The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops · Apple MacBook

Apple MacBook 2016

6owners with an opinion
50%of verdicts positive
2/2positive/negative since 2024
10 yrslongest happy owner
1happy after 3+ years

Praised for support and portability; criticized for reliability and build quality.

What people wrote

Likes itOwned 10 yearsStill going
The quibbling about ram is strange only because Apple is much better positioned to utilize ram since they are vertically integrated. I produce music and occasionally compile Haskell on my 2016 MacBook with an i3 and 8gigs of ram. So I’m in the 99th percentile power user and a 10 year old machine works great. I bet the new Mac would be even better. It doesn’t have 8gigs of ram to cheat the consumer. It’s because this company can do 10000 hours of user testing to see what people need to do their normal people things.
Doesn’t like it
Throttling issues? Did you know the MacBook Neo has no fan? It can go 2x faster FPS in games if it’s cooled better: https://youtube.com/watch?v=lswbpVtAhrc Even a simple quiet and mostly-off fan would have been a $5 addition to the system that would have boosted performance by ~10%. But Apple wanted to make an iPad computer. Apple advertises their subscription services directly in the system settings when you buy the system (they give you a trial that is shown as a system settings notification and when you refer it they do the thing where you have to cancel on the last day or else forfeit the remaining trial term before it’s over; accidental subscription dark pattern where you can’t turn off auto-renew without forfeiting remaining time) and also advertises apple subs via toast notifications. As far as device firmware, I dunno, I felt like my Intel MacBook Pro 16” had pretty shit firmware that ended up abandoned because Apple went straight to M1 and the whole T2 thing where they tried to customize Intel’s stack never really worked all that well. Apple almost certainly half-assed that machine knowing their next platform was on the way. Like the whole “instant open lid wake from sleep” that was great in the past but turned into crazy lag on those late Intel machines. Oh yeah and I just got my last settlement check for my 2016 butterfly keyboard. That machine was a lovely ownership experience. So this idea that only PC laptops have firmware issues and bad long term support…id…
Doesn’t like it
I'm going to purchase a framework just because I value repairability. And honestly, before the m1 macbook I was using a t480s, and I'm okay with compromising on hardware, esp. having been burned with the 2016 butterfly macbook. Apart from the haptic touchpad I wouldn't miss much, other makers are finally ditching low resolution 16:9 screens and you can even find nice oleds. I'm mostly missing the polished software that's only available on macos (things like carbon copy cloner or pixelmator). But with my m1 having degraded battery and having to send it off for a week or two to the nearest service center just to get a new battery, the prospect of a repairable laptop like framework where I can just order a new battery and replace it myself is looking all the more enticing.
Doesn’t like itDoesn’t say they own it
Just for the record, I agree with you. I'm not sure if I worded my response correctly. I also think the keyboard on the Speak & Spell is better than the 2016 Macbook keyboard.