The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Amazon Kindle vs Boox Note

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Amazon KindleBoox Note
Owners with an opinion112423
Positive verdicts72% of 89882% of 22
Positive/negative since 2024321/1509/3
Happy after 3+ years690
Longest happy owner15 yrs2 yrs
Praised forease of use and displayease of use and display
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itBoox Note: Likes it
The Kindle hardware is great, but the software and ecosystem are just crap, and Amazon is making it shittier every year. I've now moved to an Android eReader (Boox Note 7, for example [1]). I can just get the Ebook or PDF files and transfer them via Calibre, simple as that, and I can also download any Android app i want. There are tons of apps out there that support eInk screens. [1] https://shop.boox.com/products/go7
Amazon Kindle: Likes itBoox Note: Doesn’t like it
I have a boox note 3, I don't love it. I barely use it. Have a remarkable 2 but spouse stole it when I iddn't use it much. I bought a scribe and used it more. I had 2 sets of classes this spring. I used the crap out of the scribe. I tried the boox for it and went back to the scribe. All I was doing was taking written notes in class and using it as infinte paper for doing homeworks. The boox takes forever to wake up and just is more laggy. It was usable for reading stuff in google docs outside but an umbrella and a laptop worked better. That said all 3 have amazing battery life, they'd all last all semester on a charge.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itBoox Note: Doesn’t like it
My last e-reader was a Boox Note. It did its job but was slow and after a couple of years just didn't start up anymore. Then I switched to Kindle Scribe, mainly for the large screen. It was amazing, it was so much faster and more responsive. I even started to use the scribe to make notes, though I didn't buy it for that purpose. With the Boox Note I never did that because of the slowness, it was just annoying.
Amazon Kindle: NeutralBoox Note: Doesn’t like it
Ahh I’ve done so much research here and tried so many different devices. * the Kindle Scribe has a great feeling, but the software is lacking, particularly around the writing experience. They’ve released two substantial updates to add missing features, but they’re still far from parity with the writing-first offerings from other companies. Also, critically, only some books - crossword puzzles are their example - support writing directly on the page. It’s backlit and feels great to write on though. * I used an iPad for awhile and it’s a solid solution. Obviously if you install Instagram or whatever you’re seriously degrading its value as a tool for focus, so don’t do that. I switched away because the epaper tablets look better in sunlight, have superior battery life, and feel much much better to write on. * remarkable feels wonderful to write on. I returned it primarily because I find the company is not super responsive or forthcoming with their plans for improvements. Also, it can’t read Kindle books unless you first convert them to epub, but if you want to write directly on a book on any tablet, you’re gonna have to convert away from Kindle. If you’re really doing nothing but writing — no reading, no annotation — this is probably the right pick. The writing feel is like a scratchy pencil on paper. * I would not recommend the boox note line. These are fully featured android tablets, though it’s a mystery to me why you would ever want to watch a YouTube video on an eink displa…
Amazon Kindle: Likes itBoox Note: Doesn’t like it
I just bought a Boox Nova 3 https://www.boox.com/nova3/ after having a Boox Note Air which arrived with a cracked screen. I LOVE my kindle, but wanted to be able to take notes as well, and I don't want the glare from an iPad screen. Honestly, if somebody made an e-ink cover for an iPad that would turn off the main LCD screen, I'd have probably gone for that. I was considering making one myself, but I've got too many projects on the go already. If I could take notes on a kindle (which I'm sure is coming soon), I'd do that in a second!
Switched from the Amazon Kindle to the Boox NoteBoox Note: Recommends it
Man I love e-ink devices so much. My Onyx Boox Note Air is one of the nicest and useful devices I have ever owned. I absolutely love it and their open platform. (I even ditched my Kindle oasis for the Poke3) I always regarded e-ink as a soon-to-be (or already) obsolete technology and while that might still be true, I absolutely love it for reading and writing. There is currently nothing better.