The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Amazon Kindle vs Kobo

Hacker News owners lean toward the Kobo.

Amazon KindleKobo
Owners with an opinion1124547
Positive verdicts72% of 89880% of 459
Positive/negative since 2024321/150256/70
Happy after 3+ years6925
Longest happy owner15 yrs16 yrs
Praised forease of use and displayease of use and display
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Kindle: Likes itKobo: Doesn’t like it
I picked up the new kindle basic version. It was terribly expensive ($150!) but they go on sale often. I have messed around with many models of ereader and the thing that Amazon and only Amazon gets right is backlight evennness. The basic kindle has a perfect backlight. Kobo was always a lottery.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itKobo: Doesn’t like it
We have kindle scribe and a kobo at home, the kobo experience has been way more rough for epubs. On amazon all I do is access amazon.ca/sendtokindle and I can upload the same epub to my phone and ereader AND keep the current page in sync. The experience with the Kobo is absolutely not even close to that. And I agree with you I don't like the lock in factor, but I felt more locked on a Kobo than on a Kindle
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Neutral
I gifted my sister my kindle this morning (it was unused for years) after loaded it with azw3 files converted from epub using calibre. The other options is to send epub via email. But I told her to never put it out of airplane mode and get it on WiFi because amazon has deleted my "documents" (that's what they called sideloaded books) before. I own two kobos, a libra for fiction and an ellipsa for tech books and textbooks. Both have koreader on.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itKobo: Neutral
I've decided with all my commercial e-readers that the USB+calibre is my only option as I do not wish to share my reading habits with the zillionaire overlord. There might be new and fancy UI or something, but I spend 99% of the time only flipping pages so the outdated UX is nothing compared to the privacy I get. Ancient Basic Kindle works still nicely and so does 1st gen Paperwhite + the few Kobo's we have in the family.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
Got the X4. Put CrossPoint on it. Works like a charm. The http server accessible over wifi makes transferring books extremely simple. (Shame on the Kindle for locking everything down.) This is proof-of-concept that a microcontroller is more than enough for something like an e-reader. I have a Kindle and a Kobo. They are sturdy devices. But the X4 is the one that is a genuine e-reader. Would not get it as my one and only e-reader though as you tend to miss the size and backlight of the larger ones. What would I want from future iterations? - backlight even if it compromises on battery a bit - a bit more DPI Everything else is good enough.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I don’t miss my kindle, at all. Its text layout engine was a joke (every page edge was ragged!), you depend very heavily on amazons goodwill to keep allowing you, the device owner, to sideload your own books, it’s getting harder to install third party software, and well that one is personal but it’s from Amazon. I’ve switched to kobos (Clara HD) and I’ve had to for years. It’s chugging along (had to 3d print a replacement power button a couple months ago), I can run koreader no problem and use calibre with the kobo plugin. And the default rendering engine in kobo’s firmware does actually typeset the text: no ragged edges!
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I gave up on Kindles long ago. They wake up and drain their batteries, so they're always dead when I pick them up to read something. Not a problem with Kobo. But I really want to pick up one of these little Xteink readers next. They just seem perfect for pulling out of a pocket and reading. Also, I'm a smaller person, and they look like they would fit my hand. Modern phones feel like tablets to me.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I don’t understand why anyone would choose a Kindle over the Kobo range of devices. When I bought the Kobo Clara it was also a significantly better device purely on hardware specs. It was slightly more expensive, but that’s more than paid for by how long it’s already lasted me, whereas my spouse’s kindle (bought before we discovered Kobo), is already e-waste. Kobo has also officially tied up with iFixit to provide official fixing guides and parts, allowing for relatively inexpensive hardware repair (to be fair, the battery replacement process I went through my device was quite annoying due to the waterproofing layer, but it worked, and my device is much older than their iFixit partnership, so hopefully the newer devices have repairability more in mind).
Amazon Kindle: NeutralKobo: Likes it
The Kindle isn't a bad device on its own. Personally I use a Kobo. But I never pay for any ebook that I can't keep indefinitely one way or another. I also have an old Kindle 4 that needs to be jailbroken before the May 30th deadline. Maybe I'll do that today. Gets you out of the ecosystem. And old Kindles can be found pretty cheap.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I didn't believe they would break the social contract and I was wrong. I lost so much in money and notes when they decided the books I bought "to own" were now considered "licensed". They changed the encryption on most of the newer ones so I couldn't even retrieve most. They also took away USB transfer so I couldn't use the library system in the way I liked. Now? I own a Kobo which will never touch the internet for the rest of its life and it only contains epubs. One day, Kobo/Rakuten will likely do the same.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I've had both. Kobo is fine hardware-wise. And light years better on software than Kindle. One huge example: I have 1000+ books in Calibre. Took the time to tag them all into their respective categories. Kobo recognizes those tags and my book collection is sorted. With Kindle, I'd have to sort by hand on device. It ignores Calibre tags. For this feature alone, I'd never go back to Kindle. Sure, I might be able to replicate it with jailbreaking + KOReader. But the Kobo worked this way out of the box.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itKobo: Doesn’t like it
I have both. The Kindle is a better device overall, but the I like Kobo's software better. What I found disappointing was when I had to swap out the screen on the Kobo and found that it was glued and that the battery was soldered. I managed to do fix it, but I don't like things that are unnecessarily hard to fix.