The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Amazfit Bip vs Garmin

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Amazfit BipGarmin
Owners with an opinion27834
Positive verdicts76% of 2577% of 713
Positive/negative since 202410/5346/122
Happy after 3+ years431
Longest happy owner8 yrs15 yrs
Praised forbattery and displaybattery and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and durabilitysoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Amazfit Bip: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
Amazfit bip was nice, but I encountered a bug with GPS data loss too often. That is the price of the cheap Chinese product, I guess. So, when my Bip have been damaged, I decided to buy Garmin for 250€ instead. So far, it works well.
Amazfit Bip: Likes itGarmin: Doesn’t like it
Amazfit Bip lasts 4-6 weeks on single charge with always on transreflective display with readability improving with more sunlight (opposite of useless OLED power hungry displays) and I use it exactly just to check time and read notifications, I also use it to track my sleep, step counts and heart rate, plus one of the most used features in my night apartment is using display backlight (necessary only in dark) as flashlight it's also very small, light and thin, pretty much impossible to find such compact watch since I don't want to carry bulky brick on my wrist (so no thanks expensive Garmin bricks with shorter battery life) I'm now on my 2nd one, first I had brand new, it fell apart just before end of 2y warranty (basically the body inserted in frame without gluing, it felt outside, I could put it back and connect, just display colors were reversed but since it was in warranty I just used warranty to get money back, they improved gluing with newer versions), then went for OLED watch and gave up after maybe half year, gave new OLED watch which need to be charged at least twice a week to wife, it has unreadable AOD in sunlight (beause you need full brightness in sunlight or very least B&W AOD display instead other useless color combinations) and just bought second hand Bip for 20USD and I couldn't be happier, I'm thinking I could stock few of them into drawer in case something will happen to this one plus for people with too much spare time Bip firmware is somewhat hackable wit…
Amazfit Bip: Likes itGarmin: Doesn’t like it
I think judging by how software updates look B is correct, people don't care anymore about functionality, but how things look. They don't wanna perfectly OK display which is not so colorful and doesn't have so high resolution, but it's ALWAYS readable, more sunlight the better and battery life is counted in 4-6 weeks, they will rather have display with better colors and resolution and charge it every 2 days. Or there is option C, same as with compact phones, it's relatively small group of users and companies just don't care with providing them any options. Nowadays if you want "compactish" phone with good camera and decent battery life your only options are year old Zenfone 8, year old Pixel 5, Xiaomi Mi 12/12X or Samsung S22 and that's pretty much it, two phones released recently, meanwhile you have hunreds of tablets ("phones") to choose from. Same thing with laptops, you can have either ugly unbreakable workhorse Thinkpad T series, but most of the people will rather buy crappy laptop from different brand because it looks nicer and they don't care they will have it in repair all the time. And it's even worse with transreflective watch with good battery life and normal size, which will not break your wallet, such thing doesn't exist anymore at all. You can buy premium Garmin which is huge, expensive and lasts maybe 2 weeks and that's pretty much it unless you order some obscure copy of original Amazfit Bip (SMA Q2 or Q3), but in that case it's just easier to buy used Bip for…
Amazfit Bip: Likes itGarmin: Doesn’t like it
I have this in my Amazfit Bip watch with one month battery life and always readable display and to this day I don't understand why there are pretty much none other watches using trans reflective display besides very expensive garmin which still has crappy battery life. Had for few months stint with OLED smartwatch until I returned back to Bip, OLED was unbearable in daylight unless on maximum brightness and I had to charge it minimum twice a week, while I charge Bip once a month.
Amazfit Bip: Likes itGarmin: Likes it
Why not something like Casio G-SQUAD GBD-100/200 (starts from ~110USD)? Or there are also pricier Garmin Instinct Solar with solar transflective display which should last loong time (since he doesn't mind bulky watch unlike me). Casio claim to last one year on battery with notifications, Garmin 50+ days as smartwatch. I wish Casio made something like this (transflective graphic display which can display texts/simple graphic) in F91 form factor with rechargable battery, I wouldn't mind if it last only few months between charges. Currently using Amazfit Bip which I charge once a month.
Amazfit Bip: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Doesn’t like it
Folks ITT will talk about watches that are similar in hardware, but what was magic about Pebble was the software and ecosystem. The OS was just a delight to use, fast, wonderfully animated, and let you sideload whatever you want. I've tried a couple of Garmin watches (Vivoactive 3 and Forerunner 55) and the Amazfit Bip, and this is where they all fall completely flat. The UX is just horrible by comparison. It's like these companies have no regard for designing the OS UX and are just trying to cram features in. And the fact that companies want to make touchscreen watches is just with few/no buttons is baffling to me. Tapping tiny buttons on a tiny screen is a horrible experience. And there's tons of moving targets because of the tiny amount of real-estate. Pebble _just got it_ with the 2.0 OS and beyond. They were a joy to use. I begrudgingly have gone back to using an Apple Watch, because despite being subpar, the UX is somewhat together these days, just enough to be tolerable. When I move away from iOS again, I'll probably either pull out an old Pebble that still has some battery life, or a Casio GBD200, which isn't really a smartwatch but ticks some major boxes for me (always-on-display, silent vibration alarm, and timers, chief among them). The GBD200 runs on a coin cell too, so I never have to worry about charging or a replacement being difficult to find!