The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Google Pixel

Google Pixel 5a

19owners with an opinion
38%of verdicts positive
6/10positive/negative since 2024
3 yrslongest happy owner
1happy after 3+ years

Praised for ease of use and battery; criticized for reliability and display.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 3 years
Yeah, we had a few Motos in my immediate family (Razr-i, G4P, G7P, G Power, G Fast), but I became disenchanted with the software updates. We still have a couple of these around for low security use, e.g. as a mini tablet/reader with no significant apps nor primary accounts signed in. Because of the software policies, we switched to Google Pixel (5a, 6a, 8a so far) for our actual devices used with mobile service and real accounts. The 5a was traded in to get a discount on the 8a right when its 3 year cycle was over. Now with the 6a having 5 years and the 8a having 7 years of updates, we might finally have a device that fails before its software is abandoned.
Doesn’t like itOwned 1 year
Same here; had a Pixel 5a with Google Fi. The 1 year old Pixel randomly died one day, totally bricked. Google phone support requires them calling you (after you request it online), and the browser-based “Fi phone” was unable to receive calls from Google phone support. No other callers had this issue. When I finally got in touch with them via my wife’s phone, they wanted me to drive 1.5 hours outside of SF for a phone diagnostic. I said no thanks and switched to iPhone with AT&T.
Neutral
Its taking me awhile (about a month so far) but Im migrating my Google Pixel 5A to Google Pixel 10 Pro and GraphenOS. Its a step but seriously worth it to avoid the Google stink. RFC messaging is the only real breakage Ive seen so far in that folks that have me in a group msg dont work any more (actually that COULD work as a feature and so far everyone Ive talked to that swear they sent a msg are iPhone users so it could be another Google-Apple pissing contest underway.
Doesn’t like it
I got badly burned by the Pixel 5a, but especially with Google's support. My wife and I both had 5a, and both died spectacularly right around the end of warranty period. Mine ultimately got replaced under warranty and that replacement died the same way when I was on vacation less than a year later... which they refused to repair under warranty. They put up such a shit show and had us run through so many hoops with my wife's phone that it ended up being out of warranty by the time they agreed it was broken and needed repaired. The support experience was so painful I reluctantly let them get away with their bullshit, bought a new phone (oneplus) for my wife, and swore not to buy another Pixel phone despite having a strong preference for them and the pure Android experience.
Doesn’t like it
I built it circa 2012 or 2013 and still have the physical win8 disc. I considered futzing with linux on it. The extent of my linux experience is via SSH to a raspberry pi kludging some docker containers for this and that. SSH/linux terminal feels like fumbling in a dark room flipping random switches until something works. >scrcpy I also have a pixel 5a whose screen doesn't work, but I think functions otherwise. Would this allow me to interface with it?
Likes it
My main phone is a Pixel 5a, for one reason: it is the most modern stock Android with a 3.5mm audio jack. My other phone is an iPhone, and as nice as it is in many ways, I hate that it's so much more awkward with a wired headset. Same for any modern Pixel too, of course. Google has stopped most updates for the 5a, and it is already at the point where a few apps don't 100% work. I should be able to get a couple more years out of it before I am just forced to stop using it. My fantasy is that either Google or Apple decides to release a new high-end phone with an actual audio jack by then. We will see.
Doesn’t like it
I've yet to notice a substantive difference between my current Moto g 5g, which cost ~150 USD and my previous phone, a Pixel 5a which cost ~450 USD. I balked at the price of the pixel at the time, but figured that's just the price of admission these days. It is now useless since the screen/mobo failed soon after I switched. After it was obsoleted, I just opted for the cheap Moto and will probably never spend more than 200 USD on a phone again.
Likes it
I'm not from the USA so I have never felt any kind of societal pressure to get an iPhone. And so, instead, I've been using Google hardware for years. I think the happiest I was might have been with the Pixel 5a, it was cheap and had a headphone jack and just felt like really good value. Now I'm on the pixel 8 pro and I'm genuinely thinking for my next upgrade to be an iPhone. The reason is that, if this is the direction that they're going for I'd rather just get a proper walled garden than one that's just not really going to be there.
Neutral
I recently switched to them as a step to help de-Google. Will not go back to standard Android and push for /e/OS at the moment. I don't mind the extra weight and size between the Fairphone 4 and Pixle 5a. Waiting on a purchase from Furi Lab to see if I can move even further away. Issue with most phone hardware with Linux is that they are all past products that don't have G5 support. Looks like all the push for Linux phones is coming from the EU and stale and stagnate in the USA, hardware wise.
Doesn’t like it
Was there a point to this story? I have a pixel 5a with a dead screen that runs but can't be used because the dead part is part of the motherboard not the screen. It's a known problem with this model. So it still runs, but I can't recover any pics or texts from dead people from it because I can't respond to the screen prompts to allow the USB connection. I don't see how I'm any better off.
Likes it
I held on to my Pixel 5a for as long as I could, primarily for that rear-mounted fingerprint reader. Such a wonderful implementation. Fast, accurate, and fingers just fell naturally into place when picking it up. I'm still dreaming that someday they'll return to that.
Doesn’t like it
I'm still salty about my Pixel 8 dying out because of the "green screen" bug (basically, screen just progressively turns greener until it stops working). Very common according to reddit, and the ubreakitifixit guy acknowledged it's a common problem as well. My Pixel 5a also had some shenanigans and my dad's pixel 6 as well No idea why they don't do proper Q&A. Looks like a good phone but yet fails in ways my work iphone never has.
Doesn’t like it
> This is a limitation/downside/flaw of "VA" LCD panels. OLED panels will not experience this... I don't know what to tell you, man. I'm seeing this behavior on a Pixel 5a. Purchased _directly_ from Google's store. Google says this model of phone has a OLED display... an HDR one, at that. [0] Not even the worst color transitions for my my VA monitor (a BenQ EWE3270U) streak this badly. [0] https://blog.google/products/pixel/pixel5a-with-5g-new-googl... >
Doesn’t like it
> ...if you're getting smearing of any kind it wasn't an OLED I have a Pixel 5a. It has _comically_ slow switching times between dark-ish colors and blacks that's most obvious with dark blue-family colors. If you have such a phone, go check out the "Gunnerkrigg Court" webcomic ( https://gunnerkrigg.com >), scroll down to the border between the comic and the blog part, and jostle the viewport up and down. If you go check out today's episode (comic 2929), you get an especially long trail of slow-transitioning pixels in the art that is particularly noticeable in the bottom panels of the comic, itself. (Examine the black borders of the people's hair, as well as the black frame of the comic panels. If you're not noticing it, scroll at a rate of travel of roughly one-quarter of the screen's height per second.)
Doesn’t like it
Manufacturers quote those response times, but worst-case response times are often at least a full frame, and sometimes multiple frames. Unlike with CRTs, response time is a factor of what color you're switching to and from, and their intensity, it's highly-variable, and it makes me so sad whenever an otherwise-lovely game happens to put colors together that very obviously smear on my monitors. (Also, see above for my report on the laughably bad color smearing on my Pixel 5a.) RTNGS usually has more-detailed breakdowns of best and worst-case color transition times for the monitors they test, as well as over- and under-shoot reports... which is a phenomenon that's just as bad as slow transitions between colors.
Likes it
Heh, just to weird you out, I'll share that I charge my Pixel 5a phone about once a week and my Garmin FR255 watch about once every two weeks. And that's while recording about 5-6 hours of GPS tracks per week on the watch. I spend a lot of time in front of large screens, so my phone is mostly there in standby either to let someone call me or to do a quick check when away from a better computer. If I'm going somewhere expecting a call while my phone is pocketed, I might look for call notifications on my wrist. But otherwise I'd rather just poll my phone infrequently. Since I'm not enslaved to notifications, I usually turn on the bluetooth link once weekly to allow the watch to sync health data and refresh its cache of GPS ephemera for quick location fixes.
Doesn’t like it
https://react.dev/learn is so slow on my phone, it takes 1.5s to open the burger menu, and about 1s to jump to a section. (Google pixel 5a). It must be some SPA that loads the whole documentation all at once I presume. A traditional MPA would probably work much better here. edit: and like the sibling comment noted, the history back button gets messed up. edit2: I mistakingly wrote nexus 5a instead of pixel 5a