The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables · Apple Watch

Apple Watch Series 9

6owners with an opinion
67%of verdicts positive
4/2positive/negative since 2024
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for reliability and ease of use; criticized for value.

What owners wrote

Likes it
It may depend on skin type, body composition and wrist hair - perhaps the validation work used a skewed sample? I’ve found the sensor to give stable results, with repeated measurements always within 2 percentage points. And the results give qualitatively very reasonable data when I sleep at high altitude. The readings have a clear dependence on the elevation. I haven’t cross checked against other meters, but my Apple Watch 9 sensor gives stable and reasonable results that match expected altitude trends. So yeah it may not be tuned to a wide enough variety of wrist types.
Likes it
My sleep tracking works pretty well on my S9. It isn't perfect and there are glitches and bugs I've noticed, but overall the long term trend tends to even out and feels pretty comparative to my old Fitbit.
Doesn’t like it
Meh. Stopped wearing my S9 in May. Not sure why I bought it. Think AW wore off here finally. It’s a nice toy but useless for me (even cycling / hiking etc). I take an F91W when I go hiking as it doesn’t need charging.
Likes it
Yes, thanks for asking. Continous Glucose Monitors (CGM). That used to be a diabetic-only problem until Abbott, Dexcom,and other vendors expanded their markets beyond diagnosed diabetics into pre-diabetes markets and exercise, health, and well-being applications like: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10635370/ and: https://www.levelshealth.com/ This has exploded beyond the hundred years of ketogenic research and as research on glycemic variability in mental health has grown. My current kit includes an Apple Watch series 9 and an iPhone SE. Prior to that it was Google Pixel and a Fitbit Sense, though direct BTLE->Watch was not an option in that generation. I have two complications: Abbott Freestyle Libre 3 and Dexcom G7. Continuous Glucose Monitors (CGM). The Dexcom is entirely proprietary. The Abbott is accomplished via a series of 3rd party hacks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YqUZjXo5VXY I'd say open source, but I'm not certain that every link in the chain is open source. I've run many generations of various open source tools on Android and iPhone since no vendor ships a complete end-to-end solution that is perfect. Nightscout and watchdrip are two open source examples: https://nightscout.github.io/ https://watchdrip.org/ When G7 originally shipped last year, sensor data left the sensor and used the iPhone as a proxy-to-cloud storage, as has become the default mode across many IoT devices because it was easy, obvious, despite the unintended consequen…
Doesn’t like it
I recently had my Apple Watch (Series 9, few months old) touch screen refuse to respond to touch input, and instead issue seemingly random pokes and drags until it eventually worked its way toward calling 911. After assuring the operator that it was just my nearly-new Apple Watch freaking out, I was able to dig up an Apple Support article that outlined how to hard reset it with the physical buttons, which still worked. Apple's quality control has been getting worse every year. This is something we say every year; that's because its true every year. They started the highest coming out of the 2000s, plenty big laurels to rest on. But their (and Microsoft's) software has gotten so bad nowadays that linux desktops are starting to look stable (and don't interpret that as an endorsement of the improvements in stability of the linux desktop experience, not even close, year of the linux desktop might happen but only because everything is so shit that you might as well at least use the shit that isn't taking screenshots of your desktop or resurfacing photos you deleted five years ago).