The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets · Microsoft Surface Pro

Microsoft Surface Pro 3

19owners with an opinion
62%of verdicts positive
4/3positive/negative since 2024
10 yrslongest happy owner
2happy after 3+ years

Praised for ease of use and battery; criticized for comfort and reliability.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 10 years
And I have one that I use as thin client for my desktop, Linux made it usable! 10 year old surface pro 3, 8 to 9hr battery life, takes less than 20s to boot up to Gnome, no issues browsing on Firefox, it's a solid device on the go. And to my total surprise, it retained charge even after almost a month of no usage.
NeutralOwned 10 years
Similar, except I use a 10 year old surface pro 3. But I have to have a mechanical keyboard, so it's not exactly portable, but I can work from anywhere I have no interest in LLM, or vibe code. Even though I miss the capabilities of intellij, nvim can fill the roll in the terminal very nicely, except rust analyzer filling up storage fast, I also have a spare mobile, which I use to wake the computer up. And I have a python script running on it, to shutdown the computer in case of power failure. After initial hiccups it working pretty well, except cats turning off the router, well how many can use the excuse that I couldn't finish the work because cat controls your network. LoL
Likes itOwned 3 yearsStill going
I've been using a Surface Pro 3 as my one-and-only for almost 3 years, and it really feels like time to upgrade, so I've been looking forward to this one. My workload is probably something like 40% reading, 30% writing, 25% coding, and 5% running code, and the Surface has been a nearly ideal form factor for this. The new "Surface Pro" ticks a lot of boxes for me: - Supports my existing keyboard, pen, dock, and power adapter - Improves battery life substantially - Offers improved keyboard and pen for when I get around to it - Fanless options - Improved performance (not that I need much more) Unfortunately, the configurations are weird. My ideal machine is an i5/256GB/16GB. The closest I can get is i7/512GB/16GB, which nearly doubles the cost, and requires a fan. I just don't get how they can make the floor for 16GB RAM $2200. Is there any professional workload where 8GB isn't constricting today, let alone in another 3 years? My only thought here is that maybe the RAM increases the thermal envelope enough to require the fan, but that seems unlikely, and I would still happily make that sacrifice if I didn't have to also pay for the processor and disk upgrades. I'm going to harangue them on Twitter, and also look into clearance SP4s with 16GB.
Recommends itOwned 2 yearsStill going
I've been using the Lumia 650 for a couple months now and it's a solid device. If only it was their first iteration! Also, for those used to using a Macbook/Ipad/Iphone, consider the Surface lineup is really tablet-and-laptop in one. I have been using a Surface Pro 3 for about 2 years now and really swear by the device. There's nothing like it on the market. The anniversary Win10 update is coming soon too. Tough to say what their goals are in the mobile space though.. It's a saturated market and people are already plugged into ecosystems so it's tough to pull them out. The plus with Windows 10 Universal though is that for developers, why not make it universal and get added mobile/desktop app for free? Hard to say where they're going.. The entire market has sort of reached a strange place with shifts to the cloud and attempts at AI (I disable cortana by the way because she eats battery for breakfast).
Doesn’t like itOwned 0.25 years
Ah that explains a lot. Especially the feel I've always had about it being "change for the sake of change". There was a time when I actually tried to use it for real, I bought a used Surface Pro 3 and traveled with it, so the touch-based UI actually made sense. I wonder if that fear was realistic though. Though I have to admit MS at that time (under Ballmer) was really hostile to Linux. Edit: The point made in that article seems to be disproven though: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39493246 . Even Miguel de Icaza said it's nonsense. Can't get more authoritative on Gnome than that. But it was just too weird with the workspaces on the fly, the huge window decorations (despite touch I would mainly use the pen anyway) and the lack of a real launcher. I used it for about 3 months and got rid of it. It just rubbed me the wrong way constantly and I really couldn't stand the designers' attitude, every time I wanted to change something I ended up googling it and finding some excuse from the devs on why they wouldn't account for it (usually along the lines of "you shouldn't want/need that"). What didn't help was that Linux on the Surface Pro 3 was a huge PITA also. Often the keyboard wouldn't work after having been disconnected, or the pen would stop working, or it would turn on in my bag for some weird reason and be boiling hot, or it would fail to pick up the ethernet of the dock etc. Most of these issues were solved by a reboot but I ended up rebooting a lot to solve all th…
Neutral
I had Omarchy and then a Niri desktop installed on a Windows Surface Pro 3 for a while. I did find it was handy to scroll with the touch screen occasionally. More an artifact of being a regular iPad user than anything else. But if I need to do anything else I immediately go to the trackpad or keyboard.
Likes it
Surfaces are great devices. My Pro 3 still gets 7 hours of battery life. We use newer Surface laptops at work, even the artists, developers, and executives (note we are not a tech company). The laptops aren't very fast but they can take a lot of physical abuse and the batteries last all day. We don't need the top of the line, and forcing our developers to use lower powered computers actually improves the quality of the apps because they get to experience how our apps work for most of our customers and take performance into account from the beginning.
Likes it
My opinion on that may be colored by the fact that I had a Surface Pro 3, the one place where Windows 8.1 was actually great to use, and taking away some of the focus on tablet use was a regression. Overall you're right though, outside of tablets W10 was an improvement, because 8 tried to stick the tablet UI into desktops. I was recently connecting to some server with the Windows 8 derived version of Windows Server and gosh that full screen start menu is stupid with a mouse.
Likes it
Workspace being froze or causing issue, is just the symptom of the actual problem. It's not the workspace are the problem. So, maybe you should investigate the underlying issue. Which version of Gnome are you using? Older version of Gnome had an issue with workspace switch, which has been fixed over a year ago. You do realize, Surface Pro 3 is a 10 year old laptop, which only have 4GB of RAM, and iGPU, and I have opened up 14 workspace, with multiple applications. And, obviously it had some lag, but it never became unusable.
Likes it
Ah, bicycles, something that I love so much. Yes, agreed, someone who never rode will never realize how amazing it is feel the air in your face, the gentle sound of the tire rolling. I miss it so much. But, when you keep changing your bikes, and start fiddling with the mechanics of it, you forget, what made it worth in the first place! What was the thing that gave you the pure joy. PS: Using nvim and IntelliJ(Ultimate) side by side is for a personal reason. I have to be away from my main desktop for a really long time. So have to SSH into my desktop using a Surface Pro 3 (Running Linux) to work. It's a really portable setup, and works well as a thin client. And it is an experiment to fully utilize CLI tools, to get my work done.
Likes it
This has a miserable 1280 x 800 pixel screen and eMMC storage. If you are interested in a tablet running Linux, I think my daily driver might be a better choice: A Microsoft Surface Pro 3 running Debian¹ with very few problems. It has a 2160 x 1440 touchscreen and a real SSD. Easy to find used/reconditioned for about $100.² [1] https://github.com/linux-surface/linux-surface [2] https://www.ebay.com/itm/205341079054
Likes it
If you look up the pixel dimensions of the displays offered by even the best glasses or headsets, you’ll find that you get the equivalent of one modest screen at best. This includes the best of the Xreal glasses mentioned in a comment below. So I don’t think this kind of hardware will satisfy your needs. I’m typing this on a Surface Pro 3 (running Linux), which has (is, really) a 12 inch screen with pixel dimensions of 2160x1440. It’s 10 years old; the display outclasses anything you can wear on your face. I’m with you: I’d love to replace screens with this kind of technology. But it’s not there yet.
Likes it
My Surface Pro 3 still gets 90% battery life. My HP hybrid tablet, now over 15 years old, still works (when plugged in). My dad's IBM Thinkpad, older than most people currently on this website, still works. Apple people like to claim that Apples last longer than their competitors, but that simply isn't true. Most people, myself included, can't tell you what Dell or HP support is like because we've never had to use them. But every Apple user knows what Apple support is like, because every Apple user has had to use them.
Doesn’t like it
Surface machines feel nice and do their due x86 diligence, but they're just as ugly as a Macbook when something goes wrong. My Surface Pro 3 was a great machine, sadly plagued with a dearth of issues that could only be solved by replacing it. I like feeling like a premium user with milled aluminum and all that, but the fragility of those machines just make me too paranoid to carry them around. They make poor work laptops in my opinion, but I guess it's all very subjective and depends on the sort of "work" you do. My best compromise recommendation is to swallow the cost and get a Magic Trackpad. They work great on Linux, and the only "broken" feature is Force Touch. If you're using GNOME or KDE in a Wayland session, it will zip around and make you happier than a kid in Compiz. > With that in mind, I tried it anyway and had a lot of issues with dependencies missing arm64 binaries You don't know the half of it. I worked on internal tooling at a mostly-Mac studio during the Apple Silicon transition... it was awful. Our entire engineering team bought "upgrades" before we knew if our product even built on M1, and wouldn't you know it, huge portions of our build system was unusable. So then they all switched to cloud-only builds, and then eventually to builds in an accelerated Linux VM, and then to a mostly ARM-native pipeline with Rosetta shims for the less cooperative software. Mind you, we didn't actually ship to Mac. We wasted hundreds of engineering hours a month just becau
Recommends it
I’ve bought books, each for less than $300, that have changed my life. Can’t get a better bang for the buck than a good book. I recently bought a used Microsoft Surface Pro 3 from ebay for around $200, and installed Debian Linux on it, with a special kernel for the Surface. It runs Linux really well, and is now my main computer. I hate Microsoft as much as any normal person, but this hardware is excellent. I can use it as a tablet (the touchscreen works well) or with a wireless keyboard. Having a keyboard detached from the computer is far better than any laptop, for ergonomics and flexibility. It came with Windows 11 installed, and I even kept it on a small partition that I boot into sometimes for Zoom meetings, as Zoom doesn’t work well on Linux—and for testing websites. The machine was in absolutely perfect condition. The only issue is that the battery life is pretty bad (couple of hours at most), but I don’t know whether that’s because the battery is in bad shape or because of Linux power management.
Doesn’t like it
Also consider warranty, repair, and accidental damage protection: My Surface Pro 3 had extended warranty, and there used to be stores to drop into. I had many problems with the machine, but the horrible part was that they could only be swapped out, so I had to restore my data (easy) and setup windows all over again (kill me now). This has been addressed with their ‘for business’ series with removable SSD. My mother, never drops her laptop, works in dusty environments, uses the same computer for years. No ADP, no extended warranty, I just replaced her Asus laptop she has been using since 2013 without any hardware issues. Remarkable. My friend, who is careless, has endless problems with his HP, and requires ADP. His last machine lasted barely 3 years and has been into the depot at least twice. He wants on-site this time as he was without a machine for a week at a time. I had a Lenovo with full extended on-site warranty. Machine was a damned nightmare for problems, but I was never without a working machine. I am careful with it, it hasn’t been abused, and I believe it was a product design problem. Lenovo sent out many parts and technicians and finally contacted me to apologize and address the obvious satisfaction issue. They replaced it with a completely different model that I am happy with. My Gigabyte gaming laptop is an older beast. 4 years old, no extended warranty. From a computing perspective and hack ability, I generally love it, but there have been problems a
Doesn’t like it
I use a Surface Pro 3 as my laptop, running Windows. I avoid doing real work on it though -- not nearly enough memory, terribly slow CPU. I mostly use it for SSH, IRC, email, and web browsing. Occasionally I'll write some Rust code on it. I use a custom built desktop with 16GB of RAM and a Xeon E3-1230v2. Planning on upgrading that to either a Ryzen 1800X or some Naples Point configuration with at least 32GB of RAM soon.
Likes it
MacOS lost me somewhere around Mavericks and the idea of a tablet that is also my PC was appealing, so I tried a Surface Pro 3 and decided to keep it. Ubuntu Bash for Windows is great, but is Beta and still needs some work. As for my old 2011 MBP, Ubuntu runs very well on it. For a couple of decades I kept trying Linux on the desktop, and today I am happy with it. From managing photos, CAD for my 3D printer, Python development and music with my keyboard, Dropbox support, it really is remarkable how far the desktop has come. I am still using the web client for OneNote though...
Likes it
Over the past year I've noticed a lot of things mysteriously getting installed, things moving around, etc. I don't mind automatic updates so long as there's a separation from the new features and bug fixes. There should be a base core of apps that are necessary and a set of opt-in add-on features. It's time to move to Linux on laptop/desktop/tablet I think. While I love my surface pro 3 and the Windows 10 experience is overall a good one, I don't like them changing undisclosed stuff on me.
Neutral
I use my Surface Pro 3 on my lap a fair amount. It's not the best, but it's functional if I'm in a seat at the airport, or a hotel lobby, or on the couch. I've also realized that a lot of the work that I do in those situations involves more reading than intensive typing, and I'll just switch to using it as a tablet. I would say that "lapability" comes up with about the same frequency that "I need to use my laptop while standing and it's a pain" and "this laptop is getting really hot on my lap" have happened with previous laptops I've owned.
Likes it
The problem here is not Microsoft. I am surface pro 3 owner and i have to say that is one of the best machines i have used. I wouldn't change it for anything. I agree that MS is heading in the right direction. The steps that they are taking are to my opinion great for everyone. I have been a linux user for almost 10 years and windows 10 might be the reason to switch back. We will see. As for the driver issues, that is cause windows releases the software and then the hardware is provided by several companies which is up to them to not screw up there drivers. For apple they release one laptop and that is it. They only have to cater for that device which makes it a hell of a lot easier. Windows 8, has made huge progress in every hardware aspect of the machine.
Likes it
I've always gone thinkpad for Linux and never really been let down. I got an M$ Surface Pro 3 last month (don't laugh) but its actually first rate, hardware wise. Fedora doesn't quite work perfectly yet but its pretty close. High DPI touch screens rock!
Likes it
Have had my SP3 for more than a month now and I'm so happy I bought one. I've seen the previous models and read Penny Arcade reviews previously and was never quite sold on it. I went to MS's TechEd conference and had a play with one.. Everything just worked. It's better than any laptop I've owned and more convenient to boot. I wasn't even sold on Windows 8 prior to this, but now - bring on the change! The drawbacks: It runs hot. If you're watching a movie, it'll be fanning full speed. Having screen brightness to max will drain your battery in <4 hours. The kick stand is great but after a month of use it's no longer got that perfect rigid movement it once had, it moves slightly (< 2cm on the end) from what position I put it in. Paying separately for the keyboard which in my opinion is essential, and too pricey was annoying - but it's good quality and very nice to use. The end of the pen nib wears easily, however you can contact MS Support for free replacements. That's it. In the scheme of things that's piss all drawback for a mobile device. I'd put the engineering behind it next to that of my Nexus 5 phone. It just works.
Recommends it
I have got a Surface Pro 3 and I am likely to purchase few more over next year or so for family members. Very likely I will never purchase an iPad. The amazing part about SP3 is that you connect it to a large monitor it works just like a normal computer without breaking a sweat. Large companies like MS need to be super innovative to remain competitive in the absence of government protectionism. I am happy to see that Microsoft is back into the game well. I wish them success with the Lumia phones as well.
Neutral
The Yoga 2 and Yoga Pro are very good, cost effective, but a little bit heavier than the MS Surface Pro 3. The thing with the Surface Pro 3 is that it isn't a "laptop" it is a tablet with a keyboard, I like the keyboard for what it is, but I would never code full time on it (or use it as my only PC). The MBA is wonderful, really just wonderful, I have nothing but good things to say about it as a small light laptop. It is a little expensive but the touchpad is darn good and the keyboard is also a pleasure. I'd strongly suggest you head down to Best Buy. They have the Yoga 2, Surface Pro 3, AND MBA. So all three of your core options. Get a feel for the weight and the trade-offs. PS - I own a Surface Pro 3, it is good, but it is ultimately a tablet that can run x86-64 applications, and even with the kickstand it isn't as usable as a "real" laptop. Plus the dock is super expensive in its own right. PPS - Given your list and your requirements I suspect you'll get the MBA. It is the "boring" option but something can be said for just getting something which will simply work and is popular enough so you'll get good driver support on Ubuntu.
Likes itHasn’t owned it
Backups - http://lifehacker.com/how-to-back-up-your-computer-automatic... I don't use touchpads, even on my laptops. I use a vertical five button wireless mouse because I don't like to rotate my cuff all day since I get repetitive stress syndrome. However, my wife does use the touchpad on her Surface Pro 3 and it works just fine for her. Actually there is one touch pad that I do use for my entertainment PC in my living room and that is a logitech K400R. It also works just fine with two finger scrolling, swiping etc.
Likes itHasn’t owned it
>You can get a Surface Pro 3 for $799, if anything that's a bargain for what you're getting. Like I said, its worth the money for what you get, but that's not going to matter much. Most people spend less than $799 on a computer of any sort. >The only danger about that price point is that people might think it's an expensive tablet rather than a cheap computer.. Until they release a keyboard that actually transforms the device into a laptop, it is just an expensive tablet.