The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Amazon Kindle vs reMarkable 2

Hacker News owners lean toward the Amazon Kindle.

Amazon KindlereMarkable 2
Owners with an opinion1124161
Positive verdicts72% of 89865% of 129
Positive/negative since 2024321/15027/24
Happy after 3+ years693
Longest happy owner15 yrs5 yrs
Praised forease of use and displayease of use and display
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Kindle: NeutralreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
> This is actually the biggest reason I own a Remarkable 2/Kindle Scribe, let's me "destroy" the book while also not having to worry about losing my notes. Well... I'm mostly back to paper after losing most of the notes I had taken on my own Remarkable 2.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Neutral
I have a boox note 3, I don't love it. I barely use it. Have a remarkable 2 but spouse stole it when I iddn't use it much. I bought a scribe and used it more. I had 2 sets of classes this spring. I used the crap out of the scribe. I tried the boox for it and went back to the scribe. All I was doing was taking written notes in class and using it as infinte paper for doing homeworks. The boox takes forever to wake up and just is more laggy. It was usable for reading stuff in google docs outside but an umbrella and a laptop worked better. That said all 3 have amazing battery life, they'd all last all semester on a charge.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itreMarkable 2: Likes it
I've tried out all the e-ink note taking devices (Kindle Scribe, Boox Go 10.3, Remarkable 2, and Remarkable Paper Pro). The Kindle Scribe can't really compete with the others right now since the software is so limited. I'd only get it if you were a huge Kindle user that very occasionally wanted to take some notes. Otherwise, the Remarkable 2 or Remarkable Paper Pro are your best bets. Those are absolutely excellent products that don't overwhelm you with distractions.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Neutral
Like you, I have an old offline eReader (4th gen Kindle, replaced battery). My eReader lasts multiple books of use on one full charge. I also have a ReMarkable 2. The battery lasts about 14-16hrs of on-time for me. I keep it in airplane mode and have sleep mode disabled to prevent it from locking after 40 minutes. I turn it on around 10AM and turn it off at 5PM, writing on it sporadically between those hours. The tablet reaches a low battery state by Wednesday.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
I have a Remarkable 2 and I would say is not that good at reading PDF documents or ebook files (mobi, & epub). Very slow at loading documents and moving forth and back between pages is worse when compared to a Kindle. Remarkable 2 strength is mainly focus on creating notes to read.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
The Remarkable 2 is a good device. I used one heavily for a few months, mainly for work related things but also personal stuff. So far so good. However, there are a few things I personally didn't like: 1. Battery life. Not bad, but I expected more from a eink device. I had to charge it every 1 or 2 weeks. I expected a battery life more similar to my Kindle Oasis which I charge once in a month. 2. The OCR was useless, at least in my case. (I have to admit I have a pretty messi handwritting) 3. The navegation across menus was frustrating sometimes. I had to tap hard several times for opening a folder. 4. The ebook/pdf reading capability was not a first class citizen. 5. The export of notes to files must be done one by one. (Not sure if still the case) Overall, a decent device. However, I have to admit I ended up selling it on eBay and buying a Samsung Tab S8+. I needed a more versatile device.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
I never picked up a reMarkable because its DPI is ~220. The Kindle Scribe solves this with 300 DPI.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
I honestly cannot see the value in ReMarkable after the Kindle Scribe announcement. The kindle has a newer faster, 300dpi display vs 226dpi on the ReMarkable. I am waiting on reviews before ordering one for myself, but I can already see that Kindle Scribe is going to be disruptive for this segment.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
> I will wait for 2-3rd generation before buying it. Smart strategy. I waited for the reMarkable 2 to get better, but it just gotten worse and all it offered was an under powered and non-upgradeable and laughable 8GB of maximum storage + a cloud storage subscription for more storage. The Kindle Scribe already starts with 16GB and is cheaper than the reMarkable 2 with the equivalent accessories coming with it. I guess the one that can actually deliver a proper e-ink tablet that just works, it would be unsurprisingly Amazon, hence why it is already an immediate best seller. I'll wait until whoever releases a color E-ink tablet, something that the reMarkable 2 has failed to deliver on, despite some early competitors already selling them but support and features from them isn't going to be as good as Amazon's.
Amazon Kindle: Recommends itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
You should look for some reviews on YouTube, I have researched this space quite a bit and found this video to be one of the best https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rZ-mW6otcXw . I bought a remarkable 2, and I really wanted to like it but the reading experience was so bad. The writing was wonderful though, but my primary use is reading. I don’t think you’re going to be satisfied with a remarkable. At this point I would recommend an Onyx. They are above average ereaders with above average writing experience. They don’t seem to be the absolute best at either but they are far better in aggregate than any other device because all other devices seem to sacrifice too much in one area. It seems like you want a larger screen but if you’re fine with a smaller screen and no writing capability I recommend you get a dedicated ereader like a kindle; they really do excel at the ereading experience
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Likes it
I had an iPad Air, which I changed for a reMarkable 2 and I couldn't be happier! I see a lot of people here commenting about the limitations of it, and I get it. For me personally those limitations are features. My needs are mostly note taking and reading technical PDFs, and for that the reMarkable is fantastic. I used it extensively while taking Calculus, which, it was great to use as many pages as I needed and to write as big as I wanted without worrying about "wasting" paper. I miss background light from time to time, which I think is a great addition. I'm not super familiar with alternatives so I can't say that is better than X or Y, but I personally have been moving as much as I can to single purpose electronic devices. That allows me to be more focus and not fight my device wanting to distract me. That takes out every eInk table that has android for me, I don't want a yet another multipurpose device that I need to develop discipline to use it! On that line, I love my kindle, but that spends about 90% of the time in airplane mode, because, again, the kindle is for readin, the reMarkable for taking notes and reading Datasheets and such... But, that's just me :-)
Amazon Kindle: NeutralreMarkable 2: Neutral
Right, like I said, if you have some ideological issue with the Scribe/Amazon, you’re going to be happier w/ the Remarkable. If you hate subscriptions, you’re going to find a reason to be mad about the Remarkable. I own both Scribe and Remarkable 2. You couldn’t pay me to take notes on the Scribe or read ebooks on the Remarkable.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Likes it
I own an rm2 and love it. However, I also love my Kindle and if I had to choose I'd choose the Kindle. When my Kindle (or RM) dies, I'll almost certainly replace it with the new writable Kindle, especially as I assume it's backlit which I feel is something really missing from the RM.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Likes it
I have a Remarkable 2 and a Boox Note Air (the first one), so I’m definitely going to get the Scribe. I love my Oasis but this will really seal things. I love my Boox so much. And the Remarkable has a lot of potential and is a beautifully designed device. But if anyone is going to be able to make this category more mainstream, it is Amazon. Also looking forward to the hacks that will come to it if there are enough users.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Likes it
Hey, if you’re happy with what you’re using, that’s great. I’ve put hacks or modified OSes on various Kindles over the years, used DeDRM for Calibre, and very much had a solid experience. I also have a Remarkable 2 and a Boox Note Air that are obviously much more hackable. I’ve reviewed many Kobo devices over the years. I do find them second-rate compared to what you can get from the Kindle line. That's my honest opinion. That isn’t me feeling insecure about my decision (I am an e-reader enthusiast and have reviewed dozens of devices and have the money to buy whatever device I want. I think Sony made the best devices if I’m really being honest, and they shut down their storefront over a decade ago and barely sell any units now), it’s my personal opinion and I said “I’ve always seen it as” — I didn’t declare that as fact. You disagree, which is fine! I’m glad we have a choice of things. I still stand by my opinion that if I’m going to be tied down into an ecosystem, I’d rather be tied down to the one with the most books. And where I live, that’s Amazon.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
The Remarkable 2 also isn't waterproof and also doesn't have a front light (warm or cold) at all. That's how they got it so thin. It's also awful at reading ePubs but I guess better at note taking. Kindles aren't much cheaper. Compare the Kindle Oasis to the Libra. All you really get is a metal case for an extra $100. And the stores are pretty similar in size with the exception of like self published books which IMO are worth stripping out of search...
Amazon Kindle: Likes itreMarkable 2: Likes it
> * (if you have the financial means) get another device without ANY distraction what so ever, ideally disconnected from the internet (except maybe syncing files) For me it is a e-ink (android) tablet. +1 After years of advocating for the laptop form factor ("use a dock at home! take it anywhere! the perfect nexus of power and portability!"), I've resolved to a setup that ditches the laptop for a stationary desktop. Easier to go to bed and get out of it the next morning, I figure. I've definitely become an advocate for e-ink. Between Kindle for reading, reMarkable 2 for freehand, and the Freewrite Traveler for writing, I definitely see the value in near-bespoke devices.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itreMarkable 2: Doesn’t like it
this looks useful! will definitely give it a try. for those who made that decision recently, what ebook reader did you get? i am quite torn between: kindle, i-pad, and e-ink devices (remarkable 2, boox note air 2, kobo elipsa, quaderno.) i heard e-inks are good on your eyes, which is always good. kindles would not support uploading your own PDFs or taking notes on them. the quaderno looks fantastic but quite big (i like a book-sized device). the remarkable 2 wants you to subscribe to services... so, have you got one of these recently? which one?