The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Amazon Kindle vs Barnes & Noble Nook

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Amazon Kindle.

Amazon KindleBarnes & Noble Nook
Owners with an opinion112414
Positive verdicts72% of 89867% of 12
Positive/negative since 2024321/1502/2
Happy after 3+ years690
Longest happy owner15 yrs–
Praised forease of use and displaydisplay and performance
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Kindle: Likes itBarnes & Noble Nook: Doesn’t like it
All of that is technically correct, however my non-Amazon readers (Sony, Nook, ...) reached the end of their useful life when their batteries died or their screens broke. All of them were "unsupported" at that stage (3-4 years after announcement), so not much to do about it. With that, I have a very old Kindle (7 years or so) that is still working -- with "Amazon's blessing" of course. Any reader will turn into a brick one day. What matters is what you're getting before that point. For me, I'd rather use Send-to-Kindle and never bother with SD cards again. Naturally, YMMV.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itBarnes & Noble Nook: Doesn’t like it
I was skeptical of screen readers until the Kindle e-ink. Have some OLED or LCD screen that you find on the standard tablets like some of the original Barnes and Nobles Nooks was just not appealing or comfortable. e-ink screens have definitely been a value on on my personal appeal on them, especially the Kindle's backlit ones.
Amazon Kindle: Likes itBarnes & Noble Nook: Doesn’t like it
Back in 2014, I bought a nook, returned it. I bought a kobo, returned it. I bought a Kindle voyage that I love to this day. #1 reason: out of those three, Kindle is or was the only ebook vendor I could crack with DeDRM and actually own my books. With Kindle for PC 1.17, I can still pull down my books and import them to my Calibre library for safe keeping. Can one DeDRM their Nook or Kobo files in 2022? PS: Kobo typography was noticably worse than Kindle in 2014. Again, it may have changed. PPS: I wish the symmetrical origami cover of the voyage was more used. I lay in bed and flip from side to side while reading. A book like cover or one that just is meant for vertical support is not sufficient for my use case.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itBarnes & Noble Nook: Likes it
Never had an issue with a EPUB on a kobo or a Nook reader, I clearly never tried any edge case. Not saying there might not be any issues with EPUB but the fact that in 10 years they can't be bothered to add at least a basic reader for me just mean they want to keep this incompatibility and keep people in this separated ecosystem with amazon/Kindle. I believe this choice is anything but a technical one. Since I never had much trouble using Calibre it means I'll probably never buy a Kindle just because of it but many people can't be hassled to do that.
Switched from the Amazon Kindle to the Barnes & Noble NookBarnes & Noble Nook: Likes it
For sure, I agree with a lot here. I am still a regular customer of B&N. Even got a paid membership this year and switched from the Kindle to the Nook. I image there is some customer base like me who are using B&N just to avoid Amazon also.
Amazon Kindle: Doesn’t like itBarnes & Noble Nook: Doesn’t like it
Is there a single high-end e-reader which is not also tied to a store? I'm currently using a tolino (hardware-wise, mostly a rehoused Kobo) which is at least "multi-store" and has no account dependency at all, but it still has some ads/branding for whichever retail partner you bought it from. Much less invasive than the Kindle/Nook experience I had in the past but still - I'm willing to pay, where's the completely independent device that isn't a 7" screen running basic Android in a crappy case?