The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Apple iPhone

Apple iPhone Pro Max

10owners with an opinion
57%of verdicts positive
1/1positive/negative since 2024
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for design and battery; criticized for ergonomics and portability.

What people wrote

Neutral
I bought a Pro Max for myself and an Air for my wife, who had a Mini before. The Air is DAMN SMALL. You really should try holding it. Yes the 2D dimensions are as large as a normal modern phone but it’s hardly there otherwise. It’s a good compromise. I’d want it myself but I shoot ProRes Video.
Doesn’t like it
I researched this phone, and while being cool (I like the idea), it’s not practical for me to hunt it, it’s not trivial to buy in my area. However, I have a similar idea to others: an old tiny iPhone (4S or 5S if you can survive with the obsolete system, FaceTime and iMessage works there last time I checked, a year or two ago), or SE 1st gen (I use it as my second phone to my 12 mini), which is perfectly usable (Safari is stuck at whatever version it has from iOS 15). It’s not very practical everyday phone, but it works for most tasks, including navigation with maps. So if you’re hunting a small distraction free phone, an obsolete iPhone is a pretty decent thing to buy, and is usually cheap. I bet getting a new battery might be more expensive than the phone itself, unless you’re up to the task (it’s not complicated, if you have the basic instruments). I know it’s the opposite of an open phone with an easily swappable battery, but it’s a decent step into the direction. And I found an old iPhone being very usable for very basic tasks. If I had a Pro Max, I’d surely wasted much more time on it. I know because I had one before.
Neutral
I recently bought an iPhone (Pro Max, on a secondary number) to have one on-hand to better tutor and troubleshoot for my parents. I just had to provide an instance of that this weekend on a phone call. My daily driver is a recent Pixel Pro. If Google takes away the already limited additional flexibility it provides me over an iPhone, I don't see the need to provide them my money nor my attention, going forward. Actually, I've been thinking about carrying some sort of Linux device and relegating the phone to being a hot spot for it, plus traditional calls and texts (and "necessary" apps, I guess). I don't really want to schlep more around with me, but even less so do I want to be squeezed into the box of BigCo corporate approved activities.
Neutral
Yeah absolutely. Every time I’ve been in my local Apple Store, I’ve basically been talked out of purchasing, or it becomes a huge hassle of upselling and extra worrying charges, and quite frankly, stupidity and lack of knowledge from the pseudo-smart staff. All they can do is toe the party line and what they’ve been trained to say and do, which kind of falls apart when faced with someone who has used Apple computers and products for some 25 years now. Most recently I walked in and basically said “I would just like to buy this phone right now” when I wanted an iPhone Pro Max in a rush, and the hassle that I got led to me walking out and going to John Lewis (uk department store) next door, where I said “I would like to buy an iPhone Pro Max” and had one in my hands 90 seconds later and was paying for it, at £60 cheaper than Apple. Apples pricing structure is also annoying nowadays too. As soon as one specs out and bumps a laptop, one suddenly finds that they may as well get a different laptop, ie once you bump up a MacBook Air, you may as well just buy a Pro, until all of a sudden your £999 purchase idea has turned into £3000 and a debate about AppleCare. Ballache.
Doesn’t like it
I've also struggled to install GrapheneOS and Calyx on my iPhone Pro Max. /s (I actually do have both and definitely prefer the Pixel -- especially the cameras on the Pixel are amazing in low light, but it's a bit annoying how the official Gcam app seems to expect that Google photos is installed.) How funny is it that the best way to de-Google is to buy a Google device, and that Apple is incredibly prescriptive about knowing exactly who you are, connecting to wifi, and getting your purchasing on file before you can even get through the initial setup on an iPhone. The one thing I like about iPhone over Android is that the animations are a bit nicer and more polished, and the stock color scheme is pretty bright (but awful at night), and everything else about Android seems to be better.
Doesn’t like it
Apple phones have always been performance competitive with Android phones for quite a few years now, despite using cooling systems that maintain significantly lower wattage. This means that Apple's processors are more efficient than the equivalent Android devices, but their cooling systems are very much critically designed. Rather than decrease the CPU performance, they typically start dimming the screen first. This is extremely frustrating when outside and you need to see something in the sun, if the sun happens to warm up the screen. This is widely regarded as the biggest problem with Apple phones and thermal management. One user on YT who works on commercial HVAC on a roof in AZ, US mentions that Apple phones are unusable because the ambient temperature and sun will cause the phone to shut down and display a overtemp warning without doing anything, while Samsung keeps working. The reason flagship Android devices do not have this problem is twofold: 1) Android device makers use a ton more cooling materials. Large area graphite film layered with a competition driven (among all Chinese manufacturers anyway) almost 70% coverage vapor chamber cooler. Only Samsung lags the industry here. 2) Different trade offs. Android phones typically allow surface temperatures up to 47C for high performance devices, where Apple probably believes users will complain of overheating if the device feels hot, thus targeting 44C. This is the back surface temp, not the chip temp. The stacked main b…
Likes it
Phone manufacturers have tried selling small phones. Sony couldn't make a business of it. Even Apple reportedly can't make it go round. Face it, you're a tiny minority. My wife made fun of my iPhone Pro Max, until she inherited my old one and now she can't go back, it's huge but the screen real estate is really nice to have.
Neutral
I pulled a 5 out of my draw and was pleasantly surprised at the size and feel, but then I actually went to use it and it was quite bad. I wasn’t able to comfortably two hand the phone to type which meant my typing speed was massively reduced. Personally I mostly use my phone two handed so even the pro max is usable even though I can’t reach all areas with one hand.
Likes it
>an iPhone Pro is decidedly a luxury With my ADHD issues, the combination of >The generally long battery of the ProMax in particular (I had issue with my phone dying midday, forgetting to charge) >iOS 15 Focus mode >UWB wireless trackers >The most effective ANC in any wireless headphones >Apple watch for notifications, timers, etc Are all very helpful and the promax is just good for pragmatic and practical reasons. I would definitely say it's a high priced item but I wouldn’t frame it as a luxury. I fundamentally see my phone as assistive technology, it can’t die on me, Apple makes their longest lasting phone their most expensive.