The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Apple iPhone

Apple iPhone XR

24owners with an opinion
64%of verdicts positive
7/8positive/negative since 2024
5 yrslongest happy owner
1happy after 3+ years

Praised for reliability and support; criticized for ease of use and software.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 5 years
iPhone XR was released in 2018, and I got mine in 2019. It will still be supported by iOS 18, which is being released in 2024. 5-6 years of fully functioning hardware with official OS updates is much better than the Android phones I had before it.
Likes itOwned 2 years
I had android for years, and I got tired of the buggy experience after a year of usage, and dying when I needed the most. I switched to an iphone XR, and the phone worked perfectly for over 2 years, after which I gave it to another family member and I switched to a 13 pro. Are they expensive? For sure yes, if you go top of the line, but even an older one works perfectly fine for 99% of people needs, and they will save you time and headaches for several years. That's the selling point, they are easy to use, and last a long time (in tech world terms). "It just works" is not only marketing.
Likes itOwned 1.5 years
> everything Apple has been marketing spin for decades. After using Android since around 2010 getting a midrange iPhone around 18 or so months ago was almost a revelation for me, so no, it is clearly not all marketing spin. (Why? Even on a Note II or S7 Edge something as trivial as opening the camera would have me waiting. On my iPhone XR pressing the camera button brings up the camera more or less instantaneously. And there are also a number of small conveniences that are hard to really pinpoint like actually understanding when it is in my pocket and then not turn on and burn out my battery.)
Doesn’t like it
Not sure about iPads, but going from a pixel 3 to a pixel 5 made me feel like my pixel 3 was broken. Xr to 16 pro was similar, but that is because Xr was legit broken.
Doesn’t like it
Yeah, I’m not a dedicated iPhone user and my personal phones are androids so my iOS experience has been iPod Touch 2G -> employer owned iPhone 8 -> employer owned iPhone XR -> iPad Air M3. Each of those big gaps have seen the UI shift and the keyboard decline.
Doesn’t like it
Yea I just swapped my jogging/beach iPhone from an Xr to an iPhone 12 and wow, it's so much better than the Xr and pretty much as good as my "proper" phone, an 17Pro. It's got 4G RAM instead of 12G but it performs almost as well. Xr->12 is a huge leap in performance and I noticed it straight away. But the 12 against the 17 is much harder to see the difference. Less redraw of icons on the main screen is the primary thing I've noticed.
Doesn’t like it
I have a 12 mini. I did have an XR briefly but had to send it back because it was terrible - far too large. When the 12/13 minis stop receiving updates I guess I’ll stop carrying a phone around. Which will actually be a good thing Nothing (handheld) is as good as typing as my old blackberry curve though. Not even my psion5
Doesn’t like it
I've got the exact same storage issue on my iphone xr. Happened once before and it was fixed by doing a full reset and restore. That lasted about 6 months. I don't want to keep doing resets every 6 months. Has anyone found a simpler solution?
Likes it
"Slow phone with slow animations" is a crazy assessment, I switched from Galaxy S7 to iPhone XR in 2018 because the Galaxy was (like every other Android I had) slow to do everything, applications would crash randomly and my phone would just give up and reboot without warning. Not to mention all of the killer Android features that Google had gotten rid of up to that point (RIP notification ticker, I miss you so much). What's the point of being able to sideload and customize when none of it works on a day to day basis? And when Google/other Android phone manufacturers insist on their phones being more and more similar to iPhone/iOS, the reasons to stay on Android go away too.
Likes it
At some stage, "improvements" become nothing more than marketing buzzwords. I'd argue one reason ICE are "stagnant" are because they're "good enough" and any potential improvements required expensive R&D and manufacturing changes, for results that purchasers won't change their buying decision for. Maybe Toyata could make an ICE for the Camry that was 5% more efficient, but few people who were about to buy someone else's equivalent car will choose a Camry instead based on such a marginal improvement. I think phones are a good current example of this. I have felt zero need to upgrade from my iPhone 13, because the "improvements" since it was new are of zero interest or value to me. I'm quite likely to do a battery replacement on this one instead of upgrading to a new iPhone any time soon. (And the only reason I bought the iPhone13 was to get the backside lidar, I was perfectly happy with the XR I used before that.)
Likes it
iPhone 14 to 17 is still a solid step up. +10 hours battery. 120hz display. 48mp cameras vs 12, way better front camera... and USB-C. But if this is too minor a bump for you then just hold onto the 14? One of the great things about these recent phones is how long they last if looked after. I'm getting 17 after skipping 6 generations with my XR and it's been great this whole time. Only really upgrading now due to crappy battery life and no longer getting the latest OS versions, which I need to run. And with 6 generations skipped the step up seems major.
Likes it
I replaced my old iPhone XR with a brand new 16 this year, not because anything was wrong with it (even the battery was OK), but I wanted to see what the changes brought. I was quite surprised that other than the much better battery, USB-C, and much better camera, and sometimes faster speed, the old one was holding up quite well. You can get an old iPhone XR for 100 EURish, in decent condition. I really have no idea what model year iPhone's others have.
Doesn’t like it
Back when I got my iPhone XR I immediately thought it was too thin, and got a case for it which added a non insignificant amount of thickness.
Likes it
I'm currently using an iPhone 13 from late 2021, so almost 4 years old. It's showing 79% Maximum Capacity in Battery Health, and I only occasionally use more then 75% of battery over a days use. I still have the iPhone XR I upgraded from, so a 7 year old 2018 phone, that still holds a whole day's charge too (but doesn't get much use, and doesn't have a SIM in it right now so I'd guess it's powered down the cellular radios?) I have an iPod Touch from a bit before Covid, so 6 years old from 2019-ish - it stopped getting daily use when Covid and WFH hit, so it's battery is old, but still in reasonable condition. (Pity newer iOS won't run on it...)
Doesn’t like it
Build quality too. My iPhone XR that I am deliberately keeping on lower iOS for jail breaking reasons that when comparing the thunderbolt port to the iPhone 13. The quality lacks so much that I am unable to listen to music with a wired headphone adapter. Any slight jiggle of the adapter will cause it to disconnect. I don't want to use BT headphones.
Likes it
Still rocking my iPhone XR with zero plans to change or upgrade phones. If I did or were forced to upgrade I would most likely go for something like this or an older 12 or 14 with a few features as possible.
Likes it
I also prefer to up front whenever possible and never had a phone paid by contract. I buy an iPhone preferably used and use it until major OS updates are no longer available. I currently use an iPhone XR from 2018. I think that long term with iPhone it’s cheaper than doing the same with Android unless you go with really budget ones like 150 €, but that’s to bad of an experience for me. What I also really like with iPhone is that you can get really cheap displays and batteries which is not the case for Android phones in my experience.
Likes it
Is Indonesia even a big enough market for Apple to need to worry about losing it? Looks like Asia Pacific in general is a very small portion of Apple's revenue. https://www.statista.com/statistics/382175/quarterly-revenue... On a side note, iPhone's seem to last quite a while. I still have a Xr and it runs the latest iOS quite well, so people might be good for a while if they stick with the 15.
Doesn’t like it
Owing to my carriers not supporting e-SIM, I have two phones — the other is an iPhone XR with Face ID. Unless I'm travelling to the UK, for which I need the other SIM, the XR serves a similar role as an iPad mini would if I were in any sense a "normal person". The technical stuff is all fine, and it works as you say (I noticed the "look at screen" requirement myself a while back); my dislike is purely the practical issues, not the technical, as the arrangement of the contactless mechanisms in stores means the camera can either face me or the device can be close enough to the reader to work, but not both. Also, I'm still wearing masks quite often (not 100% of the time as when I bought the SE, but quite often) and for that, Touch works better than Face. I suppose theoretically I could set up the Wallet on the Apple Watch, but I find the watch to be disappointingly difficult to get on with, again for UX reasons. (On screen buttons are too small and often reject touches entirely, everything is so slow to respond it might as well be going via a random website). Regarding security, there's inherent (and fairly low) limits to the maximum payment, and cards can be disabled in banking apps if they go missing. (I'd count your anecdote as "UI team": developer-designer collaboration rather than siloing each speciality).
Neutral
I use Linux on my home and work computers (I'm the tech person at a small government entity and no one cares what OS I use) by choice and preference, and iOS because this iPhone XR (from 2018, I think?) was a hand me down from a friend who likes to buy new phones. I used to use Android phones, and prefer them because of F-Droid and ease of connecting to my computer. The software iFuse on Linux has been indispensable. I'm mostly disillusioned with these machines.
Likes it
This works great for me. I have only a few apps, like a piano tuner, don't use Safari on my phone, and its peaceful. The key to me is to stop looking at the phone as a computer and use it just for texting and calls. I bought a refurb, like-new, unlocked iPhone XR 64GB in 2020 for $500 on eBay to replace an Android phone, because Google's forced updates kept breaking basic phone features, like zooming a picture. I had updates and WiFi disabled, but somehow they managed to shove updates on me anyway. That and their constant nagging for more permissions for basic things like texting and speech-to-text.
Likes it
Yeah I do a lot of walking and long trips. I had a mid range DSLR and it was horrible carrying it everywhere and juggling lenses and batteries. The iPhone works 90% of the cases perfectly and the last 10% of the cases, I am happy with the compromise. Edit: The thing that really killed the DSLR for me was lugging the whole kit up Scafell Pike in the pissing rain and cold in the UK. I got some good photos in the morning but carried a brick for the entire day after the battery dumped because of the cold. I had an iPhone XR back then and that kept me going all day fine. When I got back the whole damn camera despite being weather sealed had condensation in it.
Likes it
> On Apple: good luck :) (or feel free to write a tip for others -that use apple- see. Lockdown Firewall. With that I can have a nice, midrange phone like my XR that blocks ads and opens the camera when I click the camera button - not 2,3 seconds later when the fun is gone. You are welcome, have a nice day. FWIW I was an Android user from HTC Hero until late last year. I cannot stand Mac, but on phones my midrange iPhone beats all the flagship Android phones I used over the years.
Likes it
As someone who very recently went from an iPhone SE - which I treasured since it came out (and which I nursed through one battery replacement and two screen replacements) - to an iPhone XR (triggered by a another digitiser failure), I can honestly say that I’m loving the performance boost, the massive battery life, the better camera and the brighter screen. However it’s taking some time to adjust to the size (150.9mm x 75.7mm x 8.3mm, versus the SE’s 123.8mm x 58.6mm x 7.6mm). I used to be able to slip my SE comfortably into the front pocket of my pants or jeans, and it’s size coupled with its rigidity meant I never worried that sitting or bending would damage it or discomfort me. I could even put it in a shirt pocket, where it’s relatively light weight (113g vs the XR’s 196gm), wouldn’t cause undue sag in my shirt. For me it’s definitely been a trade off. Having gotten mostly used to it though, (meaning I now carry my phone in my hands much more than I ever did), I don’t think I would go back unless I could get significantly better specs than the original SE (performance, batter, brightness, camer) in the smaller form factor. EDIT: correction to first para.
Likes it
Interesting to see so many people here prefer smaller phones over big ones. I was using iPhone 5, 5S, and SE for over 6 years. This Christmas I switched to XR and I couldn't be happier. I feel like there are so many productivity things I can do on my phone that were annoying before. I use notes, emails, and even Google Spreadsheets much more. I started using the Kindle app for reading and I actually like it. Sometimes, I even prefer it over Kindle (mostly because of what I can do with highlights right away). The only downside is that a pocket on my favorite jeans isn't big enough. So the phone often has to go inside my backpack.