The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Radeon vs AMD Ryzen

Hacker News owners lean toward the AMD Ryzen.

AMD RadeonAMD Ryzen
Owners with an opinion232355
Positive verdicts59% of 19077% of 265
Positive/negative since 202462/45109/24
Happy after 3+ years75
Longest happy owner14 yrs7 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Radeon: NeutralAMD Ryzen: Likes it
I feel like most benchmarks don’t really capture CPU benefits to gaming. It’s even difficult to find CPU benchmarks that don’t overemphasize 1080p and eSports scenarios. My upgrade from 5600x3D to 9850x3D felt kind of dumb at the time, but I decided to do it because Micro Center’s bundle deals are so far below market pricing. I was shocked at how much better it is. Benchmarks and FPS don’t really show things like micro stutters and little performance wrinkles like that. I’m not even sure 1% low FPS counts capture it. A great example game for this is Oblivion Remastered. Upgrading my CPU alone with the same GPU took away the environment loading slowdown almost entirely. The benchmark will tell you that I didn’t gain any FPS during gameplay but every time I open a door into the new environment my CPU is positively impacting the experience. I would have said the exact same thing you are saying until I actually experienced upgrading to the best on the market. For the record, this is the first time in my life I’ve actually owned the best CPU on the market for gaming. My old advice would have been to buy one of those sweet spot cheaper mid-range gaming CPUs, but my newer advice is really if you’ve already spent all that you’re willing to spend on a GPU (I have a 9070XT, my only upgrade paths are insanely expensive), buy the highest gaming CPU on the list for gaming benchmarks (e.g., I wouldn’t go crazy with a 9950X3D2 since it doesn’t have any gaming improvements above the 9850X3D)…
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
AMD software is often utter trash. I am a diehard fanboy of their GPUs, and have been since they were still ATI but I had to finally purchase an nvidia GPU because of how bad AMDs software quality is. My powerful 5700XT spent two years basically broken, because the default, driver provided fan curve locked the fan at 27%. For two years, I couldn't figure out why my GPU constantly crashed, because it was overheating, because the default fan curve prevented the GPU from keeping itself cool and it would eventually just give up. That diagnoses was complicated by the fact that AMD GPUs just resetting is very common. There's a watchdog timer in Windows that resets parts of the GPU stack because Microsoft is traumatized by 60% of Windows Vista BSODs being caused by bad nvidia drivers. Apparently sometimes if you increase this watchdog timer, the GPU eventually finishes whatever was giving it trouble. But I still love AMD, and the ryzen line is a great value in the mid range. So I bought another AMD CPU and am very happy with it. But it somehow included software and this specific auto updater utility. Which I don't need, since I don't want to update the drivers for a GPU that I shouldn't be using (maybe except some video encoding lift, but my GPU can do that too). But I could not figure out a way to kill or prevent this stupid little autoupdater utility which always steals focus , for no reason at all. It shouldn't even be popping up a CLI! Windows task scheduling is incredible an
AMD Radeon: NeutralAMD Ryzen: Likes it
For sure. I moved from setup with an i7-6700k and a gtx 1070 to one with a 5900x and an rx 6900xt, and in games the upgrade wasn't really as strong as you might expect. Code compilation, hashing, rendering were all markedly faster though. That old PC became a perfectly serviceable hand me down after 5 years of service, and I hope to get another 5 out of this rig. Pretty cool that we're seeing longevity and some progress at the same time.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
My wife has been gaming on a fourth-gen i5 + RX 570 for a few months, and it was mostly fine until Halo Infinite— with that title it was pretty clear that she was CPU bound, with the system chugging on open areas, mob AI, particles, etc. We upgraded her to a second hand B450 mobo + Ryzen 2400 and that's been fine. Still running on low settings due to the limited GPU, but everything is at least playable. And this motherboard has FW updates that support 5xxx series Ryzens, so there's upgrade headroom there now as well.
AMD Radeon: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like it
Because M3 Pro is not a real thing as far as actual agentic workflows go. I run dual R9700 boxes those idle at 150W Because of a Ryzen AM5, and I run Spark boxes, which are decent But still idle at 45-50 watts a pop. My favorite, to be honest, is a 5090 with a Qwen 27B because that one is good for quick hitters and flies, But again, the box itself idles at 140 watts. So it's really the idle power that I don't like And it's too much of an inconvenience to power boxes down and power them back on, so they just end up running and sucking electricity. I am working on getting some sort of a smarter proxy setup where I would give boxes time to wake up and go to the cloud while they're waking up. So the whole point of having these things running in the background is that you do want them to be almost always available. So power consumption is definitely an issue.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
I'm still using Xorg after all these years, on a laptop with 150% scaling, which I occasionally plug into an external monitor with 100% scaling. Somewhat surprisingly, it works great. (Cinnamon desktop, Ryzen 7840u integrated graphics. And also a desktop machine with Radeon RX 6800XT, but it's not surprising that still works great.)
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
That's so far from my personal idea of "running it till the wheels fall off" that your comment genuinely reads like a parody of an out of touch wealthy person trying to justify their wild spending habits. I've been using the same PC that I built in 2013 continuously since then. Every four or five years or so I'll buy one part in the $500 range to keep it updated. It's currently got a Ryzen 7800X3D, 32GB DDR5, and a Radeon RX 6700XT, so it's easily outperforming a brand new $3000 Macbook Pro in most workloads that I actually care about. My initial investment in it was $1200. My total investment over the last 12 years has been about $3000. Buying disposable computers simply does not make any financial sense to me.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
> Support your graphics cards on linux using kernel drivers that you upstream. All of them. Not just a handful - all the ones you sell from say 18 months ago till today. All the stuff works even if it's not officially supported. It's not that hard to set a single environment variable (HSA_OVERRIDE_GFX_VERSION). Like literally, everything works, from Vega 56/64 to ryzen 99xx iGPUs. Also, try nixos. Everything literally works with a single config entry after recent merge of rocm 6.3. I successfully run a zoo of various radeons of different generations.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
I had a laptop with a mobile GeForce RTX 4060 - it was a pain to run Linux on, mainly because of Nvidia. I got rid of it and built myself a PC (not just because of Nvidia, gaming laptops are just a disappointing experience). And went all in with Team Red - Ryzen and Radeon. It's a joy to run Linux on, I work on it and have played several games - 0 problems. Nvidia may be the leader in performance, but if it means you're stuck with Windows - I'd say it's not worth it.
AMD Radeon: NeutralAMD Ryzen: Neutral
You don't need to wait for Valve to get this experience today. The HTPC build of Bazzite [1] brings an experience identical to SteamOS to all computers with an AMD or Intel GPU from the past 8 years or so. It works amazingly well and I can't imagine going back to Windows for a PC that is built only for video games. I use it on my "Gaming HTPC" (Ryzen 3600, Radeon RX6600, Fractal Design Node 202) and it brings a great console experience to my TV, with access to my PC game library, without being locked into a console ecoystem, and without the enormous cruft and user hostility that Windows has you manage these days. I'm a pretty casual and patient gamer, and for that use case this Steam machine experience is unmatched - despite being built on desktop Linux, it works out of the box and requires zero manual maintenance. For dedicated gaming boxes this Linux user experience is significantly better and easier to use than Windows - we're truly living in the future. [1]: https://bazzite.gg [2]: It's built on top of Fedora and Universal Blue, so under the hood it's different from SteamOS which is built on a custom immutable version of Arch Linux. However, that implementation detail is actually almost totally irrelevant if you want to play games since all software is managed by Steam and Flatpak on both systems.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
Agreed. I was sorely tempted by the Mac studio, but ended up with a 96GB ram Ryzen 7900 (12 core) + Radeon 7800 XT (16GB vram). It was a fraction of the price and easy to add storage. The Mac M2 studio was tempting, but wasn't refreshed for the M3 generation. It really bothered me that the storage was A) expensive, B) proprietary, C) tightly controlled, and D) you can't boot without internal storage. Even moving storage between Apple studios can be iffy. Would I be able to replace the storage if it died in 5 years? Or expand it? As tempting as the size, efficiency, and bandwidth were I just couldn't justify top $ without knowing how long it would be useful. Sad they just didn't add two NVMe ports or make some kind of raw storage (NVMe flash, but without the smarts).
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
Basically anything recent but not the latest components will work well. If you want hassle-free then going with amd everything is the most efficient IMO. I'm running a ryzen 3600 and a radeon rx5700xt, and i've not had any driver issues, be it with x11 or wayland. I've been playing a bunch of games from my library but there are still some games that aren't compatible (for ex. Vermintide 2 has non-compatible anticheat) so i keep a spartan windows instal on a 128gb ssd for those and VR. VR is a non-starter on linux. That being said, nvidia has RT cores now, which can do very fast matrix multiplication which is advantageous for ML workloads (on top of a lot of ml work being optimized for cuda cores). Can't speak to their drivers but older cards should be safer, especially considering the 40 series hasn't been shown to be worth it over used 30 series.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
The high end these days is insane. Huge diminishing returns in performance/watt and performance/cost. My current mid-range gaming PC (Ryzen 5600X, Radeon 6700XT) uses about the same amount of power as my 2008 mid-range PC (Core2 Q6600, GeForce 8800 GTS 512) while of course running laps around it in performance. Unfortunately this current generation across the board seems to be throwing GHz at the problem as if we didn't learn our lesson from Pentium 4.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
I like multiple monitors too! I loved the two 32” 4K LG 32UD99-W monitors I used to have. Those were perfect too. Only switched to the 55” OLED TV because I lost those monitors—One had to to back to the company that provided it for working at home… aaaaand I broke the other. With big top-heavy monitors I have learned the lesson that all surfaces must be grippy towards each other under all circumstances. Also when and if the drawer-stand put under the monitor scooches 1mm out of the desktop area and off its grip-pads. Actually the lesson is: Always just get adjustable gas-pump monitor arms for everything. Less clutter, more desk space, more flexibility, better ergonomics. It’s even more worth it than I suspected it would be. They cost less than I thought and make a bigger difference. I have a nice little Ryzen 3900X machine. Reasonably lucky silicon - it runs at 4.2GHz at a slightly reduced voltage. 2 × 16GB DDR4-3200 CL14 sticks which are happy at 3400MHz CL14. I don’t recall the rank – it’s Crucial BallistiX. The sticks were too expensive for what they do! – I bought them as an experiment to see what the difference was if I got the fastest memory I could find without going to the scary steep part of the price-performance curve. There is a difference!, but not strictly worth it. GPUs: I have Radeons – 5700 XT and 6800 XT. Those are overkill for development-only but very nice. The 6800 XT is smoother and snappier at driving a 4K desktop! I’m curious how the 6600 XT is. (I…
AMD Radeon: NeutralAMD Ryzen: Neutral
For laptops, maybe. I just built a desktop with a 5900X and a 6900XT, expecting to not be able to get my hands on an MSRP 7000-series CPU or GPU for a long while after their release. Not to mention the shortage of DDR5. Plus, with the affordable gaming PC market being behind by about 2 years now thanks to lockdowns, video game developers are probably expecting to release their games with lower spec requirements than they otherwise would have if everything continued on pace as usual.
AMD Radeon: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
For me personally, my preference primarily comes down to extreme differences in low-intensity/idle power usage of Ryzen 6000 vs Intel 12th gen. There aren't true "apples to apples" (same chassis/model, but AMD vs Intel) comparisons yet, although those should be coming in the next month or so, but here's an example of how efficient the Ryzen 6000s are: https://youtu.be/3bSetglEPOY?t=170 For people that need to use their devices on the go, I think it's a no brainer to prefer a Ryzen 6000 vs Intel. The RDNA2-based Radeon 680M iGPU also significantly outperforms the (admittedly, much improved) Intel Xe iGPUs in 3D rendering. In synthetics, the new Radeon iGPUs are going head to head with Nvidia 1650 Max-Q dGPUs. This probably doesn't much matter if you aren't doing any gaming, but if you are, it means you can play most modern titles reasonably on the road in a thin and light form factor without giving up any battery life when you aren't.