The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops · Lenovo ThinkPad

Lenovo ThinkPad T14s

26owners with an opinion
67%of verdicts positive
11/7positive/negative since 2024
2 yrslongest happy owner
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for performance and battery; criticized for comfort and display.

What people wrote

Doesn’t like itOwned 3 years
Same here, both X1 Carbon and T14s have had keyboard problems after 3 years or so, yet they keep making them thinner and worse to use. Lenovo seem determined to destroy the ThinkPad's best feature.
Doesn’t like itOwned 2 years
The latest ones are really terrible. The T490s was still passable, decent key travel. But the T14s gen3 I have now is super shallow and lacks feedback. It's like an apple keyboard :( I've had it for 2 years now and I still hate typing in it when it's not docked. It's horrible. I wanted to keep the 490s but my work didn't let me, couldn't buy it either. The stupid thing is that the 14s isn't even thinner. The base is thinner yes but the screen is almost double the thickness as before which wastes all the gains. Besides, the X1 carbon had a decent keyboard and was thinner and lighter. Not sure about the latest models of that though. I think Lenovo just stopped caring about making good hardware.
Likes itOwned 2 years
I've been running Linux on my laptop and on my workstation since the 90's. Still using it as my main driver. Fedora Kinoite is my distro of choice, and Lenovo AMD Thinkpad T14s the laptop. Everything works flawless, and it's still pretty fast even though it's two years old already. And I do not miss at all the Microsoft bullsh*t on tracking and advertising. Or the general sluggishness of Windows.
NeutralOwned 1 year
I have experimented with a Thinkpad T14s and Framework 13 AMD during the past year. Running Linux. I think the Framework is a much more solid machine. The quality of the hardware feels higher to me and I like the screen ratio more. The keyboard feels even better than my Macbook Air M2's. I would recommend it for Linux use at least. I don't know about Windows. If something closer to the hardware quality of Macbooks came along, I'd switch immediately, but there doesn't seem to be such a thing. Of course, I don't have the resources to try everything out there.
Doesn’t like it
Yeah us too. Just keep using the same hardware for a while longer is what they're saying. That's fine for me, 3 years was too short a cycle anyway. And lenovo's ThinkPad range have been getting much worse. My T490s still had a great keyboard but my T14s gen3 is terrible. Almost no travel and no feel to it. If it were up to me I would have kept the 490s but they insisted on replacing it :(
Doesn’t like it
The recent thinkpads are shit. They market high tech materials in the T14s machines but the bottom for a huge amount of the line is aluminium with plastic mounts glued to it. Those are fragile and break off. So really the whole magnesium alloy thing is performative. I preferred the older plastic coated Mg chassis ones. At least they were honest about the materials. Personally I avoid laptops now since the T430 line. Desktops are faster, cheaper, more reliable, easier to repair and replace bits and most of the time I don't need to carry a computer around.
Doesn’t like it
> It takes a hour of research to know if the trackpad is not-awful This, so much this! I run Asahi on M1 Air but wanted to upgrade to something with fuller Linux support. After trying Thinkpad T14s, trackpad quality has rosen to my attention, something I never thought about before. Turns out glass, haptic trackpads are still only available in probably about a dozen laptops on the market and it's not easy to actually know which ones are these!
Likes it
If you have an old M1 Macbook lying around, you use that to run a local model. Then it only costs whatever the electricity costs. May not be a frontier model, but local models are insanely good now compared to before. Some people are buying Mac Minis for this, but there's many kinds of old/cheap hardware that works. An old 1U/2U server some company's throwing out with a tech refresh, lots of old RAM, an old GPU off eBay, is pretty perfect. MacBook M1 Max or Mac Mini w/64GB RAM is much quieter, power efficient, compact. But even my ThinkPad T14s runs local models. Then you can start optimizing inference settings and get it to run nearly 2x faster. (keep in mind with the cost savings: do an initial calculation of your cloud cost first with a low-cost cloud model, not the default ones , and then multiply times 1-2 years, compare that cost to the cost of a local machine + power bill. don't just buy hardware because you think it's cheaper; cloud models are generally cost effective)
Likes it
Almost two years ago I bought an opened but never used ThinkPad T14s from eBay very cheaply. It's not too specced but it does the job and it will easily last me 2-3 more years at which point I just buy another one. I see what Framework is doing, and they probably need the support of customers to get the scale of Lenovo/Dell to lower the cost of production.
Likes it
Thanks for the info! My current laptop is T14s Gen 3 which I find perfect, but the screen size is a big insufficient for programming. I will be looking for a 16" laptop and currently there aren't that many options with a centred keyboard.
Neutral
And even the T14s (gen 1) has a "cheap" trackpad with a plastic foil on top instead of a glass surface. The day before yesterday I did the upgrade from foil to glass on my T14s and it isn't the big leap I was hoping for. Sure, friction went down a bit but precession and gesture detection were good before already. The same upgrade on a T480s was a bigger improvement. Compared to my MacBook Pro (M1 Pro) the trackpads of my ThinkPads are always worse. Overall I'm in the same situation as the author of the article (if you substitute Arch for pop!_os with Cosmic) and totally agree with him.
Doesn’t like it
Dells age really horribly though. Unlike ThinkPads (especially the IBM and early Lenovo days) I used to love my T490s even. It was a really recent model but still not bad for me. But now my work gave me a T14s and it's horrible. The keys have way less travel. The body is thinner but the screen is way thicker than the T490s's. I don't know what they're smoking but ThinkPads are dead as decent laptops.
Likes it
For me power draw is about battery life. If you occasionally need to work without a power plug, or carrying your laptop from meeting to meeting all over the office, you really appreciate when the power lasts all day. My T14s battery draw of ~6.5W on the 57Wh battery will last me ~8 hours, good enough for a day unplugged at the office. (I'd love a bigger battery, but it is what it is...)
Likes it
I have used Manjaro with i3wm (a tiling window manager) on a number of different Thinkpads and it's generally been pretty trouble free, and a lot of fun sometimes! Currently have an AMD T14s. Fwiw I tried Ubuntu desktop a few times before settling on Manjaro/Arch about 4 years and and it never clicked for me (though I'll happily use Ubuntu servers).
Doesn’t like it
I'm happy to see it go. I don't like them at all, and they're in the way of typing. It feels awful when I hit it by mistake because it has no 'give'. I always remove the little red hood to make it easier but you're still stuck with a hole in the keys. What I find much much more of a problem is the awful keyboards on ThinkPads these days. My T490s was the last with a serviceable keyboard. My new T14s has too little travel. It's awful to work on. Strange enough it hasn't become thinner due to the crap keyboard because at the same time they made the screen a lot thicker. Ps I don't like trackpads either. They're ok in emergencies but usually I just bring my mouse.
Likes it
Kind of a weirdly written article. Only one model removed the nub, and it's from one of its "we're trying to be MacBook" lines (the X line, like the Z line, are more about form than function). And all that tech shipped in its other lines for a while, afaik. I recently sold a Z13 because it had so many quirks (low battery life due to OLED, trackpad and trackpoint were crap, bluetooth barely worked through the dense metal chassis, display didn't fold down 180 degrees, felt heavy af). I got a T14s instead. Holy crap, it is so much better. Feels lighter, the touchpad and trackpoint are great, 500nits low-energy display is "ok" but battery can last all day. I use the trackpoint all the time (partly due to the touchpad drifting for some reason, and partly just to have a more precise pointer for fine work). The only downside is the lack of more USB-C ports. A random upside if you order it with Ubuntu: it comes with Secure Boot set up correctly. But then a downside: Linux kernel prevents hibernate from working if Secure Boot is enabled, unless you set up an encrypted swap and jump through hoops to set up the bootloader right (and of course it's not set up on Ubuntu). I can't believe it's still such a pain to get otherwise-standard laptop functionality with Linux.
Likes it
I have a T14s (AMD) which works very nicely, battery lasts for long 7-8 hours and things generally work. Before that, I had a P14s Gen1 for work. No matter what, that system runs a bit hot and battery times are awful. I haven't dedicated days to searching for fixes, but that's my point, it used to _just work_, and in this case, it works poorly. It used to be the case that outside of certain specific setups (like a dual-GPU machine), Lenovo Thinkpads would just work, Ubuntu certified or not. But that P14s G1 really soured my experience. I would advise you to check the return policy, maybe double-check if anyone has blogged about their device. FWIW I have had many thinkpads over the years, they _mostly_ work well. But there have been more misses as of late. I will add that I also own a Z13 Gen 1 and that it works well. Albeit the battery drains much faster because of the high-res oled screen. And I do think the palm-rest is a bit uncomfortable, the edges are too sharp, but that's not a Linux issue :D
Neutral
> Other than power user distros (arch, gentoo, etc) Linux has been one click install and ready to go just like windows for a decade (Ubuntu, fedora, etc) and provides a very good OOBE nowadays. So my experience with Ubuntu and Fedora on a new Thinkpad T14s Gen 3 (AMD) laptop has been a mixed bag. Lenovo state that this is an Ubuntu supported notebook so everything should have been compatible with no tinkering but that was not my experience. You're right, OOBE with distros today is good. But in day to day usage there were three very annoying problems: 1. The display flickers due to AMD's variable refresh rate feature (doesn't happen on Windows) - fixing this required a custom kernel with VRR disabled 2. The speakers sounded very quiet and anemic due to the laptop shipping with Dolby Atmos tuning - fixing this in Linux required installing Windows (which supports Atmos), recording a special diff file in Windows Audacity with Atmos tuning on/off and then importing that into PulseAudio on Ubuntu to give it the same speaker tuning profile 3. The trackpad scroll speed was way too fast and Gnome annoyingly offers no way to customize this - the solution is to edit one of the libinput-config files Granted the big stuff like Wifi, Bluetooth, GPU, printing and sleep all worked perfectly - even Steam + Proton worked out the box with games like Arkham Knight and Witcher running as well as Windows but little issues like those three above required a good few hours of tinkering in the comm…