The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

AMD FX vs AMD Ryzen

Hacker News owners slightly favor the AMD Ryzen.

AMD FXAMD Ryzen
Owners with an opinion13355
Positive verdicts73% of 1177% of 265
Positive/negative since 20242/2109/24
Happy after 3+ years15
Longest happy owner10 yrs7 yrs
Praised forperformance and durabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized fornoisenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

AMD FX: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
I've been using AMD since 2004. My first AMD processor was the Athlon 64 3000+, I was a kid I wasn't really allowed anything too expensive. We had dominately used Intel upt that point but when 64bit CPUs hit it was a revolutionary thing. The roughest era of AMD CPUs was the FX era. While it was comprable to its mid-range competition it was alos a sure fast way to burn down your house with its power draw. Ryzen was a huge step forward in CPU design and architecture. I see this era as Intel's FX era, if they have the right leadership in place they can turn the boat around and innovate.
AMD FX: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
> However it might actually be the inferior gaming machine for CPU/main RAM intense strategy or simulation games (e.g. Stellaris). On Stellaris I remember having a pretty good experience (not stellar) playing on a 2012 AMD FX-8350 desktop cpu. The six year old midrange laptop cpu Ryzen 4650u smokes that desktop cpu. https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare/1780vs3766/AMD-FX-8350-... Just to draw out the fact that with the Steam machine you will have a better Stellaris experience than what I had 7-8 years ago. (Because I assume even better performance than this laptop class cpu) My thoughts go more on the question if 15GB ram 8GB VRAM is enough for the next 7 years. And if Steam verified will all be split up, and become more confusing, between the 3 different devices they have.
AMD FX: Likes itAMD Ryzen: Likes it
These were interesting results then, but I think code generation and OSes have evolved enough that current compiles on a current OS with a current toolchain are actually faster on an FX-8150 than on an i5 of the age from those results. Even from the time that Ryzen first came out until now, OSes have been improving threading, reducing contention, et cetera, to noticeable degrees. Tell you what - when I'm back on the coast that has my older machines, I'll run some modern compiles on a quad i5 of that era and on my FX-8150, and we'll see. If nothing else, perhaps it'll be interesting to see how much threading performance has improved in the last decade. BTW - I did do side-by-side testing back then between the quad i7 and the FX-8150, and the results were certainly not as clear cut as these. Then again, I wasn't building a huge, barely portable source tree with -J 8 like Chromium - I was building many separate things in parallel at the same time. The cost is what ultimately tipped me in favor of AMD. Not everyone who bought AMD then was necessarily a fanboi, and I'd point out that people who were fans of the Ryzens when they were new often liked both how they were very favorably priced compared with anything Intel, plus how we were assured that later Ryzens would work in our then current motherboards. Having just replaced a Ryzen 2600 with a Ryzen 5700X and seeing overall power usage go down, I'd have to disagree with your early Ryzen sentiment.
AMD FX: Doesn’t like itAMD Ryzen: Doesn’t like it
price-to-performance is the last resort of a company that has failed at taking the performance crown. Nobody cuts prices more than they have to , but everyone adjusts prices to where they need to go to sell the product. Bulldozer was priced low because it was genuine garbage, it was actually slower than Phenom in a lot of cases (which blows the "it was about price to peformance!" thing out of the water - nobody regresses performance on purpose). (and before people wind up about the obvious counterexample: Ryzen was priced low because a 1800X was genuinely a lot slower than a 5960X in productivity tasks due to latency and poor AVX performance, and got completely smoked in gaming. If they had tried to go head-to-head with Intel at $1000 pricing they wouldn't have sold anything because it would have been a far inferior package to what Intel offered, they had to cut prices by around half to make it a compelling offering. And even then it was not that appealing compared to, say, a 5820K.) Companies need to make enough of a showing to attract consumers but if a company prices something super aggressively, there's often a catch. And that's bulldozer in a nutshell. Oh shit the product sucks. What can we charge for a mediocre "8-core" (sorta) that underperforms the 4-core i7? Offer it at i5 pricing and see if anyone bites. If they had managed to achieve good performance, they would have priced it appropriately. (the other thing is - people prefer to make the comparison…