The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD Radeon RX vs AMD Ryzen

Hacker News owners slightly favor the AMD Ryzen.

AMD Radeon RXAMD Ryzen
Owners with an opinion119355
Positive verdicts72% of 8877% of 265
Positive/negative since 202438/11109/24
Happy after 3+ years25
Longest happy owner6 yrs7 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD Radeon RX: NeutralAMD Ryzen: Likes it
Just a funny anecdote: I got an i5 13600KF last black friday (with a long haul to Hong Kong for about 2 weeks) from Amazon, with initially a budget motherboard that I thought would be fine, and it turns out the system would keep turning off at one point and reboot again with a huge drop in voltage (it was about 10 months later that I learned this is a brownout). It was for my company computer, but I bought it personally, so the ownership is still mine. I then bought a new SF750 PSU at home and swapped the CPU for 13100 salvaged from a computer someone donated, so now the 13600KF would be my personal gaming rig. I made sure it gets a platform that sustain enough power and appropriate headroom for thermals, and it was all fine until 6 months ago, it starts to BSOD all over the place, when gaming; programming; or even just resume from suspend. I have to refund two games because of this, one is accepted and the other isn't. And also turn over to cloud machine for development because BSOD in the middle of debugging is really nasty. So I decided to say "fuck it, I'm going back to AMD". I actually still use my 3700X gig a year ago but I figured the 5 year old system is now becoming an old dog. I just can't run most modern game at even 80FPS, so I swapped to the 13600KF as an intermediate replacement until it glitched up, so I need another replacement again. Coincidentally I bought a 7945HX engineering sample ITX motherboard originally for the intent of running Kubernetes homelab (no…
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Neutral
> Put that in perspective with high-end machines with hardware concerned with performance and not power draw, that can easily idle at 100W. I've been trying to optimize my desktop's power consumption. At the beginning of the year I put the kill-a-watt on it and was shocked to see it was using 115W idle! I got it to 90W pretty quickly with some minor Linux tuning but was still pretty unhappy to see so much idle load. Recently though, I've got it idling at 57W, which makes me feel much better about it (although more than I'd want for a 24/7 load). 5700X cpu and RDNA4 9070XT video card. Dialing down unnecessary cooling helped more than I would have guessed. Under-volting the GPU -30mV may have helped but I'm not sure. Adjusting every governor I could find to powersave helps of course, and doesn't feel noticeably different. A lot I think is just that the new tuned daemon is way way way better at it's job than previous solutions like tlp was. I did have some problems with my Crucial P3+ NVMe drive not liking "powersupersave" PCIe Active State Power Management (aspm), but most improvements were a kernel setting away, and tuned really seemed to do . One of the thing I really love about modern computing is that I can just dial in power consumption under load. With the new RDNA4 video card, I was seeing 450W power consumption when gaming. But I can open CoreCtrl and tell it, no, use 70W, and for surprisingly little FPS hit my system is now down to ~155W. (Still looking for more co…
AMD Radeon RX: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like it
Windows is complex, and the hardware people run Windows is also complex. Shit can be weird. For one, I had a problem with my Ryzen 5600 CPU and RX-5700XT video card combo. There is some kind of incompatibility between these two, and one that I only experienced in Windows, and only in a few specific games, and only in specific scenarios in those games. One such was looking up on the sky in Anno 1800, a strategy game. Look up the sky, and Windows reboots in one minute. This experience is rare, evidenced by the many normal benchmarks and gameplays that exist with this, and similar combos. But other people also experienced it, such as this user: https://www.reddit.com/r/buildapc/comments/xxrg3h/my_pc_rx_5... I have since swapped my 5700 xt to a 6600 xt, and the issue went away. The new owner of the 5700 xt is also happy as a clam at high tide. I'd wager that maybe a few hundred of people experienced this at most.
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Neutral
Not as powerful of a setup, but I have a 5800X, 32 GB of RAM, and an RX 6800 XT on a 4K monitor, and I got 5 FPS on the main menu (which was showing an empty grass field). I had to set my resolution to 1080p in order to get anything remotely resembling performance (this change alone took main menu FPS from 5 to ~55), plus disabling motion blur, depth of field, and volumetrics, and turning model fidelity down. I've also heard that disabling vsync can make a huge difference, but it didn't affect things for me.
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
Right now I'm battling the rough edges around the RX 5500 XT support. If you try and use 3 monitors it reliably crashes. You can kind of make it work by manually setting monitors.xml to a low resolution on them or a low refresh rate before you add the third monitor, but that only seems to work if you add the monitor at runtime. I copied the same monitors.xml for gdm as well so no clue what during initialization seems to be crashing it only if it's during boot. I've tried all the way up to DRM-next, mesa-git, latest linux-firmware and so far I'm stuck with 2 out of 3 screens. I've also got a new 3700X and that's been completely stable.
AMD Radeon RX: NeutralAMD Ryzen: Neutral
For those wondering about AMD performance, I did some very brief testing. I have an Radeon RX 7900 XTX graphics card and a Ryzen 7800X3D running Fedora 41 with Proton Experimental on a 1920x1200 display. I booted into the Ravenholm level and immediately got mid-50 FPS with no obvious stuttering. The framerate jumped over 70 once I got inside the first couple buildings. Those framerates are not ideal given the cost of my hardware, but I'd consider them to be perfectly playable. Or at least I would if not for the bigger problem... The image quality was extremely blurry such that I could not clearly see anything over 10ft/3m away. There were no obvious graphics options I could change to fix this. I don't know if this is a result of some upscaling tech not working with my AMD card, a weird Proton issue, an anti-aliasing or depth-of-field feature gone horribly wrong, or something else entirely. Regardless, I'd consider it to be unplayable until the blur issue is resolved.
AMD Radeon RX: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like it
27w idle with monitor off is 3x what I've managed in my Ryzen, with the old 1700 or the new 5700x. I am just in awe at how frustrating annoying and hellish power management has been. I've wasted ghastly amounts of time trying to tame this beast, but it just does a terrible job idling. Powertop, tlp, kernel aspm powersupersave, countless more: I've tried things after things after things. Combed through the bios again and again. So few real wins, nothing like what I would have expected. Then I thought, well, if it's not something I can justify running 24/7, I'll get suspend or hibernate working so I can at least use it when I need it, without losing my whole desktop. I started out of the gate trying to get wireless wake on lan working, but pretty quickly realize even good ole failsafe/fallback hibernate isn't working?! (Maybe I just need to point at the swap partition for hibernate?) I have to 120 reset after trying to sleep! It's just been criminal how bad the power support on this system is. I tried Windows for the heck of it, and suspend & hibernate didn't work their either. I tried downtuning my rx580, and it got worse! The mclcks seem to stay pegged, so power consumption on desktop idle went from like 7w to 23w! Bah!