The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Amazon Kindle vs Boox Palma

Hacker News owners lean toward the Boox Palma.

Amazon KindleBoox Palma
Owners with an opinion112429
Positive verdicts72% of 89889% of 27
Positive/negative since 2024321/15024/3
Happy after 3+ years690
Longest happy owner15 yrs0.42 yrs
Praised forease of use and displayportability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Kindle: Likes itBoox Palma: Doesn’t like it
thrift stores. root, flash koreader. add a hosts file to restrict network activity to your sync server, or keep it in airplane mode. i have never paid more than $10 for an e-ink device until boox palma. that one sits in a drawer and i went back to the thrifted kindle.
Amazon Kindle: NeutralBoox Palma: Likes it
I've used this on a very old kindle. I had a kindle voyage from 2014 and installed this, it gave my kindle new life I didn't know was possible. It was fast and it had all the modern software features I would want. Suddenly I found myself being able to organise my library how I wanted (through the use of folders, like any directory). Very easy to manage. Also it made it super easy to send books without having to rely on the cable. Ultimately, it was the hardware of the device that made me look for an alternative. I just couldn't stand micro USB charging in 2023. So I bought a Kobo and later on a palma (for the form factor). Being able to install Koreader has now become a feature I select for. Also, it's very easy to sync books in Koreader, if your device is always online you can do it automatically or the way I do it is with some swipe gestures to push and pull the progress.
Amazon Kindle: NeutralBoox Palma: Likes it
I haven't seen any overwhelming support. I absolutely love this thing. Coming from Kindle and Kobo. It's not a good smartphone replacement. It IS a fantastic E-reader. I carry it with me everywhere. I do Anki flashcards, do my Obsidian notes, read my Kindle and Kobo libraries I've accumulated finishing books I've procrastinated on, I use Omnivore.app for any articles I find on my Pixel, and the web browser for things like Crossplane Docs which don't get captured nicely as an article. I can share notes with Android to my Obsidian. Look I know it's Android, I know it's probably not the latest kernel, I know it has drawbacks. But from my personal experience this device has single handedly revived my ereading and replaced 90% or my doom scrolling because of the convenient form factor. Other vendors make competition! I want color and a more secure android please.
Switched from the Amazon Kindle to the Boox PalmaBoox Palma: Likes it
I've got a Palma 2 and I like it. It replaces the Kindle for me: fits in the pocket, more book apps, actual feed reader and read later apps, good for typing quick notes and using Anki. You can also use Terminus to ssh to a box in a pinch. I would never think of daily driving it as a phone if it had a modem. The biggest dealbreaker is that streaming music is a pain on e-ink devices: all of the services except Apple Music (which doesn't support 2FA sign in on Android so it's useless to me) are dark mode only, and dark mode is the enemy on e-ink. Another problem is that the camera is pre smartphone level, it's really bad and with e-ink it's harder to see if the focus is good. And of course, it's running an obsolete version of Android and is continuously phoning home to China, so you probably don't want any important data on it. But as an e-reader, I strongly prefer it to the walled garden tablets.
Switched from the Amazon Kindle to the Boox PalmaBoox Palma: Likes it
I've been using this thing daily for about five months and really adore it. I use it as a Kindle replacement and with Readwise Reader as a longform article dump. I've read more longform pieces in the last few months than last few years combined. The device is incredibly light, and maintains battery even if you leave it idle all day (unlike my kindles which often drained themselves). Anyway, it's been a nice surprise, the palma.[0] [0]: https://craigmod.com/roden/091/#digital-reading-in-2024
Amazon Kindle: Likes itBoox Palma: Likes it
I have both a Kindle Oasis and Palma and I like the Palma much more for when I'm laying in bed. It's lighter and easier to one-hand, but most importantly is it's easy to hold while laying on my side. The narrower screen isn't too bad if you're mostly reading EPUBs or AZW3 files where they reflow text appropriately. I have it set up to use the volume rocker for changing pages. The included case makes the buttons a little... mushy for my taste, but I've otherwise been largely impressed. The fact that it runs Android means I can install an IETF RFC app and Instapaper and sync easily, which has been a surprisingly huge plus for me as well.