The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Everything else

IBM Selectric

15owners with an opinion
83%of verdicts positive
4/2positive/negative since 2024
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for comfort and design; criticized for value and noise.

What people wrote

Doesn’t like it
I have, along with some other ones I created from different fonts. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1kXnsvYfaF4&t=2160s (it was an aside to a longer Selectric project I did; this typeball project came out around the same time so I decided to make a few of them). Watching this back, it partially works but some of the letters clearly need their positions adjusted, and some of them seem to have trouble imprinting fully on the page. That's besides the fact that the proportional fonts look pretty weird when printed monospaced. I didn't really go further with this because the resin printed balls didn't hold up very well. A slot near the hole would always break open, and then the ball would spin freely instead of being indexed like it was supposed to. These days I've pretty much abandoned home resin printing entirely since it is extremely messy, and I've never been able to make parts with it that weren't ridiculously brittle, even with the supposedly "strong" or "tough" resins. I've used commercial resin prints that Shapeways/Xometry/PCBWAY have and they are a lot tougher, so maybe they would work well.
Doesn’t like it
The problem with this 3D-printed typeball is that without being injection-molded with an extremely durable plastic, it will not make good strike. I suspect it would also be torn apart (separating at the printed layers), beginning with the smaller common characters (e.g. the period/comma would quickly fail). The typeball hits the paper hard and it is under incredible rotational strains. I've recently retired an IBM Selectric II, only because it is so damn finicky! When it is operating it is a fantastic machine, but it definitely needs a full-time technician to service (and they've almost entirely died off at this point, save for Berkeley). I got tired of the pulley creep [which eventually leads to gibberish output], only solved with continued maintenance (parts too fine for my electrician hands, and my nearsight is antiquating rapidly). For my daily drivers, I still love my Smith Corona "Coronet Super 12", which has individual strikes and a powerful motor (for all your latenight raging / brainstorming). Can't [easily] change the font, though (which is why I have multiple S-C models). ¢¢
Likes it
I have never seen a Selectric in which the ball moved instead of the carriage. I can't imagine how complicated the mechanics would be for that and how often it would jam, break, or malfunction. Certainly not something a company such as IBM would make their reputation on. I used many Selectrics in my time.
Likes it
I skipped typing classes altogether, and I'm not sure how; they were a requirement in every school district I attended and a prerequisite to the programming classes that I took instead. My typing has developed "organically"; I use most of my fingers at least sometimes, but heavier on index and middle. > IRC and AIM in the 90s/00s were the big drivers for fast typing. Those are how I developed my touch typing; the incentive was to see everything happening in the chatroom full of friends without missing anything, and being able to react quickly. > The tactile response and feel of an electric typewriter is pretty cool. Granddad was a retired IBM employee, and had a Selectric typewriter (either II or III, not sure). That thing felt (and sounded) awesome. The whir of the flywheel, the amazing feedback of the "thunk" of the ball hitting the ribbon. I used to type random crap that didn't need to be typed just to use that thing for a few minutes.
Likes it
Whoof — this brought back memories of endlessly typing things like... kkk kik kik k,k k,k jjj juj juj jmj jmj hhh hyh hyh hnh hnh ...on a lovely, bangy, ink-scented IBM Selectric in typing class. Which at the time felt like a meaningless exercise, but absolutely strengthened the ability of my fingers to find the right keys in a hurry without looking at the keyboard.
Neutral
A student organization I was an officer in had a Selectric with a correcting ribbon and I ended up using it for a lot of papers latterly. The newspaper had Royal typewriters and I used those. We did a bunch of literal copy/pasting and then stuff was typed into a huge typesetting system. Grad school (starting 1979), there was a mainframe with DecWriter terminals and that was a big improvement but still nothing like terminal GUIs.
Neutral
I took typing my freshman year of high-school (87-88 school year) and on an IBM Selectric typewriter I got up to around 40 wpm. A few years later I took a keyboarding class in college and got to somewhere around 70-80 wpm. I haven't tested my typing speed since, so I really don't know what it is these days. I rarely make it a point to try to type as fast as I can, and because I'm frequently switching between different computers, with different keyboards, I doubt I'm anywhere near my peak potential speed. If I was forced to guess, I'd say it might average out to something like 50 wpm.
Neutral
When I was in the Air Force and had to take a typing class (on IBM Selectrics w/ blank keycaps), they had a couple set aside with Dvorak keyboard layouts --- everyone was offered the chance to "type out" on the first day, by typing 50 WPM or faster after adjusting for errors (I did 65). The instructor noted that while folks often failed when testing on QWERTY, that he had never seen a formally trained Dvorak keyboard typist fail to type out, and that most were well above the average QWERTY speed.
Likes it
I first learned typing on a Selectric. The keyboard felt so nice, then they put me on a Commodore 64 and eww. I remember switching with my parent cause I didn't want to use the Commodore again, but after a few weeks I had to stop that as some assignments had to be handed in electrically (I think on disk, though my memory is fuzzy and network options did exist). I haven't seen a Selectric since, but I still remember how nice it felt to type on.
Likes it
About 10 years ago I started seeing writing as a creative practice very similar to playing an instrument. If you want to get good at playing an instrument there's no shortcut to replace playing a LOT. I found that when I wrote on a computer I was too distracted by where the writing would go. I was conscious of writing for an audience, and would get too caught up on saying things in a particular way- stopping starting deleting rewriting. I ended up getting a Selectric III, the pinnacle of mechanical typewriter achievement. It is a beautiful, heavy, loud machine. While there is a corrective function, I've never used it. Writing on a typewriter is like a one way street- words come out of your hands and can't be put back in. I was focused on pushing out as many pages as I could, practicing on the instrument for an hour a day or more. It changed my writing style and helped me discover a personal voice. I still use the Selectric for writing letters to friends, and for "daily driver" writing use an Alphasmart NEO (another beautiful purpose-built machine). Edit to comment on TFA: I use an "IBM Selectric Script" ball. A sort of light cursive.
Likes it
Nice. I signed up for the preorder. The first keyboard I used was an IBM Selectric on which I learned to type in a high school typing class. Great keyboard. Another aspiring software geek suggested the class. I am so glad I took his advice. The next keyboard I used was the DEC VT100. Again, a great keyboard. The third keyboard I used was on my Mac 128K. An okay keyboard. The fourth keyboard I used was an IBM Model M. An outstanding keyboard. I am typing on it now ;)
Likes itDoesn’t say they own it
Those beam springs had the second-best feel ever, after the Selectric. Then the Model F cost-reduced (and thickness-reduced) it, and the Model M further. > The downside is how tall and aggressively angled the keyboards are, which are very far from modern ergonomic standards. Like a typewriter. And like a typewriter, you were expected to have them on suitable furniture so the keytops were at the right height.
Likes itDoesn’t say they own it
"Mechanical keyboards" like these are not very mechanical. I've overhauled Teletype machines with real mechanical keyboards. You can only press one key at a time, because the encoding mechanism pushes back if you push two keys at once. When you press a key, it briefly locks down during the scan cycle, then releases. Typing is speed limited, and it's like playing a piano at a constant rate. An original IBM Selectric keyboard has the same lock-down properties, but allows one-key rollover. Nobody replicates that, although the Selectric was once held up as the gold standard of keyboards.
Likes itDoesn’t say they own it
Typewriters. One of those hobbies that's very malleable towards any given mood. There's a zen/expression interaction between the mechanical keystroke, sound, metal scent, etc. that puts me in flow much faster than anything else. When you want to tinker, they give both the challenge of complexity, the beauty of 100 years of design refinement, and a mechanism with no black boxes (unlike electronics). You can build a mental model of how the core design works very quickly and then decide how much or how little of the nuances you want to learn between various makes and models over the eras. If you want a true maintenance challenge, a Selectric is one of the more complex and beautiful purely-mechanical devices created by man. [ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BJITkKaO0qA ] Note, the average manual typewriter is conceptually 10x simpler, so if this video is intimidating, no worries! Very active communities centered around restoration, creative writing/blogging, pen pals, and collecting. Forums, discords, FB groups, meetups, international snail mail, etc. Inexpensive if you hang around some collectors groups and watch what prices they tolerate vs Etsy prices. Lots of sound machines can get the habit going in the $20-50 range. --- Other suggestions: * Funkier tech niches that are adjacent to the big popular ones, but aren't themselves big players--PDAs, Wonderswans, etc. * Instruments--another multi-sensory hobby * Foreign languages--if you're a native English speaker something like F…