The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Amazon Fire vs Apple iPad

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPad.

Amazon FireApple iPad
Owners with an opinion141525
Positive verdicts50% of 1259% of 1245
Positive/negative since 20243/3320/259
Happy after 3+ years061
Longest happy owner–15 yrs
Praised forvalue and portabilityease of use and performance
Criticized forperformance and softwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazon Fire: Likes itApple iPad: Neutral
I use an iPad continuously for browsing the web, controlling IoT devices in the home, playing music on the HEOS system, etc. I live in a place that carriers choose not to serve so I don't spend a lot on a smartphone and plan, sometimes I have a cheap prepaid phone, sometimes I go for years and not renew it. Skype is my preferred way to make phone calls both with my PC and the iPad. It works in most places I want to make a call because public WiFi is available in a lot of places. The real problems w/ the iPad as I see it are: it refuses to use play music over Bluetooth when using WiFi (Android devices try and usually fail because of interference between the two services) and Apple doesn't allow access to NFC on the device except for Apple Pay. I have a lot of android tablets that I bought for testing software. Before I had the iPad I used Amazon Fire tablets pretty seriously (read software docs when doing cardio at the gym, I took my best photo of the last decade w/ a Fire tablet) but all of my Android tablets go unused for so long that I can't count on them being charged when I need them.
Amazon Fire: Doesn’t like itApple iPad: Recommends it
If you’re planning on using it for productivity purposes, rather than as a detached-keyboard Windows PC, then the iPad is your best choice (Pro devices being the best option, new or used). Amazon-curated Android-based Fire tablets are cheaper, but with a shorter lifespan and dodgy expansion storage (WTF is wrong with Android platform storage?!?). If you’re located in a developing market, stick with pen, paper and bicycles: decent data throughput is a hard requirement for high-end tablet use.
Amazon Fire: Doesn’t like itApple iPad: Likes it
For younger kids, the Amazon Fire 10 kids edition tablets are nice (nearly indestructible, cheap, parent controls and a lot of content if you subscribe to Kids+). If you have several kids, you can get 3 Amazon Fires for the price of an iPad. They are useful as long as kids don't need to use a browser, because Amazon's Silk is horrible. And you should probably avoid the Fire 7/8, because they are too slow... (haven't use the latest 7/8 models, but they still have slower CPUs than the 10 inch models) But for adults, I don't think Android tablets are worth the trouble. iPads just work, while Android apps do not always work that well on tablets. Also, iPads are really fast. And while they are more expensive, they have a much higher resale value.
Amazon Fire: Likes itApple iPad: Likes it
I've had a lot of tablets. iPad is better than most of them but my feeling is that tablets are sorta disposable, even if you don't intended them to be disposable. [1] If you want to read the web, read PDFs, it doesn't really matter that you're running AMZN's fork and using AMZN's gimped app store because you need like: a web browser, a PDF viewer, maybe ssh and RDP clients and that's it. The only (relatively) high end Android device I had was a Google Pixel, everything else has been a medium Samsung, BN Nook, I even had a $99 Windows tablet that was "good enough". A lot of people who would want a Kindle would be pretty happy with a Fire, it is not so easy to read in peak daylight and the battery life is worse, but the value is good enough that AMZN has driven quality affordable Android tablets out with very little fanfare. [1] I can't believe anyone gets an iPad Pro, but if I did I'd get an expensive case for it and treat it like a laptop. What I like about tablets is that I can take them places where they might get smashed.
Amazon Fire: Likes itApple iPad: Likes it
I’ve done it at times. In EC2 I’d probably want something like a M7i.8xlarge which would cost around $0.80 an hour for on demand pricing, which would be a good deal because I’d only actually spin it up when I was using it. (I use to go to hackathons with an Amazon Fire tablet back when Android has mouse support and the iPad didn’t and having a $10 cloud bill is cheap for having the sleekest bit of kit that anybody brings.) The thing is I do most of my software dev on a “gaming PC” I built myself that has a good graphics card. My RSS reader YOShInOn runs when I am awake and as a web app it is super responsive on my tablet. I just drank a coffee at the gas station and I am tapping this out on my iPad right now. It’s really convenient to use this machine even if I do have a moment sometimes when I’m not sure if the window I picked will open and have to suppress the urge to click again (which could make the window go away!)
Amazon Fire: Likes itApple iPad: Likes it
I think many people underestimate the success of Amazon's Fire tablets. I took one of the best photos that I took in the last ten years on a Fire tablet: that's a combination of the camera being "good enough" (though nowhere near as good as my iPad's camera) and being at the right place at the right time. There was that time I was walking down the road and ran into a woman who had a huge dog that put its paws up on my shoulders and tried to push me down (in a friendly way.) She invited me into her trailer and I saw that a Fire tablet was her only computer. Although she'd never heard of Android and didn't seem so sure that Amazon had anything to do with it she was reading email, sharing photos, watching videos and doing most of what people do in their digital life. Fire will be hard to beat for a few reasons: (1) Amazon subsidizes the devices and can afford to do so because the device sucks people into the Amazon ecosystem, and (2) Amazon makes smart choices about what features to include and which not to. I used to have a Nexus 7 and I liked it a lot but it was packed with sensors that pushed up the BOM. Amazon is able to make tough decisions that Google somehow just can't do.