The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets · Apple Pencil

Apple Pencil 2

8owners with an opinion
83%of verdicts positive
0/0positive/negative since 2024
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for ease of use.

What people wrote

Likes it
> Anyone have experience of using an iPad mini for this. Is the form factor do-able or really too small? I contemplated doing that, but went with an iPad Pro instead (11’’, second hand). Even 11’’ felt a bit small and I got a 13’’ eventually. Besides screen size, the Apple Pencil 2 is miles better. > I like that I could read lying down with one hand, which I can’t achieve with a full-sized iPad. Yes, for reading a Mini would be much better. More Kindle-like. The 11’’ Pro is still manageable with one hand (but without a case), but it’s not comfortable.
Likes it
I'm a note taker and I got tired of having hand written notes scattered all over and never being able to find the note I needed. So took a leap and purchased an iPad Air and an Apple Pencil 2. I carry it with me and make all my notes there. I use it way more than I ever imagined. I use the Paperlike screen protector to make it feel more like writing on a notebook. And it has all the added benefits of an iPad.
Likes it
> after more than a thousand years. A lot more than a thousand years[0]. I have an iPad Mini with a PaperLike screen protector, and Pencil 2. Works wonderfully. I have a number of apps to convert input, and they work quite well. Apple did very well, with Pencil 2 (don’t get me started on Pencil 1). I still prefer a paper notepad, most times, though. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Papyrus
Doesn’t like it
All my experiences with Apple have been far below the expectations set by "it just works". For example, don't use an Apple smartwatch to keep time (the clock will fall behind and stay there, even after interacting with the display to "wake" it up.) The "Pencil 2" stylus they sell for iPads can't be used exclusively. (E.g. activating the "Command Center" requires you use your finger.) They build advertisements into the OS (very notable if you don't use iCloud) and reset preferences willy-nilly (such as if you have iMessage disabled.) I hope more people talk about these issues, I'd love to see Apple pressured to make meaningful improvements.
Likes it
I was a pretty staunch opponent of the iPad for a very long time. Tablets were clearly a consumption device, and I've always disliked Apple's penchant for proprietary connectors. However, things have shifted enough that on the artistic/creative front, the iPad is actually a really nice thing to have. When the iPad Air 4 (I think? The iPad ecosystem has terrible nomenclature) came out, it not only had a USB-C connector, but worked with the Apple Pencil 2. I did something I thought I'd never do - I bought an iPad. There are music & synthesizer apps that only make sense on a tablet, and they can talk with other music apps on the iPad pretty seamlessly too these days. And with the Apple Pencil 2, it's like a magic art pad. I've been sketching and drawing and 'painting' like I haven't done in 20 years. And I can charge it with the same cable that charges my Pixel 6, my work-issued Macbook pro, or my wife's Thinkpad's power supply. It certainly took long enough, but I no longer think that iPads are pure consumption devices. Now... would I try to use it the way I use a laptop? Oh, hell no.
Likes it
I've been drawing digitally for around 15 years, starting with the original Wacom tablets. For drawing, my iPad Pro (2018) with the Pencil 2 feels like magic. In my experience, its latency is much better than the Cintiq or the Surface. It feels so much like drawing on paper, especially with a matte screen cover. Every time I use it to draw, I feel like I'm living in the future. No piece of technology has impressed me to this degree. That being said, outside of digital art, it's pretty clunky. The lack of a mouse pointer and proper multitasking makes it less than ideal for business uses. But when I'm drawing on it though, man, I feel like Tom Cruise in Minority Report
Likes itDoesn’t say they own it
Right. The Apple Pencil 2 (used on more expensive iPads) connects to the side of the iPad magnetically and charges that way. It looks nice and works fine. The original way (stick straight out of the port) worked but was always weird. They had a chance to fix it and… compromised? The “fixed” the iPad by going USB-C, which is good. They don’t have to redesign the first Pencil which is fine (it’s cheaper than v2) but that left them with… this. Very un-Apple. More than the original.
Likes itDoesn’t say they own it
Oh wow! That looks really nice. For reading and such an e-ink display seems nicer. Very tempting haha, I might order one. Can also recommend an iPad btw. Besides being an excellent note taking device it does all sorts of other cool stuff. (If for note taking/drawing; I suggest get one that supports Apple Pencil 2, it's a big improvement.)