The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Amazon Kindle Paperwhite vs Kobo

Hacker News owners lean toward the Kobo.

Amazon Kindle PaperwhiteKobo
Owners with an opinion178547
Positive verdicts70% of 14680% of 459
Positive/negative since 202467/40256/70
Happy after 3+ years1625
Longest happy owner13 yrs16 yrs
Praised fordisplay and reliabilityease of use and display
Criticized forsoftware and performancesoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Likes itKobo: Neutral
I've decided with all my commercial e-readers that the USB+calibre is my only option as I do not wish to share my reading habits with the zillionaire overlord. There might be new and fancy UI or something, but I spend 99% of the time only flipping pages so the outdated UX is nothing compared to the privacy I get. Ancient Basic Kindle works still nicely and so does 1st gen Paperwhite + the few Kobo's we have in the family.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: NeutralKobo: Likes it
Other commenters gave good reasons, and here are a few more: - If you like long books, an e-reader is much lighter than a tome. Not only more portable, but also easier to hold when reading. - When lying down you don't have to fight the cover 50% of the time. Easy to read one-handed too. - The new ones are water-resistant. - You can have multiple books available, in case you switch it up or just finish them quickly. - Search feature. - Built-in bookmark. - Time estimates until end-of-chapter and end-of-book. - The e-ink screen doesn't feel like a screen. Not really a plus on top of paper books, but just because you mentioned. I still read physical books when they're gifted or the medium requires it (House of Leaves being the latest example), but otherwise I'm 100% on e-readers. Previously Kindle Paperwhite 6th Gen, and since a few weeks, Kobo Clara BW.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
A Kobo would be a great choice. I use a Kobo Libra 2 and love it a lot more than my old Kindle Paperwhite that got stolen: https://gl.kobobooks.com/products/kobo-libra-2 The Kobo Sage is also good because it has an 8" screen. Standard eBooks offers kepub format for Kobo devices and files, they use their advanced Webkit-based renderer: https://standardebooks.org/help/how-to-use-our-ebooks#kobo-f...
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: NeutralKobo: Likes it
A kobo loaded with standard e-books ( https://standardebooks.org/ ) in the kobo format is glorious. I still have a paperwhite which is ok. My favorite device right now is a boox Go6, smallish, cheap, android. I don't use many apps on it other than the reader but threw a copy of Kiwix on there, and use it as a writing deck using a bluetooth keyboard, hits a lot of semi-offline use cases for me.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Likes itKobo: Doesn’t like it
I read several types of books, multiple hours per day: reflowable fiction books, PDFs, books generated from my Markdown notes… I’ve got a Paperwhite, a Scribe and a Kobo Forma, but I’m still searching for the perfect e-reader. The Paperwhite is too small for PDFs, but great for fiction and portability. The Scribe is excellent for PDFs, but it makes my books disappear sometimes, and it does not work well with sideloaded fonts. The Forma is a middle ground in terms of portability, but its battery died after a couple years and nowadays I only use it near a power outlet.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I have a pretty old paperwhite. When it started deleting books i had side-loaded via calibre, I decided to get a kobo. I have a libra color, and I have to say: price notwithstanding, it's a great device. I don't have a lot of experience with more recent devices, but compared to my 2nd gen paperwhite, it is _amazing_. Color is good enough to read comic books on it, the google drive integration means it's not too hard to get my CBR/CBZ files on directly. The annotation / notetaking featureas are nice (I haven't leaned into them yet, but they work well even on the small screen size), plus all the regular stuff with normal book reading. Also, since it's kobo/rakuten, the libby integration is better (search and select library books right from the device). The actual reading app is maybe 90% as good as reading on the kindle (or a more specialized reader like perfectviewer on android). There's some annoyingly fiddly features- font size is kind of weirdly variable, when going through CBR files there's no "read next in the folder" gesture nor is there a "this is read/unread" state in the google drive ui, so you always have to remember which book you are finishing when opening the next in the series. I tried out one of those boox readers with the android apps, which would be even better software-wise, but the boox hardware seems like garbage (for an N=1 at least). My display came with several rows of stuck pixels, and apparently it's a good thing that I ordered from amazon instead of…
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Doesn’t like itKobo: Likes it
I wonder if they’re still using soft touch/rubberised plastic on the back? My last-gen Kindle Paperwhite has already started to go sticky and gross. I’ve also got an issue where the latest software update is causing frequent hangs when opening new books (literally 5+ minutes) and I quite often get stuck in books, unable to summon the menu to go back to my library. Seems to be a fairly common problem judging by Reddit. I ended up buying a Kobo Libra Colour just this week. So far I’m very happy with it. Performance is better and it’s compatible with a lot more stuff.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: NeutralKobo: Likes it
I think e-readers are pretty much a solved problem for books that consist of solely text - it's got to the point where they only differentiate themselves on things more related to personal taste than any technical merit. And price, of course. I consider myself a heavy user of ereaders, probably averaging over an hour a day, and have had a few in my time (Kindle paperwhite, Kindle Voyage, Kobo Aura H2O, latest the Kindle Oasis - which I got in Jan 2019). The only real time I felt like I got an "upgrade" was the slightly denser screen on the voyage, then the slightly larger screen on the Aura. The Oasis feels functionally the same for my use case (again, 99.9% text, no images or diagrams or animations, so can't compare them). But really the only reason I "upgraded" after the voyage is leaving it on a train or got damaged in my luggage one time. And what can they really improve on it? There are denser screens - but they don't make the font size I use actually look any better. There are larger screens, but it's already about the limit of what I want for portability, and much larger would be harder to read not easier. There are faster refreshing screens, but I've never even noticed the page refresh speed, as it's lost in the time it takes to realign my eyes to the top of the page anyway. So what's left? Looks? "Premium" materials? Thinness? The oasis is already at the point where any thinner or bezels any smaller and you couldn't hold it. I don't read comics on it, so don't really…
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Recommends itKobo: Likes it
There's really not a one-size-fits-all solution for everyone. The options you listed seem to be larger devices with pen support, so is that what you're in the market for? I ask because the best pure ebook reader device is not necessarily the best device for PDF reading/annotation. Bigger screens are better for those--you really need at least a 10-inch screen if you want to comfortably read or edit PDFs. As close to a standard 8.5x11" piece of paper as you can get, ideally, because the majority of PDFs that you would be annotating will likely be physical paper scans. But if all you're reading are ebooks in formats that support text reflow (EPUB,MOBI,etc.), you can get away with the normal 6" readers, with the advantage that they're smaller and more portable, and cause less fatigue to hold in your hands for extended periods. Of the smaller e-readers, I personally favor the Kobo. The Clara HD had slightly better specs than the equivalent Kindle Paperwhite when it came out, in addition to better supporting the things I care about (like STANDARD ebook formats, Pocket integration, and Overdrive integration). So that was the right decision for me. But for my family, I've just recommended they get the Kindle Paperwhite, because most of them don't care about trying to pull their books out of the Amazon ecosystem.
Switched from the Kobo to the Amazon Kindle PaperwhiteAmazon Kindle Paperwhite: Doesn’t like it
Years ago I had a kobo and put kohreader on it. But I left it on a bus and got a kindle Paperwhite as a replacement. I definitely regret that and second this comment: kohreader is such a superior experience. I'll never again get an ereader that can't run it.
Switched from the Amazon Kindle Paperwhite to the KoboKobo: Likes it
Even without koreader a kobo is refreshingly open to tinkering. Getting root and ssh access is just a matter of renaming a file on the disk. I got the colour after being on an old paperwhite for many years so thankfully it's a big step up for me.
Switched from the Amazon Kindle Paperwhite to the KoboKobo: Likes it
Totally agree. I was given a Kindle Paperwhite as a gift (great gift idea, by the way) and eventually bought a Kobo for some more flexibility. Both were about $120 retail. It brought so much reading into my life - I'm a full ebook convert at this point. Few pieces of tech could give me so much value.
Switched from the Kobo to the Amazon Kindle PaperwhiteAmazon Kindle Paperwhite: Doesn’t like it
For me, they were drm free ebooks I bought legitimately and had to sideload via calibre because the kindle doesn't support epub. It's an old Paperwhite, and it only happens when I go out of airplane mode. However, I have to go out of airplane mode (or had to before I ditched the kindle for a kobo) to get library books and the occasional actual Amazon kindle book when I didn't feel like waiting for the library to get me to the front of the list. *Edit to add: I believe the kindle won't delete epubs you sideload via the Amazon kindle email gateway, but I have no interest in doing that.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Doesn’t like itKobo: Doesn’t like it
What I would appreciate is them not plastering the logo/name on the front where it's staring you in the face as you try to read. I already bought the damn device, stop advertising (harassing) to me! (Both my previous generation Kindle Paperwhite that I switched from and the Kobo Clara Colour that I switched to, do this.) Then if they could make the glass screen flush with the front like the Paperwhite, that would be awesome too.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Likes itKobo: Likes it
I got a Kindle Paperwhite as a gift from my work and I fell in love with e-readers. Then I really didn't like how Amazon was locking down getting your own epubs onto the device (it's only gotten worse), so I quickly found Kobos were an excellent device for my use case. I found that buying ePubs online was way more available than I would have thought and now I get to keep my digital books. Just drag and drop them onto the Kobo. Kobo also has a "sideload mode" that (despite the slightly confusing name) just remove all online features all together.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite: Likes itKobo: Likes it
I'll chime in - the Kindle Paperwhite I believe is the superior machine from a physical feeling and aesthetic perspective. The problem (for me) is who makes it. Amazon keeps locking it down so it's harder and harder to load your own DRM free books onto it, in addition to tracking everything you do on it (like sending all your reading statistics whenever you get online). I have a Kobo Clara BW. It's still a great machine, but the Kindle is definitely superior for feel and visuals, but I use the Kobo 95% of the time. They are way more open with the software and I have mine in "sideload" mode (an official setting), which really just means that it doesn't make me log into anything and it doesn't even attempt to connect to the internet. Also, I can purchase a DRM free ebook on the train, plug a USB cable into my phone and my Kobo, and then load it on like that. Now I own my digital book, have supported the author with a larger margin, and get to read it on my more private machine. Definitely not a no-brainer for everyone, but I'm happy with my Kobo.