The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Samsung Galaxy S

Samsung Galaxy S8

12owners with an opinion
45%of verdicts positive
4/3positive/negative since 2024
3 yrslongest happy owner
2happy after 3+ years

Praised for comfort and performance; criticized for battery and software.

What owners wrote

Doesn’t like itOwned 6 years
I've been holding on on my 6 years old Galaxy S8 for this reason. It's yet-another-battery-to-be-charged, it introduced lag in audio especially where it matters(think video playback or games), the battery degrades over time, can't be used with my laptop as seamlessly as unplug-here-plug-there, and I personally like to keep headphones ON all the time even when I'm not listening, in case something comes up. this would be impossible with the Bluetooth ones. sign such a crappy direction they all headed in.
Likes itOwned 3 years
I used a Galaxy S8 for 3 years, I did like it, but switching back to a budget iPhone was marginally better for a fraction of the price. I daily drove some budget phones last year on Android, which was not an enjoyable experience. My original comment was more about why the other commenter got downvoted (it was irrelevant pile-on), not trying to take a strong stance here, but I can see how it came across now. I obviously have my opinions, though (a bit more so now after the budget phone experiments of 2023…)
NeutralOwned 3 years
I think it was the Galaxy S4 that I had for 4 years, then the S8 for 3. I don't remember if/when updates stopped. I probably only had the phone I bought in 2010 for 2 years because back then they were still subsidizing new phone purchases at the 2 year mark.
Doesn’t like it
I still remember when my bank wanted me to run Android 9 instead of my Android 15 rom (without root) on my Samsung S8 because "muh security!!" Funnily enough, the only way to hide those detections was to Root my phone... And i still remember when i had an appointment there, they wanted to see something in my Bank app, i opened it (and i assume it had an update since i then last used it) and a big "THIS DEVICE IS NOT SUPPORTED. ROOT IS NOT SUPPORTED" poped up But was as simple as readding the bank app to my root hiders. but still, i hate this security theater
Likes it
I had an Android phone circa 2018 (Samsung S8) that had this feature: it was called "App Pinning" and people could only navigate inside the pinned app until you unlocked your phone like you usually would. Edit: I am now an iOS user since 2022, and I only learn about "Guided Access" from other comments haha
Likes it
I'm running a custom ROM on a Galaxy S8 (so without project treble) and I've been pleasantly surprised! Even something as niche as the swipe on fingerprint sensor to pull notifications drawer down still works! Everything from phone calls, camera, fingerprint, all the essentials work pretty much flawlessly.
Likes it
I still use the Galaxy S8 with a 5.8" screen as well. It is actually quite amusing that nowadays this is considered "Small phone". I find it to be the perfect size and refuse to carry a brick around with me. Good thing in my country we still have 2G for when this breaks :P
Doesn’t like it
I have noticed with two 7 year old Snapdragon 835 devices that RAM and running a recent Android version makes a huge difference. I daily drive a OnePlus 5 running Android 14 through LineageOS and the user experience for non-gaming tasks is perfectly adequate. This phone has 6GB of ram, so it's still on par with most mid-range phones nowadays. My only gripe is that I had to replace the battery and disassembling phones is a pain. Meanwhile a Galaxy S8 with the same SoC, 4GB of memory and stock Android 9 with Samsung's modifications chugs like there's no tomorrow. I can understand that having two more gigabytes of memory can make a difference but there is a night and day difference between the phones. Perhaps Android 14 has way better memory management than Android 9? Or Samsung's slow and bloated software is hampering this device? Either way it's irritating to see that many companies don't test on old/low-end devices. Most people in the world aren't running modern flagships, especially if they target a world-wide audience.
Doesn’t like it
I guess the OP should have said that the "perception" of speed is the killer feature. I find Android is now terrible on both my Samsung Tab 2 and my Galaxy S8. Sometimes I click something and it takes over a second to do any UI changes and looks like it hasn't responded. Just as you go to click it again, it comes up. I find the same in multiple apps where basic actions take too long even simple menu/view apps like email. I don't know what has happened but it does seem crazy that in 20 years with hardware that is 1000s of times more powerful, we still can't consistently solve click latency. Maybe it's just me.
Doesn’t like it
Try out an iPhone for real world use. I did the opposite. Android is extraordinarily slow ("feels unresponsive") even on high end hardware compared with a comparable iPhone. I had to use a Galaxy S8 for a spell at work and every non-keyboard tap seems to generate a half-second-plus delayed response. I actually thought something was wrong (malware on a recycled company device?) and wiped the phone, installed all patches, and... still slow as hell despite the hardware that is 4x more powerful than my iPhone 6S. It's as if they somehow ported the as-yet-unfixed lagginess of all Linux desktop managers to the phone on purpose, because they didn't know the world could be better. And no, I'm not a fanboy, my phone is my only iThing. And no, there was no MDM or AV installed on the phone by my company that caused this lagginess.
Recommends it
A Nexus 4 handed down to my son recently stopped working when he dropped it, smashing the screen. Gave him my cast off Nexus 5 that was still storming great. My wife's Nexus 5 was working perfectly, though we replaced it with an iPhone 7 (to her great dismay, it turns out). My own Nexus 6P has worked perfectly, but for dev reasons I replaced it with a GS8 (which is simply a stunning device in every way, including the fact that I immediately dropped a UHS-1 64GB SD card it in and now do my data churning development on that). The point, I guess, is that anecdotes vary. Heck, my son has been toying around with the G1 and G2, and Nexus One, I had sitting in drawers.