of money and time and yes, that is a trust issue. And you can say “well that wasn’t the official framework org” but they’re kinda holding themselves out as a serious contender (marketing on LTT etc) yet apparently don’t have things as basic as working Linux drivers (in their officially supported choice of distro)! I think there is indeed a general belief among the public that you need to at least get that far before holding yourself out for public consumption, as a non-beta product, yeah. When you do those sorts of things it’s clearly not being held out as an enthusiast device for tinkering etc, and then people will have some (reasonable) expectations that it’s gonna actually work . If not, arguably it’s FTC time at that point. It’s kinda the same as AMD graphics drivers on windows… having the fans repeatedly insist they’ve never had a driver issue for 10 years now (when Vega, rdna1, and rdna3 all had major issues that lasted a significant amount of time) does destroy trust among the public when they try it and see it’s not true. Nothing feels worse than recommending them to a friend based on seeming internet consensus and having them have problems over the advice I gave them. Spent a lot of time trying…
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
1. Driver stability 2. Works on more consumer grade cards 3. Ecosystem advantage (lots of software developed against an existing and well supported ecosystem) I have a laptop with a mobile 2060 and a desktop with a top-of-the-line consumer 7900XTX. As of yet, the 7900XTX isn't officially supported (and I haven't bothered to go down the obnoxious rabbit hole to figure out how to compute on it). Meanwhile, I can load up CUDA.jl on my laptop in mere minutes with absolutely no fuss.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
I was so disappointed with the 7970 and 680 era of cards because the one time AMD launched first they priced a mid size die as if it was a top end card and Nvidia followed suit renaming the x70 card to the 680 as competition. It marked the beginning of the period where cards have got more expensive and renamed over and over. The 580 in pedigree looked a lot more like a Titan card/x90 does today than any x80. An x80 today is a x60 class card of that era in terms of die size, memory bus width and power consumption targets and a host of other core big measures of GPU design. They have both been at it gradually increasing prices to the point where a mid range card of a decade ago now costs 5x as much and twice the price of an entire console. It's got pretty insane this generation with marginal gains and massive price hikes and another set of renaming cards to step the dies down again. Finally no one is buying them but these companies are big enough they will just blame the overall economy anyway.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
It's far more complicated than that. Take a look at the Nvidia Frameworks Support Matrix[0]. The Nvidia PyTorch Docker container is 20GB uncompressed(!!!!) and consists of dozens of layers of Nvidia/CUDA tailored software stacks[1] that all come together to do this magical ML/AI stuff we take for granted on CUDA hardware. BTW, we have a nice, clean Nvidia CUDA docker situation because Nvidia has been working on it for years. It's rock solid and universally supported. Moving to a lower level, check out the release notes for the latest Nvidia driver and look in amazement at the sheer number of supported GPUs[2]. In short, literally every GPU they've put in a laptop, desktop, workstation, or datacenter over the past decade (plus their embedded Jetson stuff). There are over 2,000 GPUs listed there and I can tell you from experience the "Unified" in CUDA holds up. If the card is supported by the driver, it has a compatible compute arch, and enough VRAM whatever you throw at it will just work. In many cases even on Windows! People complain about the proprietary driver but the fact is if your GPU says Nvidia on it you can install the one driver on any distro and have these projects up and running in minutes. Compare that to the ROCm "list"[3] of what, maybe a dozen GPUs? I know from experience (unfortunately) that even with "supported" hardware in many cases just getting the driver to work is a nightmare. Then you have basic frameworks randomly crashing, etc. It's a complete mess an…
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Doesn’t like it
I have the opposite configurations of my machines (my desktop has an AMD GPU, but my laptop has an Nvidia), and my experience has been that the Nvidia stuff requires a lot more tinkering to get working. Because the laptop is an "Optimus" configuration (i.e. integrated graphics are used for most things, but the Nvidia card can be used for offloading), I need to use `nvidia-prime` ( https://archlinux.org/packages/extra/any/nvidia-prime/ ) to launch things I want to run on the discrete GPU. I've had a lot of issues with the GPU overheating by default the past few driver versions, which I currently work around by disabling `nvidia-powerd` and then invoking `nvidia-smi -pl` with a custom power limit on boot. The power limit feature was only enabled one or two driver versions ago though; before that was enabled, the only setting I could find to try to mitigate the overheating when it first started happening was setting a custom max clock speed with `nvidia-smi -lgc`, which was somewhat less effective. Before the power limiting feature got enabled, I noticed a bizarre related issue during overheating where specific keys (the '1', 'a', and tab keys, but never any of the others around them) intermittently miss inputs. From googling, it seems like keyboard issues due to overheating isn't uncommon, but I couldn't find anyone with as specific issues as I was having. On a whim, I tried switching to using X11 instead of Wayland, and the keyboard issues confusingly didn't happen even when t…
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
My totally user/curious 2 sats experience: I've recently tried to play with Stable Diffusion. I have an RTX 3060, a base M1 MBP and a laptop with an AMD RX6800m. - The RTX 3060 just works. Setup was straightforward, performance is good. - The M1 has those neural engine thingies but it's not compatible with SD. It can run SD on CPU but if you want to make use of the NE you need coreml specific programs and models. Issue here is that it's just not the same stuff. Prompt structure is also different. It doesn't recognize weights and put a lot more emphasis on prompt order. Most of the time it seems to ignore most of what you wrote. On the positive side running stuff on the NE is very fast and doesn't seem to be taxing to the system. - Finally the 6800M. It should be the powerhouse of the bunch considering its gaming performance ahead of the 3060. Problem is AMD toolkit kinda sucks. They have this obscure ROCm HIP stuff that acts as some kind of translation layer to the CUDA API. It's complicated, it simply doesn't work without a bunch of obscure environment variables and only works on fp32 mode, which means it uses twice amount of video RAM for the same thing. Support is iffy as they seem to only support workstation cards. Using it often throws lots of obscure compilation errors. Bugs celebrating anniversary. To sum things up, Nvidia is far ahead of the curve in both usability and performance. Apple is trying to do its thing but it's too early yet while AMD is in a messy situatio…
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Doesn’t like it
Basically anything recent but not the latest components will work well. If you want hassle-free then going with amd everything is the most efficient IMO. I'm running a ryzen 3600 and a radeon rx5700xt, and i've not had any driver issues, be it with x11 or wayland. I've been playing a bunch of games from my library but there are still some games that aren't compatible (for ex. Vermintide 2 has non-compatible anticheat) so i keep a spartan windows instal on a 128gb ssd for those and VR. VR is a non-starter on linux. That being said, nvidia has RT cores now, which can do very fast matrix multiplication which is advantageous for ML workloads (on top of a lot of ml work being optimized for cuda cores). Can't speak to their drivers but older cards should be safer, especially considering the 40 series hasn't been shown to be worth it over used 30 series.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Neutral
I bought a 1060 for 300€ in the mining boom in 2017 and later switched to an RX580 for 100€ (sold and bought). Now I'm thinking of buying a new GPU if the prices are down enough for me to justify it. The RX580 just isn't enough for my 1440p@144Hz E.g. I had to use FSR 1.0 with Ghostrunner to achieve the 100+ fps I want. And that just doesn't look good enough. For my Steam Deck 40Hz is fine, since I play with joysticks.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Recommends it
Just don't bother with AMD if you want wide support for deep learning. While it is getting better, CUDA is king and will remain so for the future. I had an AMD GPU and I gave up and bought an Nvidia one for ML workloads. The gaming features are also superior to AMD's equivalents as well, like RTX and DLSS.
AMD Radeon: Likes itNvidia GeForce: Doesn’t like it
I just got stable diffusion working on a 2011 era desktop. The GPU and boot SSD are a month old though. I somehow bought one of the cheapest currently-working GPUs: a ~$300 Radeon RX6600XT w 8GB RAM. I'd like to claim foresight, but I explicitly decided not to spring for a beefy ML card. I got it because my old NVIDIA GTX570 can't run xscreensaver any more and is missing a video codec I wanted. It takes the radeon under 2 minutes to generate a batch of images.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
Also, he's using an AMD graphics card. AMD GPUs are infamous for stuttering issues and framerate problems on Windows. I tried a RX580 pre-pandemic and it was both a space heater with massive power consumption, framerates were wildly inconsistent in several games, and I had game crashes. Switched to a GTX1060 and boom, problems gone.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itNvidia GeForce: Likes it
The part about them being buggy is definitely true. Up until somewhere around 2016-2017 the ATI/AMD drivers were really bad. I had an "HD 7850" GPU on Linux around that time and it was barely usable. The performance was less than half of what you got on Windows, and the drivers would crash very often, sometimes several times a day if I was trying to play games like Team Fortress 2. It was so bad that I decided to replace the HD 7850 with a new GTX 970 and decided to not buy anymore AMD GPUs for the indefinite future. The GTX 970 was stable and performed very well with the closed source drivers, and other than them being closed source I never had an issue with them. I always installed the closed drivers through the system package manager which handled all of the tricky stuff for me (Arch Linux maintains the nvidia driver as a system package and makes sure it runs on the current kernel before releasing it). In modern times the situation has flipped though. I still haven't bought an AMD GPU since then but I am pretty sure my next one will be.