The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables · Apple Watch

Apple Watch Series 3

10owners with an opinion
38%of verdicts positive
1/3positive/negative since 2024
6 yrslongest happy owner
1happy after 3+ years

Praised for performance and ease of use; criticized for reliability and design.

What owners wrote

Doesn’t like itOwned 9 years
Apple Series 3 owner for about 9 years. 1. Notifications. Most useful in noisy environments such as grocery stores, airports, shop floors, or any place you may be wearing hearing protection. Also great while working with your hands, like car work or cooking and directions while driving. It’s best to limit them to the apps that matter, and only when you need them. 2. Biometrics. However, after this watch finally dies, I don’t think I will be going back. Big reason is smart watches are not stylish at all. For men watches are our only fashion accessory that we can freely wear in all occasions. No matter what band or watch face you use you are stuck with a black square attached to your wrist. Also smart watch battery life is a bit of a bummer, it’s hard to beat self winding or solar powered watches that you never think about changing as long as you wear them.
Likes itOwned 6 yearsStill going
I’ve had the series 3 for almost six years now. It still works fine, and even though I’m very tempted to upgrade there is no immediate need. So the lifespan of these devices is actually pretty good. I like the Apple Watch a lot. There’s not a single killer feature in my opinion, just a bunch of small stuff that together makes it very nice. Like using it as an alarm clock without sound to not wake the rest of the family. Or timers when cooking. Or seeing how much (or more likely how little) I move about in a day. Seeing how many hours of sleep I got, taking into account my toddlers wake me up a few times every night. Having my todo list (Todoist) on the wrist, even though I’ll admit it’s pretty slow and I can’t quite get used to dictating my tasks. Seeing the weather for the day through a glance at a my wrist, to quickly know whether to bring a rain coat or not. Seeing the UV-index on a sunny summer day, to know how worried I should be about sunscreen for my kids. Seeing my schedule for the day without having to pick up my phone. Always having the phone on silent without missing calls or texts. Pinging my phone when I forget where I put it. None of these features make the watch worth it on their own, but in aggregate it’s an amazing device and if it ever breaks down I’ll buy a new one in a heartbeat.
Doesn’t like it
I have somewhat different store. Moved to Garmin (for sports and outdoor activities) and Mido as an everyday watch from Apple Watch (had 3 and 7 versions). Can't really imagine going back. I guess I was sold the idea that I neeed notifications, weather and all this bullshit on my wrist all the time. At some point I realized I've disabled notifications completely and basically the only thing I was using my Apple watch was paranoidal heart rate monitoring. >Swiss mechanical movement yada yada yada... Most swiss mechanical movements cost 50-100$ though.
Neutral
I had a Series 3 Apple watch, I also had atrial fibrillation. I upgraded to the Series 7 and it's recordings, though dismissed my doctors but supported by their choice of detectors enabled us to determine the probable cause. I have hearing loss and the hearing aids I bought a few years ago cost me £4,000 / pair. I lost one. My insurance excess is less than a pair of Apple Pro 2 earphones. [1] I'm not sure what else they could produce in the health sphere that would directly benefit me but so far what they are doing is great. [1] One caveat: If you see me and realise I am wearing a hearing aid you will probably react in a different way to if you see me wearing Air Pods and assume I'm listening to music (which I think was a point made here a few days ago but which happened to me today at the pub).
Neutral
About the Apple Watch... I have an Apple Watch Series 3 at the moment. You seem to upgrade your watch much more frequently than I'd do. Could you give me an idea what gets significantly better at each upgrade? (not trying to criticize your choices: I checked the current models and did not find anything particularly compelling for my use cases... but I wonder if I am maybe missing something without realizing)
Doesn’t like it
> Contactless payments up to £1000 mean I can pay for basically everything without touching anything. This feels like a good opportunity to reflect on the Apple Watch, and security around contactless payments. Try taking off your apple watch, but keeping your fingers pressed against the back of the watch as you do. If you time it right (it's really not difficult to time it right), you can take off someone's watch and place it on your own wrist, without triggering the lock. If you have a debit or credit card associated with your watch, you're now at risk of a supposedly authenticated card payment occurring. (I removed all my cards from my Apple Watch S3 when I realised this vulnerability)
Doesn’t like it
I had an Apple Watch Series 3 back when they came out and ended up returning it. It actually had a fault too, but I chose to take the refund rather than a replacement because I didn't find myself liking it so much. I initially went for it for stuff like notifications and hoping it would make me more productive and help me track my time better. Ultimately, I think the ecosystem has potential but it's in its infancy currently. Main good points, though: - Fitness tracking. If you do things like running or swimming you'll benefit from the watches. Most useful functionality is for fitness. - Elderly people. I think the functionality for falls, although it seemed like a joke to some, can actually be pretty useful for older people and encourage more independence. I think it has the potential to be useful in more areas: - Health. I think the heart rate and ECG is genuinely beneficial. Many people have cardiovascular conditions or are on medication and doctors advise them to take regular checks of heart rate, blood pressure, etc. But in my experience with the Series 3, the heart rate functionality was a mess. My HR was around 65, whenever I opened the app on my watch it would start at 120bpm and slowly go down to my actual HR. It would log all the results in the watch app, even the very incorrect readings of 120bpm. I hope they fixed this since. - Sleep tracking. The Apple Watch doesn't currently have native sleep tracking, though 3rd party apps exist that I've never tried (they may b
Likes it
I have the T-Mobile version of the LTE dumbphone (Alcatel Go Flip). It can be used as a hotspot, wifi calling, and HD voice (much clearer than previous dumbphones). KaiOS is really laggy unfortunately. I haven't used that phone in 6 months or so because I switched to an Apple Watch series 3. I've never had a smartphone as my actual phone. I synced it to my SIM on my wife's phone with my Apple ID, then reset her phone back to her stuff. The watch works great as my only phone. Eats batter power, about 15 hours per charge, less if I talk or listen to music more than a couple hours per day. Looking forward to watchOS 5 because it will the phone self-manage wifi settings, which should fix a lot of the battery issues. Right now I can only connect to one wifi network (since I don't have a phone to sync to that manages it). Once I can connect to my home and office wifi, battery life will improve. Not having a phone in my pocket ever again is a great feeling. Just the default apps on it. Wish I could stream podcasts. I still keep the dumbphone around the house in case I need to take an SMS (Apple Watch apparently doesn't handle those either, just Apple Messages).