The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Radeon RX vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX

Hacker News owners slightly favor the NVIDIA GeForce RTX.

AMD Radeon RXNVIDIA GeForce RTX
Owners with an opinion119617
Positive verdicts72% of 8876% of 416
Positive/negative since 202438/11214/71
Happy after 3+ years210
Longest happy owner6 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and value
Criticized forsoftwarenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Radeon RX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
It used to be that for locally running GenAI, VRAM per dollar was king, so used NVidia RTX 3090 cards were the undisputed darlings of DYI LLM with 24GB for 600€-800€ or so. Sticking two of these in one PC isn't too difficult despite them using 350W each. Then Apple introduced Macs with 128 GB and more unified memory at 800GB/s and the ability to load models as large as 70GB (70b FP8) or even larger ones. The M1 Ultra was unable to take full advantage of the excellent RAM speed, but with the M2 and the M3, performance is improving. Just be prepared to spend 5000€ or more for a M3 Ultra. Another alternative would be a EPYC 9005 system with 12x DDR5-6000 RAM for 576GB/s of memory bandwidth with the LLM (preferably MoE) running on the CPU instead of a GPU. However today, with the latest, surprisingly good reasoning models like QwQ-32B using up thousands or tens of thousands of tokens in their replies, performance is getting more important than previously and these systems (Macs and even RTX 3090s) might fall out of favor, because waiting for a finished reply will take several minutes or even tens of minutes. Nvidia Ampere and Apple silicon (AFAIK) are also missing FP4 support in hardware, which doesn't help. For the same reason AMD Halo Strix with a mere 273GB/s of RAM bandwidth and perhaps also NVidia Project Digits (also speculated to offer similar RAM bandwidth) might just be too slow for reasoning models with more than 50GB or so of active parameters. On the other hand, if th…
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Even 200B for 3k USD is really good, 128 GB of memory for that price is surprising! Right now using a two RTX 2080 setup for a pilot project, where it runs ollama and qwen2.5-coder (14B quantized version), a more serious step up from there on a budget would realistically be an RX 7900 XTX (24 GB, though I've had issues with setting up ROCm) for 1k EUR or RTX A5000 (24 GB) for 2.5k EUR in the current market. Honestly, I don't even need the best performance for what I'm trying to do, even an Arc A770 (16 GB) for 350 EUR would be enough to iterate, except that it's not actually supported by ollama and lots of stuff out there: https://github.com/ollama/ollama/blob/main/docs/gpu.md (I know ollama isn't the only solution, but it sucks when the tools you like aren't available)
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
You could at least give an example. You claimed that AMD can’t make software, full stop. That’s not a fair analysis. I switched to an AMD card last year and I’m playing games old and new without any sort of issues. I even think the driver software is easier to use than Nvidia and I like how I don’t have the ugly 1990s Nvidia control panel anymore. I also like how I don’t have to login to an account for automatic driver updates like I did with the GeForce Experience application. Plus, you can turn off telemetry in AMD software, where that’s not even an option for Nvidia. My last card was a 3070 and so far my upgrade to the 7800XT has been excellent. No difference in software has affected me in any perceptible way.
AMD Radeon RX: Recommends itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
Yea you gotta just go AMD gpu. I had an NVIDIA RTX 3070 and despite being decently technically proficient I could never deal with the hassle of Linux gaming. I bought an AMD 6950 XT and immediately many random issues I was having like league of legends crashing or bugging out just stopped. Granted I also switched from default fedora to fedora with the Sway WM so there are some confounding variables there. Even a brand new game like Starfield just worked™ for me, which was quite surprising. I do just leave Steam on Proton experimental so that may have something to do with it. Anyways, I'd recommend Linux gaming now to anyone if they have AMD hardware and value privacy. There are definitely still some quirks and typical Linux configuring but even for someone as impatient and intolerant to that stuff as me, it's been pretty good so far
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Perhaps RDNA3 GPUs get comparable results, but RDNA2 GPUs are behind. I bought a RX 6800XT to do some AI work because of the 16GB VRAM, and while the VRAM allows me to do stuff that my 6GB RTX 2060 wasn't able to, on performance side it's actually a downgrade in many aspects. But the main issue is software support. To get acceptable performance you need to use ROCm, which is Linux only. There was some Windows release of ROCm few weeks ago, but I am not sure how usable it is and none of the libraries have picked up on it yet. Even with a Linux installed, most frameworks still assume CUDA and it's an effort to get them to use ROCm. For some tools all it takes is uninstalling PyTorch or Tensorflow and installing a special ROCm enabled version of those libraries. Sometimes it will be enough, sometimes it wasn't. Sometimes the project uses some auxiliary library like bitsandbytes which doesn't have an official ROCm fork, so you have to use unofficial ones (that you have to compile manually and Makefiles quickly get out of date). Which once again, may work or may not. I have things set up for stable diffusion and text generation (oobabooga), and things mostly work, but sometimes they still don't. For example I can train stable diffusion embeddings and dreambooth checkpoints, but for some reason it crashes when I attempt to train a LORA. And I don't have enough expertise to debug it myself. For things like video encoding most tools also assume CUDA will be present so you're stuck wi…
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
In DDR3 era heat, drivers, crashes (lots of crashes) during gaming. In DDR4 era heat, drivers during game dev (substance painter, UE4 etc.). Lots of finicking with the card/drivers/software. On my home NAS (Ubuntu for longest time, now Kubuntu) I've had more random issues with my RX 580 than my 3060, I know it's not the most fair comparison due to their age but still.
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
I got a painful reminder of this in the spring. The RX 570 I had in my build died. I paid around $199 CAD for it. Retail for an RX 6400 was around double that, and based on benchmarks online, it would have provided worse performance, which is shocking 5 years later. I sucked up purchasing an RTX 3050 for around $400 since it was at least a performance increase, albeit not very high on the bang for my bucks scale.
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Whenever I try to use Mint theres always something weird that happens that won’t seamlessly install or something, most recently it was steam games not being able to start. A couple of years ago I installed Pop and the automatic tiling paired with Gnome was very offputting (I’v e gone back and forth with Pop Os because of gnome seemingly eating up memory), when, in previous installs, the tiling thing didn’t happen. Also I dont really like/understand relying on websites and browser extensions to modify gnome bits. I switched to Kubuntu and it was great… with an AMD gpu. I upgraded to a 6700xt a couple of months ago from a rx480 and it was great, but I sent it back and switched to an nvidia 3060ti because of being interested in dipping my feet in video editing. I found trying to use the nvidia gpu with Kubuntu was a real hassle I couldnt figure out (I couldnt log in even after running a command in safe mode installing nvidia drivers) so I went back to Pop and kind of grin and bear gnome because my new system has 64gigs of ram, the Pop team is working on their rust based DE, and because Pop can come with Nvidia drivers included. Regarding snaps, I really like that PopOS tells you whether a given package is a snap or deb and that you can choose (for now at least), but I try to avoid snaps myself.
Switched from the NVIDIA GeForce RTX to the AMD Radeon RXAMD Radeon RX: Likes it
7900XTX not 9700XTX which didn’t exist. 9070XT is RDNA4 not RDNA3 and steam machine has 28CU’s on RDNA3 which is same as RX7400 the bottom of the range RDNA3. The 7900XTX has 84 and 24GB of VRAM. This is a strictly entry level last gen GPU, don’t expect miracles. The hardware is not good unless the price is very cheap. As for the 7900XTX been enthusiast only in the sense it it was the top of the line from AMD it’s about 4080 in some areas and loses badly in others (ray tracing), price wise it wasn’t far of the 9070XT price wise at launch. I have a 7900XTX I like it a great deal but the 4090/5080 and 5090 crush it and the 90’s are enthusiast both on price and perf. I ended up with a 7900XTX because nvidia pissed me off on Linux one time too many otherwise I’d have gotten the 4090 but between kernel installs causing pain (nothing insurmountable) and them straight breaking power management for nearly a year on mature hardware, nah, AMD deserved the sale, they really do support Linux better.
AMD Radeon RX: Recommends itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Recommends it
So, you have DDR4? Pick any B550 with a VRM heatsink for $90, a 5600 for $190, and you are back in business. Get a 5070 or 9070 before GDDR supply is completely gone if you want an actual upgrade. As for GPU price, that Vega 64 was $500 in 2018. Even a midrange GPU hasn't been $300 since the Radeon RX 480 launched a decade ago.
AMD Radeon RX: Recommends itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Recommends it
Someone got ZLUDA running llama.cpp a while back (search the ZLUDA/llama.cpp issues). If I recall, it ran about half the speed of the existing ROCm implementation. I tried ROCm on my iGPU last year and you do get a bit of a benefit for prompt processing (5x faster) but inference is basically bottlenecked by the memory bandwidth whether you're on CPU or GPU. Here were my results: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kT4or6b0Fedd-W_jMwYp... Note, only GART memory, not GTT is accessible in most inferencing options, so you will only basically be able to load 7B quantized models into "VRAM" (BIOS controlled, but usually max out at 6-8GB). I have some notes on this here: https://llm-tracker.info/howto/AMD-GPUs#amd-apu If you plan on running a 7B-13B model locally, getting something like a RTX 3060 16GB (or if you're on Linux, the 7600 XT 16GB might be an option w/ HSA_OVERRIDE) is probably your cheapest realistic option and will give you about 300 GB/s of memory bandwidth and enough memory to run quantizes of 13/14B class models. If you're buying a card specifically for GenAI and not going to dedicate time to fight driver/software issues, I'd recommend going w/ Nvidia options first (they typically actually give you more Tensor TFLOPS/$ as well).
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
I don't even know what people are really asking for anymore. 4070, 7800XT, 4060, and 7600 were all incredibly high-value launches, and in January we're incredibly likely to get price drops on 12GB cards as well as 16GB cards at the old 4070 Ti price point. The value is there, just a fairly large faction of people have an emotional investment in pretending like it's perpetual doom-and-gloom. Consider the reaction when Microcenter started putting a $100 steam gift card on the already-attractive 4070 price. People still flipped a shit even though a de-facto $500 price was obviously about as good as any 4070-tier product would get for this gen (apart from the firesales at the end). https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/12v790e/100_s... https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/12ug1ql/it_ap... https://old.reddit.com/r/buildapcsales/comments/12ucq6b/gpu_... https://old.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/12ucljb/micro_cente... This is pretty much what super refresh is going to accomplish next month (a year later!) - 4070 will probably move down to $499-549, 4070 Super will be 95% of a 4070 Ti for $599-629, and 4070 Ti Super will offer 16GB at the same $749 price point. But people want a return to 2000s-level pricing (despite soaring wafer costs etc) and nothing short of that is going to satisfy some people. (and a fair number of people (including reviewers!) actively propagandize about these cards, like complaining the 4060 or 4060 Ti is actually slower than i…
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
> People who are into BSD don’t use BSD. This seems to be a reason for lacking hardware support. Ryzen 9 5650x - no issues AMD 5700 XT - no issues Nvidia 3070 - no issues Presonus - no issues While waiting for replacement morherboard I did a complete swap from AMD to Intel 4770k and no issues. Linux kernel panicked and Windows just BSOD. What issues are people having? Because the desktop runs like a charm, sound works. Internet and WiFi.
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
TDP of 450W Someone else made this point elsewhere but a 4090 can be CPU limited at 4K. It's 50% more performance with the same power draw as the 3090 Ti. Undervolting grants a 150W drop with a 5% drop in performance. The 40 series is looking spectacular so far. The RX 6xxx XT gen do better than the newer intel GPU and with a LOWER TDP!! close to half the TDP in fact! In rasterization. But the future of gaming is "DLSS" and ray-tracing. Both areas that AMD struggles so far. It's generally accepted, but muted in most reviews that both Intel and Nvidia are ahead in ray tracing and upscaling tech compared to AMD. It doesn't bode well for AMD's market has what appears to be a pretty competent opponent in that space now with Arc.