The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Other PC parts and servers

Fractal Design Define

6owners with an opinion
80%of verdicts positive
3/1positive/negative since 2024
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for noise and design; criticized for portability.

What people wrote

Doesn’t like it
That's part of the reason I want to sell it - and hopefully get it into the hands of someone who can give it a second life before it becomes e-waste. I feel a bit guilty every time I think about it sitting and collecting dust. The specs are still more than enough for any of the development I do. My main issue is just the form factor - a laptop is so much better for my current situation. The power consumption also kind of bugs me - things have improved a LOT in that regard since 2019 - although it's kind of nice for heating my office in winter. It also doesn't help that I built it with a full ATX motherboard and a giant case (Fractal Design Define R6), which is kind of ugly and takes up a ton of space.
Doesn’t like it
I recently upgraded my home-NAS from a Fractal Define R4 to a Define 7 XL. The R4 had the rubber grommets, but hot-swappable trays that were just held in by spring force. As such they rattled a lot. The Define 7 has the same grommet system, but the trays can be fastened by screws to the support rails. The difference in noise was significant. Even though I went from 6 to 10 disks it's much more quiet now.
Likes it
Value was the driving factor for some of my early hackintoshing (Core 2 Duo era), but what pushed me to do it from 2015-2020 was the abysmal state of higher powered Mac hardware. The Mac Pro was still the un-updated 2012 trash can, the 15” MBPs were too thin for the CPUs they housed (perhaps Intel’s fault for getting stuck on 14nm for so long, but still) and were hot with terrible battery life, and while the 27” iMacs weren’t terrible and probably the best of the lineup, they still weren’t cooled quite as well as they should’ve been. My 6700k + 980Ti tower in a Fractal Define case with a big quiet Noctua cooler was just flat better and made a far better Mac than anything Apple sold at the time. That said, I did eventually grow tired of the tinkery-ness of it all and in 2020 picked up a refurbed base model iMac Pro, one of the few Macs in that timespan that wasn’t a mistake, for about half its MSRP. It was about as powerful as that tower, surprisingly even more quiet, and of course just worked without the tinkering.
Neutral
The first step would be to define what you want (& why & their priority for your budget), you would then search & select single components based on that. The what you want -step is really really important. E.g. I just built a PC ("Fractal Define R5" case + 3 low-RPM Noctua fans + MSI X570S motherboard + 128MiB RAM Kingston + 5 2TB NV2 Kingston NVMe + 1 AMD Ryzen 9 5950X + the only PCIe x1 GPU I could find which turned out to be nVidia) to run a Postgresql DB server. In my case I specifically ended up selecting for example MSI's X570S motherboard because it doesn't have an active fan for its chipset, the Ryzen 9 5950X because it has so many CPU cores that it would be able to manage my workload even when its "boost"-feature is disabled (in my case -15% less work done without CPU "boost" but at the same time with as well -33% watts used), all this because of wanting to have as less heat and noise as possible because I host this in my flat (trying to save $ by replacing a server which I used to host with "hetzner.com" for 100$/month). In your case your usecase will probably be different. In my case the whole experience hasn't been as smooth/mindless as multiple posts here mentioned: the RAM type/clock/whatever compatibility with the CPU&motherboard was the most scary one followed by the capability of PCIe x16 split to 4x4 (to have a single NVMe-card able to handle 4 NVMe at high speed). As well basic things like the pins of e.g. HDD-LED & Power & Reset & etc... of the case can…
Likes it
And the crazy thing is it's not even designed specifically for storage, it just kind of has that space. Good for big GPUs. I have a define 7 for my gaming pc with 0 HDDs installed (M.2 only)! It's a great case anyhow. I very nearly bought a second one to replace an actual designed-for-NAS case which only has room for 8 HDD; the only reason I didn't is because that older Fractal Design case still works fine. It lives in the living room in the open without shame, and the Design 7 would look even better.