The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Monitors · Dell UltraSharp

Dell UltraSharp P2715Q

8owners with an opinion
83%of verdicts positive
0/0positive/negative since 2024
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for reliability; criticized for performance.

What people wrote

Likes it
I haven't bought a Dell computer in many years, but I love their monitors. I started with the first 1920x1200 they offered probably fifteen years ago now, and have been through a series of them culminating in the two 27" 4k panels I have on my desk now (P2715Q and P2721Q). In that time I've never had a problem, not even a dead pixel that I've noticed.
Doesn’t like it
> Unfortunately, it seems a subset of monitors have a strangely broken behavior where, when waking up from standby, they will virtually disconnect their inputs a few seconds later, then connect them again. I'd be curious to know whether disabling "EUP Compliance"/"EUP Deep Sleep" mode resolves this issue. The long and short of it is that the EU passed some idle power requirements that monitor companies found difficult (or expensive?) to implement and it's caused basically a decade of weird bugs in PCs, docks, and other hardware. To hit the power target they put the monitor into a really really deep sleep state and some of the implementations don't always wake up properly, or do weird things as they wake back up and restart. (this occurs even on some premium monitors and brands... my Dell P2715Q is a very high-end monitor for its day and it has bad issues with freezing after wakeup!) This is the source of the classic "my monitor sometimes won't wake up after my PC goes to sleep, until I cycle the power to the monitor" and "all my desktop icons reshuffle themselves after sleep" and I suspect also the root cause of many "displayport issues" with thunderbolt docks. I think EUP power draw is also why many monitors "disconnect themselves" when idle... from the perspective of the PC it's in a deep enough state it's not even responding. This is legal behavior according to the spec, it's not incorrect to do so, but it's not required , and it confuses the PC which obviously now…
Neutral
I've got my main 4k Dell screen plugged in via HDMI. Then I've got two Dell 2.7k displays hooked up with this: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07C69HG33?psc=1 There is a little glitchiness but it is confined to: 1. the main display snows on startup very briefly every time so it requires a half second of patience. 2. once a month or so the main display just doesn't wake up from sleep and i have to restart the display, but this isn't a daily occurrence. 3. the displaylink adapter causes a "your screen is being monitored" warning message to pop up on the unlock screen which is ignorable. I was running that on my M1 mini with 3 displays and on my Mac Stadium. That might not be sufficiently pro-level enough for some, but I'm able to game on the main 4k display fine (although I don't tend to play bleeding edge games). I haven't needed to upgraded the other monitors to 4k and mostly use them to park chat apps and music streaming and other stuff. If you need wrap-around 4k monitors for your 3+ screen Eve Online gaming or whatever it is these days then it might not work for you. I don't push that DisplayLink adapter terribly hard. I have no special settings and the firmware on the monitors are probably many years old. YMMV. EDIT: I'm running 2xDell U2713Hm at 2560 x 1440 @ 60.00Hz and 1xDell P2715Q at 5120 x 2880 scaled to 2560 x 1440 @ 30.00Hz. Wonder if that 30Hz is why subnautica looks a little choppy, I figured it was doing well just to be playing under Rosetta at al…
Likes it
I heard about this bottleneck a lot, but I just haven't noticed it--I do not have thermal issues. I run in clamshell in a cheap vertical lap top stand. I rarely hear the CPU come on when I'm docked with the standard BM eGPU. I run scaled 'looks like' 2560 x 1440. I run tons of apps and browser tabs in multiple spaces. I only notice the CPU is weak when I'm encoding with something that isn't aided by GPU. One case I do hear the fan come on is near the end of a 200+ step unit test in pycharm on my primary personal web app. But that is just about the only time I can think of it comes on and it shuts back down as soon as my tests complete. (hopefully all passing!) A bit more on my specific setup: - 2018 MBA (maxed out) - Dell P2715Q monitor - Blackmagic eGPU - Edifier S880DB (USB HD Audio) - AT2020 USB+ mic - Logitech C920S webcam - Vertical Laptop stand - Magic keyboard / trackpad This setup is probably the best I've ever had, because the portability is great and the docked situation is just very, very good. All those peripherals off a single connection to the laptop. I am hoping that the ARM mac will have much better graphics, but I think it is likely at least the first two generations of it will still be majorly improved even by the 580 in the current blackmagic. It is worth mentioning that I do try to use the software disconnect of the eGPU and have had that just stall out or not complete. I have not tried the trouble shooting someone suggested here though--and it is so stab
Neutral
my setup: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/559047/doupe.jpg middle: 5K, iMac (mid 2015) left: 4K, 27" Dell P2715Q right: old Apple Cinema LED Display 27" mid-bottom-left: iPhone 5s, for testing mid-bottom-right: iPad Air, for testing, sometimes TweetDeck/HipChat with DuetDisplay I think 5K iMac can drive 5K, plus two external 4K displays at full speed without issues edit: also note that all the displays are 27", so they naturally fit side-by-side, that seems to be a detail, but it is quite important for seamless mouse movement (aligned virtual desktops). Even if physical pixel densities are not the same, all displays have the same virtual size: see https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/559047/aligned-displays.... . And the keyboard: http://www.daskeyboard.com , also highly recommended for a developer.
Recommends it
This may be above your budget but I have this one and I'm extremely happy. Retina quality is superb and comparable to my Macbook Pro's retina screen. https://www.amazon.com/Dell-Monitor-P2715Q-27-Inch-LED-Lit/d... It's about $150 more than your budget allows but I made a liberal interpretation of your "$300-ish".
Recommends it
Remember that the size of the screen determines how much "real estate" you have. It's easy to think that higher resolutions will allow you to see more. It's hard to say if it's worth it or not. Software support is getting much better but the benefits seem unclear. I recommend Dell P2715Q. It's $700 for 27" (though Dell often has sales/coupons - I got mine for about $500). IPS + matte. The stand is pretty decent. Nothing stupid like a glossy bezel, etc. I'm not sure I would but it again. I use 19020x1080 monitors at work and don't notice a big difference. Plus monitor resolutions jumped up quickly (after being stagnant for so long) but video cards didn't. Not a huge issue for editting text but something to consider. You can always game in 1920x1080 (and it will look fine) but alt-tabbing to your desktop will be slow.