The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs · AMD Radeon

AMD Radeon RX 580

11owners with an opinion
60%of verdicts positive
4/3positive/negative since 2024
1 yrslongest happy owner
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for performance and value; criticized for software and reliability.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 1 year
I actually bought an RX 580 8 GB new for 139 EUR last year (most likely sat around some warehouse in an unopened box for years) - it has no issues running most indie games or even the decently optimized AAA games at 1080p, which was an upgrade over my previous RX 570 4 GB. The only actual issues I ran into were when I tried running it for PCVR (Quest 2) because the latest drivers actually cause crashes and instability, although I could fix that by rolling back to either the 2020 or 2022 drivers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38870500 Sometimes hardware from generations ago is not only decently affordable, but also sufficient for what you want to do, as long as your standards aren't super high. Getting some of that hardware with no previous owners also feels a bit interesting, albeit I've also bought used CPUs off of AliExpress for my homelab servers with no issues either.
Doesn’t like it
This is a really good card that keeps on getting better. After my steam deck battery puffed up and my RX580 became too old to play any modern games, I had two choices: 1. Upgrade to a new GPU - this was costing me $300 at the very least for a 3 year old card 2. Hope to get a steam machine - but the crazy queue and the $1000 price tag really soured me on this 3. Get a bc-250 for $150 and make do for a year or two before upgrading. I'm so glad I went with this option. I just used my old atx power supply and old PC case. Everything almost just works. It consumes lot less power than my previous gaming PC. It's a lot more silent. Some times there's a crash or two. I'm waiting to upgrade the power connector before unlocking it's full potential (40 compute units, and the two extra cores). So far I've finished playing Spider-Man 2, Hogwarts legacy, now playing 007 first light.
Likes it
Wait are you me? i shut down my z800 about a year ago (was my mainmachine for about 13 years) i buyd a second cpu for like 10$ after 5 years and upraded the ram to max, i think it was 46gb, also ssd's....and a rx580 which is still in use.
Doesn’t like it
I will say AMD seems to have come a long way since 2020/2021. I also messed around with an RX580 and ROCm on Ubuntu Server and while I wasn’t as experienced in the world of ML/Data Science then, I remember encountering a roadblock or two when following the official install guide. I haven’t had an AMD GPU since, but I’ve read and heard many good things. Supposedly Tensorflow and PyTorch work more or less out of the box with the right AMD GPU.
Likes it
> Hah, you really did the VM thing? A lot of people have suggested that to me but I didn't think it'd actually work. Pretty cool! Another data point that it is indeed possible. I had a dual Xeon E5-2690 v2 setup with two RX 580 8GB cards passed through to separate VMs, and with memory and CPU pinning it was a surprisingly resilient setup. 150+ FPS in CSGO with decent 1% lows (like 120 if I remember correctly?) which was fine since I only had 60Hz monitors. I have a Threadripper workstation now, I should test out to see what kind of performance I can get out of that for VM gaming... > Yeah I could get higher-quality 10G cards and put them in all the machines but they seem expensive... I have had very good luck with Intel X540 cards. $20-40 on eBay, and there’s hundreds (if not thousands) available. They’re plug-and-play on any modern Linux, but need an Intel driver on windows if I remember correctly. I’ve never had one die and I’ve never experienced a crash or network dropout in the 9 years I’ve been running them. The Marvell chipset just seems terrible, unfortunately - I’ve had problems with it on multiple different cards and motherboards on every OS under the sun.
Neutral
In your case, with an RX 590, do NOT buy an expensive x3D processor expecting any improvement. I upgraded from an RX580 (using an original HTC Vive) to an RX 5700xt (and a valve Index) and that's the position you are in. You cannot drive a high pixel density VR headset with a Mid tier GPU from 8 years ago. Get something that is at least as powerful as that RX 5700xt I had (I now have a 4070 super) and you will be satisfied. It drove my Index at 90hz.
Doesn’t like it
I recently had issues with AMD's RX580 GPU, where the latest drivers would cause issues for me when trying to run VR games with an Oculus Quest (either SteamVR or the Meta OpenXR implementation). I'd play the game for about 10-40 minutes and then it would crash, the drivers would reset, the screen would go black in the middle for a bit and the OS would make an attempt to recover (which didn't always work). In the end, turns out that the version of AMD Software and their included drivers from 2023 didn't work and I had to revert to an older version. I ended up going for their 2020 AMD Pro drivers and software because the card is from 2018 and the improvement was immediate - I haven't had a single crash since, whereas previously I could reproduce it 100% of the time, with only the time before the crash varying. Note: this is on Windows 10, which I boot into for gaming, though I actually like their AMD Software which feels a bit better than CoreCtrl on Linux distros. Some people suggested that 2022 drivers/software would also work, but this is one of those cases where the hardware technically gets updates, but they actually make things worse, perhaps because the older hardware is not tested against as much, especially with newer games and programs. I don't necessarily expect anyone to care that much about hardware from 2018, it was just an interesting case of things going wrong. Overall, I like AMD because they're affordable (still running a Ryzen 7 1700 CPU on my main workstati…
Likes it
I am running an i5-2500k from 2011 as my desktop. Just dropped an rx580 in as my graphics card, and it's running great for my light gaming purposes (overwatch, 1080x60 screen). I think I could get away using it for 1440 or 1080x120 pretty comfortably.
Doesn’t like itHasn’t owned it
For some reason AMD's GPU division continues to be run, well, horribly. The CPU division is crushing it, but the GPU division is comically bad. During the great GPU shortage AMD had multiple opportunities to capture chunks of the market and secure market share, increasing the priority for developers to acknowledge and target AMD's GPUs. What did they do instead? Not a goddamn thing, they followed Nvidia's pricing and managed to sell jack shit (like seriously the RX 580 is still the first AMD card to show up on the steam hardware survey). They're not going big enough dies at the top end to compete with nvidia for the halo, and they're refusing to undercut at the low end where nvidia's reputation for absurd pricing is at an all time high. AMD's GPU division is a clown show, it's impressively bad. Even though the hardware itself is fine they just can't stop either making terrible product launches, awful pricing strategies, or just brain dead software choices like shipping a feature that triggered anti-cheat, getting their customers predictably banned & angering game devs in the process And relevant to this discussion Nvidia's refusal to add VRAM to their lower end cards is a prime opportunity for AMD to go after the lower-end compute / AI interested crowd who will become the next generation software devs. What are they doing with this? Well, they're not making ROCm available to basically anyone, that's apparently the winning strategy. ROCm 6.0 only supports the 7900 XTX and th…